NC Supreme Court hears arguments in Ace Speedway case

Latest Polls (view all)

Since the Democratic Socialist campaign message has been that the Republican nominee, "Donald Trump is a threat to Democracy," is it not exceedingly ironic that the leadership of the Democratic Socialist party is endeavoring to remove their presumptive nominee - Joseph R. Biden, though elected - as their candidate for the presidency of the United States?

11.11% The Democratic Socialists reserve the right to always be incredibly flexible in all matters pertaining to communicated core ideals.

88.89% The Democratic Socialists are long on hyperbolic promise, but way short on purposeful performance, ergo, they are grand hypocrites of the first order.

0% None of this really matters.

Click Here to Vote
9 Vote(s)

View all Polls

NC Supreme Court hears arguments in Ace Speedway case

Published: Friday, March 29th, 2024 @ 4:41 pm
By: Carolina Journal ( More Entries )

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is Theresa Opeka.

    The North Carolina Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday in the case of an Alamance County racetrack that was forced to shut down during the pandemic.

    In June 2020, Ace Speedway was shut down indefinitely by former N.C. Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Mandy Cohen, who now serves as director for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

    Cohen went to court to secure a preliminary injunction enforcing her "order of abatement." She later dropped her legal complaint in September 2020, but racetrack owners continued to pursue their counterclaims challenging Cohen's shutdown and are seeking to recoup some of the losses they incurred during that time.

    State Solicitor General Ryan Park started the proceedings by saying how the world was thrust into a crisis during the spring and summer of 2020 with the COVID-19 pandemic, and elected officials, from then President Donald Trump to Democrat Gov. Roy Cooper, were forced to make a series of "excruciating" decisions based on the best available information between saving lives and preserving the healthcare system, temporarily restricting economic and other social activities.

    "One of those decisions was the secretary's choice to issue an abatement order, pausing Ace Speedway 's ability to host what were at the time some of the largest mass gatherings occurring anywhere in the country, which would have been illegal virtually anywhere in the country, including under similar executive orders issued by all of our neighbors, Georgia, South Carolina, Virginia, and Kentucky," he said.

    Justice Trey Allen raised concerns about the abatement order, which he says repeatedly references the governor's emergency order. Under the Emergency Management Act, he said an enforcement provision states that the violation of an emergency order is a crime, and there is no civil enforcement mechanism.

    "So, I have a concern that the order of abatement is essentially an attempt to enforce the governor's order through some civil mechanism, even though the legislature didn't give the governor the authority to enforce this order civilly," he said.

    Allen later mentioned a statute that gives municipalities the power to enforce ordinances, which includes a provision that allows criminal enforcement and a set of civil mechanisms that local governments can use.

    "I don't see that in the Emergency Management Act, and so, therefore, I have a concern that the legislature made a decision to limit the means of enforcement and that the abatement order is, to some extent, an effort to circumvent that limitation," he said.

    Justice Richard Dietz also had concerns about the situation since racetrack owners spoke out against Cooper because they resisted his order, essentially embarrassing him, which Dietz said led Cooper to order the government to target Ace Speedway and shut it down, even though there were other similar businesses engaged in the same sort of conduct that went unregulated.

    "What's going on here is you have government officials who are petty and say this particular business is standing up and others are not," he said. "We want you to single them out, let's target them, let's punish this business and make a point, and what I'm saying is if there are facts that could prove that that's correct, why wouldn't that be enough to prove that what action they (the government) took was not reasonably necessary to promote some public good in this particular circumstance?"

    Chuck Kitchen, attorney for Ace Speedway, agreed with Dietz that the racetrack was targeted for defying Cooper's order to shut down.

    "The governor actually sent letters to the board of commissioners and to the sheriff saying go shut down Ace Speedway, and the sheriff said no, I'm not gonna do it," he said. "He went out and talked to them, but he said no, I'm not going to do it. So, what did the state do? They said we're gonna go and issue an abatement order. We're going to do a civil remedy to shut you down for violating my executive order."

    Justice Anita Earls pushed back at Kitchen.

    "So, you're saying that even if there was a public health problem with people gathering in these numbers, the state could not protect the public by stopping the gathering? The state could only criminally punish whoever is responsible for holding the event?" Kitchen replied no.

    A decision on the case should be forthcoming in the months ahead.

    In August 2022, a unanimous N.C. Court of Appeals panel ruled that Ace Speedway could move forward with a lawsuit against the state's top health official. By that time, Cohen had left DHHS. The suit continued against current Secretary Kody Kinsley. The state Supreme Court agreed in March to hear Kinsley's appeal of appellate judges' ruling.

    The brief recounts key details of the Ace Speedway shutdown. The track has a seating capacity of 5,000 spectators. Owners said they needed 1,000 paying customers at each race to break even. On May 23, 2020, the speedway conducted a race with 2,550 spectators. Two other races took place over the next two weeks - with attendance of 1,600 and 1,200 - before Cohen blocked further track operations.

