Among conservative legal s;cholats, "originalism" staying true to the intent of the drafters of the Constitution and its amendments, is the most fundamental consideration in interpreting them. Liberals prefer to twist meanings to get whatever result they want at the moment. This will be the key battle in the Supreme Court over President Trump's executive order ending "birthright citizenship".
Most developed countries in the world base citizenship on the nationality of the parents, not on where the child happens to be born. President Trump's EO follows that theory of citizenship.
The issue before the Supreme Court turns on the meaning of the words "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" in the 14th Amendment's citizenship clause. After its adoption, the Supreme Court heard a case on the issue of whether American Indians were US citizens under the 14th amendment or not. The court held that since Indians were subject to the jurisdiction of their tribal governments which were treated as nations, that the 14th amendment did not make them citizens of the US. Congress had to pass legislation to make them citizens.
Most important in the present case is that more research into the positions of the authors of the 14th amendment clearly shows that they did not intend to give citizenship to children of foreign citizens just because they happened to be born in the United States. Tis was clearly stated in both the House and Senate while the 14th amendment was under consideration and no member at the time even suggested otherwise.
The majority on our Supreme Court claims to be originalists. This case will be test to see if they really are. One has to be concerned about weak kneeded members like John Roberts and Amy Comey Barrett.
The Wall Street Journal has a great opinion piece on the subject:
https://www.wsj.com/opinion/trump-is-right-on-birthright-citizenship-954ae377?st=tWd4Ha
Other good articles:
https://www.zerohedge.com/political/restoring-meaning-american-citizenship
|
|
borderhawk said:
( April 3rd, 2026 @ 11:04 am )
This is one of the most critical decisions ever to come before the court, and I worry that the court is too full of legal midgets.
|
|
Roberts comments during oral arguments in this case point to his being a total sellout, another Earl Warren, a total spineless traitorous twit. He is almost certain to backstab us as he has often done while chief justice. Amy Comey Barrett, another all too frequent sell out also sounded very weak. Without one of them our Constitution will be permanently compromised by birthright citizenship that its authors never intended.
|
|
now Democrats are reluctant to give Trump DOT the $50 Billion needed to fix it
Published: Wednesday, November 18th, 2026 @ 5:34 pm
By: John Steed
|
|
democrats plan communist take over
Published: Wednesday, November 18th, 2026 @ 5:15 pm
By: Countrygirl1411
|
|
"Criticizing Islamism is neither Islamophobic nor racist."
Published: Wednesday, November 18th, 2026 @ 2:42 pm
By: Daily Wire
|
|
most of them entered country illegally
Published: Wednesday, November 18th, 2026 @ 1:00 pm
By: John Steed
|
|
American voters got played
Published: Wednesday, November 18th, 2026 @ 10:03 am
By: John Steed
|
|
and too many lemmings follow along
Published: Tuesday, November 17th, 2026 @ 4:38 pm
By: John Steed
|
|
Democrats want this in the US
Published: Tuesday, November 17th, 2026 @ 11:14 am
By: John Steed
|
|
by Rev. Mark Creech
Published: Monday, November 16th, 2026 @ 3:41 pm
By: Countrygirl1411
|
|
they are in hock to the radical teachers unions
Published: Monday, November 16th, 2026 @ 9:30 am
By: John Steed
|
|
Democrats want to make government less affordable to citizens
Published: Monday, November 16th, 2026 @ 9:12 am
By: John Steed
|
|
by Rev. Mark Creech
Published: Sunday, November 15th, 2026 @ 3:25 pm
By: Countrygirl1411
|
|
Tillis and Cornyn may help Dems block GOP appointments
Published: Sunday, November 15th, 2026 @ 3:15 pm
By: John Steed
|
|
Film critic Tyler Smith builds a streaming platform after suffering a horrifying illness.
Published: Sunday, November 15th, 2026 @ 1:37 pm
By: Daily Wire
|
|
they are breaking Mexican immigration laws, too
Published: Sunday, November 15th, 2026 @ 9:22 am
By: John Steed
|
|
Islamists threaten rape and murder police do nothing
Published: Saturday, November 14th, 2026 @ 5:30 pm
By: Countrygirl1411
|
|
yet the Democrats want to saddle our taxpayers and our economy with this madness
Published: Saturday, November 14th, 2026 @ 11:14 am
By: John Steed
|
|
as Democrat politicians try to destroy our health care system
Published: Friday, November 13th, 2026 @ 8:00 pm
By: John Steed
|
|
This is the opposite of "affordability"
Published: Friday, November 13th, 2026 @ 12:14 pm
By: John Steed
|
|
by Rev. Mark Creech
Published: Friday, November 13th, 2026 @ 10:09 am
By: Countrygirl1411
|
|
Discrimination, Exclusion, and Indoctrination (DEI) is in Democrats plans
Published: Friday, November 13th, 2026 @ 8:59 am
By: John Steed
|
|
as DSA and others push for even more leftwing speaker
Published: Thursday, November 12th, 2026 @ 5:01 pm
By: John Steed
|
|
Democrat politicians are one of the biggest threats to democracy
Published: Thursday, November 12th, 2026 @ 3:38 pm
By: John Steed
|
|
the answer appears to be YES
Published: Thursday, November 12th, 2026 @ 9:36 am
By: John Steed
|
|
the REAL Democrat Party reveals itself
Published: Thursday, November 12th, 2026 @ 9:02 am
By: John Steed
|
|
by Rev. Mark Creech
Published: Thursday, November 12th, 2026 @ 5:25 am
By: Countrygirl1411
|
|
recount almost certain
Published: Wednesday, November 11th, 2026 @ 11:05 am
By: John Steed
|