Blue Cross NC formally protests award of State Health Plan contract | Eastern North Carolina Now

On Thursday, Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina (BCBSNC) submitted a 14-page formal protest to Sam Watts, acting administrator of the State Health Plan, opposing the award of the plan’s 2025-27 third-party administrator contract to Aetna.

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    On Thursday, Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina (BCBSNC) submitted a 14-page formal protest to Sam Watts, acting administrator of the State Health Plan, opposing the award of the plan's 2025-27 third-party administrator contract to Aetna. BCBSNC held that contract for more than 40 years.

    In a letter accompanying the protest, BCBSNC asked that the State Health Plan either cancel its award of the contract to Aetna and instead award it to BCBSNC, or vacate the decision and start over with a new request-for-proposal process.

    In August, the State Health Plan issued an RFP for the third-party administrator of the plan and down-selected candidates to three possible vendors who met minimum requirements; Aetna, BCBSNC, and United Healthcare. From there, the three candidates submitted full proposals for evaluation by the SHP Board of Trustees. On Dec. 22, State Treasurer Dale Folwell announced that Aetna won the contract.

    Saying that the proposal evaluations were based on "arbitrary criteria and a distorted scoring system," BCBSNC's objections to the award centered on changes to the evaluation criteria since the 2019 RFP cycle. According to the submission Thursday, cost criteria changed from a 10,000-point scale to a 10-point scale. For the 310 technical questions in the RFP, answers could only be "yes/no." According to the protest, bidders were not allowed to submit narrative answers in 2022, as they were in 2019.

    In a December debrief, BCBSNC was informed its RFP was awarded 303 points for technical requirements, while Aetna and United Healthcare got 310. BCBSNC also said that its network of providers is 38% larger than that of Aetna in North Carolina.

    "The Plan took a complex decision - selecting the third-party administrator for a health plan that covers hundreds of thousands of North Carolinians - and tried to turn it into a checklist. That approach ignored critical issues that will affect the welfare of the State and the welfare of the Plan's members," BCBSNC wrote in the protest.

    BCBSNC also took issue with Folwell's description of the third-party administrator contract as a "back-office" role. North Carolina's State Health Plan for Employees is self-funded and serves more than 700,000 state employees and retirees.

    "The Plan's third-party administration is not a back-office function. Instead, the third-party administrator has responsibilities that play a central role in defining member benefits. The administrator must also deliver a provider network with the strength, depth, and reach to offer high-quality, accessible health care to Plan members."

    "We welcome the opportunity to engage in a factual, thoughtful, and transparent review of the State Health Plan's contracting process for third-party administration services going into effect two years from now," Folwell said in a prepared statement responding to the BCBSNC protest. "Just like Blue Cross Blue Shield of North Carolina has the right to point fingers at everyone else for losing the contract after 44 years, the State Health Plan, Board of Trustees, professional staff, and I all have a duty to seek the best financial value and member service for those that teach, protect, and serve as well as taxpayers like them."

    In the formal protest, BCBSNC also points out that the contract was awarded on Dec. 14, and on Dec. 15 and Dec. 20 the company submitted public records requests regarding the award process and has not yet received documents.

    "Blue Cross NC is proud of our long record of serving North Carolina's teachers, state employees, first responders, county and city employees, and their families," said Dr. Tunde Sotunde, president and CEO of Blue Cross NC. "State Health Plan members are more than customers, they are our neighbors, our friends, and our family, and we have filed this protest to ensure the best outcome for them, for taxpayers, and for our state."
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

NC Medical Board audit raises patient safety concerns Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Cooper bans TikTok, WeChat on state government devices


Latest State and Federal

Democrat strategist James Carville raged against the legacy media this week, demanding that they take an even more biased approach when reporting on former President Donald Trump.
Republican congressman Byron Donalds said it would be a “great honor” if former President Donald Trump were to ask him to be his running-mate for 2024, saying the ultimate goal is for Trump to win and he’ll do whatever he’s asked to help him do that.
Voters in Arizona will have the opportunity to enact broad border security measures in November as the state faces a flood of illegal immigration after the Republican-led state legislature passed a resolution that will put the measures on the general election ballot.
The former White House physician for Presidents Barack Obama and Donald Trump says that a new report this week about how President Joe Biden is struggling to function behind closed doors represents a serious threat to the U.S.
The Tikva Forum for Families of Hostages, an Israeli group created to represent the families of those taken during Hamas’ October 7 terrorist attack, urged President Joe Biden to stop interfering with Israel’s campaign to destroy the terrorist group.
After saying the six-foot social distancing guideline during the COVID-19 pandemic “sort of just appeared,” Dr. Anthony Fauci on Monday testified that his statement had been “distorted” and that it “actually” came from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
The state Supreme Court has agreed to hear one of two pending cases involving North Carolina bar owners challenging Gov. Roy Cooper's COVID-related shutdowns in 2020.
The Biden administration canceled over 350,000 asylum cases, allowing migrants to stay in the United States indefinitely in a move that experts called “mass amnesty.”
Former White House medical advisor Anthony Fauci changed his view of COVID vaccines from 2021 to 2024, clips show.


The Department of Justice announced on Friday that 75-year-old Paula Paulette Harlow was sentenced to two years in prison for violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act by taking part in a “conspiracy” to block pregnant women from entering an abortion clinic in Washington, D.C.
A GOP-led House panel is seeking access to Dr. Anthoni Fauci‘s personal email accounts and cell phone records as part of an investigation into the origins of COVID-19.
Former President Donald Trump is considering having Tesla CEO Elon Musk serve in an advisory role if Trump reclaims the White House, according to a new report.
On Tuesday, special counsel Jack Smith‘s bid for a gag order against former President Donald Trump in his classified documents case got rejected by the presiding federal judge in Florida.
On Thursday, the GOP-led House passed a bill that pressures the Biden administration not to withhold arms from Israel as the U.S. ally fights Iran-backed Hamas following a deadly terrorist attack in October of last year.
The Islamic Republic of Iran’s president and foreign minister and other officials have been confirmed dead after a helicopter crash on Sunday while they were traveling in the eastern part of the country, according to Iranian state media.
President Joe Biden challenged former president Donald Trump to debates last week because Biden needs to swivel the political spotlight away from his record ahead of the election, according to Daily Wire editor emeritus Ben Shapiro.
The 2024 second primary election will be held statewide on Tuesday, May 14, 2024. In-person early voting ends at 3 p.m. Saturday, May 11, in all 100 counties.


Back to Top