    Ace had consulted with the Alamance County health director, the local sheriff, and others before developing a plan to operate races while addressing concerns about COVID-19.

Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias

Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)

Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Login to Leave a Comment

Stretch of Blue Ridge Parkway closed over bear concerns Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal State Supreme Court to decide whether speedy trial violation could lead to money damages

Latest State and Federal

Russia Sentences WSJ Reporter Evan Gershkovich To 16 Years In Penal Colony

On Friday, in a case that the United States government and his employer have denounced as a sham, a Russian court found Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, the first U.S. journalist to face such a charge since Nicholas Daniloff in 1986, guilty of espionage

Published: Thursday, July 25th, 2024 @ 2:46 am By: Daily Wire

J.D. Vance Celebrated As ‘One Of The Best’ Senators On Immigration

"The largest deportation effort in American history is going to have one hell of a co-pilot," one organization exclaimed.

Published: Tuesday, July 23rd, 2024 @ 5:15 pm By: Daily Wire

Governor Cooper Names Julia White Chief of Staff

Chief of Staff Kristi Jones to Depart for Private Sector Opportunity

Published: Monday, July 22nd, 2024 @ 11:21 am By: Governor's Office

Trump Again Addresses ‘Project 2025,’ Says Dems Are Engaging In ‘Pure Disinformation’

Former President Donald Trump once again addressed the proposed transition policies in the Heritage Foundation’s “Project 2025,” saying in a social media post on Wednesday night that Democrats are trying to deceptively “hook” him with those proposals.

Published: Monday, July 22nd, 2024 @ 3:03 am By: Daily Wire

Ramaswamy Says He Would ‘Strongly Consider’ Replacing Vance As Senator If Asked

Biotech entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy told The Daily Wire on Monday that he would “strongly consider” replacing J.D. Vance as U.S. senator from Ohio now that former President Donald Trump has picked Vance to be his running mate for the 2024 election.

Published: Saturday, July 20th, 2024 @ 9:46 am By: Daily Wire

NC city tops “best for veterans” list for second year in a row

For the second year in a row, Raleigh was ranked as the overall best place for veterans to live in the United States, according to a WalletHub report. Charlotte, Durham, Greensboro, and Winston-Salem came in 26th, 35th, 48th, and 51st overall, respectively.

Published: Saturday, July 20th, 2024 @ 9:44 am By: Carolina Journal

‘The Gunman And The Would-Be Dictator’: The Atlantic Says Trump ‘Had It Coming’ Less Than 24 Hours After Assassination Attempt

Less than 24 hours after a failed assassination attempt against former President Donald Trump — which left one bystander dead and three others, including Trump, injured — The Atlantic’s David Frum blamed the violence on the former president and his supporters.

Published: Friday, July 19th, 2024 @ 3:35 pm By: Daily Wire

Biden’s Team Suggests Biden Has More Stamina Than George Clooney After Clooney Calls On Him To Drop Out

The Biden campaign fired back at actor George Clooney on Wednesday after Clooney called for President Joe Biden to drop out of the presidential race, suggesting that the 81-year-old president has better stamina than Clooney.

Published: Friday, July 19th, 2024 @ 3:10 pm By: Daily Wire

Ray Epps: Tucker Carlson Is ‘Obsessed With Me,’ GOP Lawmakers Had Bigger ‘Impact’ On Riot Than Me

Ray Epps, the man accused by many of being involved with federal law enforcement during the January 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capitol, said over the weekend that Fox News host Tucker Carlson was “obsessed” with him and trying to ruin his life.

Published: Friday, July 19th, 2024 @ 2:19 pm By: Daily Wire

Our Members

ENCN Sign Up

BCN Home

Beaufort Observer

Portfolios

Current Events: A Historical Perspective

Current Weather

Latest Comments

Latest Polls

Featured Entries

Latest Entries

Advertisement

Local News & Expression

Calf Creek Preserve Exposition: July, 2024 Edition, Volume One - Tract S, Lot #10 Hillcrest

Severe Weather Briefing 7/18/2024

Our Founding Principles: The Beginning of the American "Experiment"

The Declaration of Independence: Thirteen Colonies Yearning to Be Free

Independence Day

All Latest Entries

Advertisement

Weather (7 day forcast)

Washington, NC, USA

Advertisement

Categories (view all)

Across North Carolina

Body & Soul

Business

Community

Current Events: A Historical Perspective

Government

Local Governments

Local News & Expression

Memorial

NativeFront

Op-Ed & Politics

Sports

The Arts

The Region

The Studio

Advertisement

Resources & Services

Local Gas Prices Check out our list of local gas prices for Washington, Greenville, and Chocowinity

Popular Articles Check out our top entries for the latest two months.

Symbiotic Networks Custom web design, online marketing/advertising, programming, and web development projects.

Advertisement

NC Supreme Court hears arguments in Ace Speedway case | Eastern North Carolina Now

NC Supreme Court hears arguments in Ace Speedway case

Leave a Guest Comment