Gmail more likely to flag Republican fundraising emails as spam, study finds | Beaufort County Now | A study from researchers at N.C. State University finds that Gmail marked 59% more fundraising emails as spam than Democratic ones during the 2020 election.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is David Bass.

    A study from researchers at N.C. State University finds that Gmail marked 59% more fundraising emails as spam than Democratic ones during the 2020 election.

    Researchers examined more than 100 accounts and 318,000 emails for Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo Mail from May through November 2020. The emails came from the campaigns of both presidential candidates plus 78 Senate candidates and 156 House candidates from both political parties.

    "We observed that the [spam filtering algorithms] of different email services indeed exhibit biases towards different political affiliations," the researchers concluded. They noted that none of the three email platforms provide "any transparency on their internal workings," and that a "growing body of evidence suggests that the biases in online algorithms can influence undecided voters."

    In contrast to Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo Mail were 20% and 14%, respectively, more likely to snag Democratic emails and send them to users' spam folders.

    Gmail has an estimated 1.5 billion users globally, while Outlook has 400 million and Yahoo Mail 225 million.

    "Research has long shown that there are biases, explicit or implicit, in the algorithms tech companies employ," noted Dr. Andy Jackson, director of the Civitas Center for Public Integrity at the John Locke Foundation.

    While Yahoo Mail and Outlook were slightly friendlier to right-wing candidates, Gmail "retained the majority of left-wing candidate emails in inbox ([less than] 10.12% marked as spam) while sent the majority of right-wing candidate emails to the spam folder (up to 77.2% marked as spam). We further observed that the percentage of emails marked by Gmail as spam from the right-wing candidates grew steadily as the election date approached while the percentage of emails marked as spam from left-wing candidates remained about the same."

    "As these prominent email services are actively used by a sizable chunk of voting population and as many of the voters today rely on the information they see (or don't see) online, such biases may have an unignorable impact on the outcomes of an election," the authors added. "It is imperative for the email services to audit their [spam filtering algorithms] to ensure that any properties of the sender that they consider in determining whether any given email is spam or not are not, unknowingly, putting one side at an advantage compared to the other."

    A spokesperson for Google issued a statement saying, "Political affiliation has absolutely no bearing on mail classifications in Gmail and we've debunked this suggestion, which has surfaced periodically from across the political spectrum, for many years ... Mail classifications in Gmail automatically adjust to match users' preference and actions. Gmail users can move messages to spam, or to any other category. Gmail automatically adjusts the classifications of particular emails according to these user accounts."

    "The NCSU researchers found that demographic factors such as age, ethnicity, and sex, had no relationship to the rate at which political emails from the left or right were caught in spam filters," said Jackson. "Since those demographic factors are correlated with political views, they should have been related to the rate political emails are marked as spam if it is just a matter of email providers responding to user interactions with political emails."
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Local introvert Esther Leigh surprised her husband of ten years Thursday by sitting him down and explaining that he'd been mispronouncing her name this whole time.
The National Football League (NFL) faced backlash on Wednesday afternoon over a map it published that showed Taiwan belonging to China.
Biden tried to warn us. He's been sounding the alarm for weeks now, desperately trying to alert the nation to a grave threat to our national security: ULTRA MAGA.
U.S. Senate candidate Dr. Mehmet Oz, who is running as a Republican in Pennsylvania, was grilled by Fox News “Primetime” host Will Cain on Wednesday on issues that matter most to conservative voters, including guns and abortion.
Tomorrow will mark 75 years since the first race at North Wilkesboro Speedway on May 18, 1947, and on the eve of that historic day, Governor Roy Cooper visited the speedway to highlight the significant investments it will receive for repairs.
Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas triggered laughs from his audience when he uttered a terse statement regarding the way those in the media do their job.
A tale of two Sandys has come to an end as previous GOP nominee Sandy Smith has won over Rocky Mount Mayor Sandy Roberson in North Carolina’s 1st Congressional District GOP primary race.
Last week, the North Carolina State Board of Education approved a request to begin drafting new science and healthful living standards for public schools.

HbAD1

On Sunday, in the wake of a second female teammate of University of Pennsylvania of transgender swimmer Lia Thomas coming forward to delineate the emotional devastation wrought by Thomas on the women of the university’s swimming team
It's important for kids to read because it nurtures their imagination and will help them understand important concepts like the political background in the world of Dune—or why socialism fails every time it's tried.
expensive and unreliable wind and solar soak ratepayers

HbAD2

 
Back to Top