Watauga County, three towns ask N.C. Supreme Court to reject Boone’s tax challenge | Eastern North Carolina Now

Watauga County and three of its towns want the N.C. Supreme Court to reject a lawsuit from Boone. That town challenges Watauga's system for splitting local sales tax revenue.

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Watauga County and three of its towns urge the N.C. Supreme Court to reject Boone's request to take up a dispute involving local sales taxes.

    Boone is trying to drag the state's highest court into a "messy, local political squabble," according to a document filed Tuesday with the state's highest court.

    "This lawsuit by the Town of Boone and one of its residents alleges in sensationalistic fashion that Watauga County and the Towns of Beech Mountain, Blowing Rock, and Seven Devils engaged in an 'illegal sales tax distribution scheme,'" according to the court filing. "The reality, however, as the complaint reveals, is that this case amounts to a local political debate going back 35 years."

    The dispute focuses on Watauga County commissioners' decision about whether to split local sales tax revenue on a "per capita" basis focusing on population or an "ad valorem" basis focusing on local tax values. State law gives counties the choice of either option.

    "As the Plaintiffs acknowledged in their complaint, Watauga County's decision of which distribution method to adopt has been the subject of political discourse for decades," according to the filing from Watauga County, Beech Mountain, Blowing Rock, and Seven Devils. "From 1987 until 2013, Watauga County chose the per capita method. During these years, Beech Mountain and Blowing Rock 'petitioned the Watauga County Commissioners on several occasions to change the local sales tax distribution to the ad valorem method,' because it would 'greatly benefit those communities.' But they were unsuccessful. So for 25 years, Beech Mountain and Blowing Rock lost the political debate, while Boone repeatedly emerged as the political winner."

    "In 2013, however, the County decided that it was time for other municipalities in Watauga County to enjoy the benefits that Boone had enjoyed for so long, and it changed the method of distribution to ad valorem," the filing continued. "Significantly, the County's decision meant that those benefits would extend to the County's local fire districts, which do not receive sales tax allocations under the per capita method but do receive distributions under the ad valorem method - a worthy cause that the County considered in its legislative judgment. ... So after 25 years of the local fire districts getting nothing, the Watauga County Commissioners in their legislative discretion decided that their local fire districts should receive some distributions, too."

    Watauga and the three towns contend Boone was "[f]rustrated that its 25-year streak as the political winner had come to an end." After failing to reverse county commissioners' decision, Boone took the issue to court.

    "To be sure, 'local political squabbles' - in particular, 'messy' ones - are meant to be resolved at the ballot box, not in a courtroom," according to Tuesday's filing. "When Boone failed in its attempts at political persuasion, however, it left its ballot-box remedy behind, and, instead, sought to foist this 'messy, local political squabble' on the judicial branch."

    Watauga County and the three towns also accuse Boone of violating legal rules. Boone changed its arguments from the trial court level when it took its lawsuit to the N.C. Court of Appeals, according to Tuesday's filing. A unanimous three-judge appellate panel rejected Boone's case.

    The latest court filing arrives two weeks after Boone filed paperwork asking the Supreme Court to take the case.

    Boone argues that county commissioners adopted an illegal "kickback system" in 2013 that costs Boone $2 million each year.

    "This case raises the question whether any town or taxpayer can question county and municipal misconduct when the violations of law are causing millions of dollars of damage," wrote attorneys representing Boone and resident Marshall Ashcraft.

    Boone contends that the system in place since 2013 amounts to neither a "per capita" nor an "ad valorem" system. Instead, Boone argues that the three other towns surrender to the county government some of the gains they would make under an "ad valorem" system. Boone contends that the arrangement violates state law.

    There is no deadline for the state Supreme Court to decide whether to take the case.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Aetna awarded State Health Plan contract, ousting Blue Cross Blue Shield NC Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal State fights lawsuits involving school bus accidents during COVID-19 meal deliveries


Latest State and Federal

Approximately 6,800 people in North Carolina have sickle cell disease, of which approximately 95% are Black or African American.
President Joe Biden delivered remarks on Tuesday at gun control advocacy group Everytown’s annual conference, Gun Sense University — and as is often the case when Biden speaks about guns, critics were quick to point out a series of factual errors.
Democrat strategist James Carville raged against the legacy media this week, demanding that they take an even more biased approach when reporting on former President Donald Trump.
Republican congressman Byron Donalds said it would be a “great honor” if former President Donald Trump were to ask him to be his running-mate for 2024, saying the ultimate goal is for Trump to win and he’ll do whatever he’s asked to help him do that.
Voters in Arizona will have the opportunity to enact broad border security measures in November as the state faces a flood of illegal immigration after the Republican-led state legislature passed a resolution that will put the measures on the general election ballot.
The former White House physician for Presidents Barack Obama and Donald Trump says that a new report this week about how President Joe Biden is struggling to function behind closed doors represents a serious threat to the U.S.


The Tikva Forum for Families of Hostages, an Israeli group created to represent the families of those taken during Hamas’ October 7 terrorist attack, urged President Joe Biden to stop interfering with Israel’s campaign to destroy the terrorist group.
After saying the six-foot social distancing guideline during the COVID-19 pandemic “sort of just appeared,” Dr. Anthony Fauci on Monday testified that his statement had been “distorted” and that it “actually” came from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
The state Supreme Court has agreed to hear one of two pending cases involving North Carolina bar owners challenging Gov. Roy Cooper's COVID-related shutdowns in 2020.
The Biden administration canceled over 350,000 asylum cases, allowing migrants to stay in the United States indefinitely in a move that experts called “mass amnesty.”
Former White House medical advisor Anthony Fauci changed his view of COVID vaccines from 2021 to 2024, clips show.
The Department of Justice announced on Friday that 75-year-old Paula Paulette Harlow was sentenced to two years in prison for violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act by taking part in a “conspiracy” to block pregnant women from entering an abortion clinic in Washington, D.C.


A GOP-led House panel is seeking access to Dr. Anthoni Fauci‘s personal email accounts and cell phone records as part of an investigation into the origins of COVID-19.


Back to Top