Federal Appeals Court revives Charlotte driver’s lawsuit against city on technical issue | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has thrown out a lower court ruling favoring Charlotte in a dispute over drivers' privacy. Appellate judges ruled that the trial judge failed to address whether his court had a right to hear the case.

    Plaintiff Jonathan Hensley argues that the city violated the federal Driver's Privacy Protection Act of 1994. "Because the district court ruled on the merits of Hensley's claims without first resolving the City's jurisdictional challenge, we vacate the district court's judgment and remand for further proceedings," wrote Judge Pamela Harris for the unanimous court.

    The suit, filed on behalf of Hensley "and a putative class of similarly situated plaintiffs," alleges that Charlotte "routinely" violated the 1994 law. "According to Hensley, the City knowingly disclosed to the public personal information from motor vehicle records - specifically, accident reports - used by personal injury lawyers to solicit motorists involved in accidents."

    Hensley cited a city contract with the LexisNexis website and a policy allowing public access to the records "over the counter" at the police department's records division. "After the City made his own accident report available to the public, Hensley claims, he himself received targeted mail solicitations from personal injury lawyers," Harris wrote.

    Charlotte argued that Hensley lacked legal standing to bring his suit. "Hensley could establish ... standing, the City explained, only if the injury he claimed to suffer - the receipt of mail solicitations - could be linked causally to the City's allegedly unlawful disclosures," Harris wrote. "And here, the City contended, Hensley had not alleged and could not establish that any solicitation he received was based on an accident report improperly disclosed by the City."

    U.S. District Judge Kenneth Bell rejected Charlotte's motion to dismiss the case. But Bell granted the city's motion for a "judgment on the pleadings." That decision amounted to a legal win for Charlotte.

    "Hensley, the district court found, had failed to plausibly allege that he was 'the victim of a wrongful disclosure of his personal information,' as required to make out a claim under the DPPA," Harris wrote.

    The court already had ruled that the city's disclosure of accident reports to LexisNexis did not violate federal law. That left only the over-the-counter disclosures to assess. "There was no way to establish which accident reports actually were viewed by the public at that location, and Hensley had not alleged that he ever received a solicitation based on a physical disclosure at the records division," Harris wrote.

    Bell determined that he did not need to address the city's jurisdictional challenge. Appellate judges disagreed.

    "We appreciate the district court's efforts to resolve this case as efficiently as possible, without engaging in unnecessary back-and-forth on evidentiary questions," Harris wrote. "But that route to decision - bypassing a complicated jurisdictional question in favor of a more readily resolved merits ruling - is foreclosed."

    A 1998 precedent "establishes that a federal court's subject matter jurisdiction is a threshold question that always must be addressed before passing on the merits of a case, even where the merits question is more straightforward."

    "[I]t is incumbent on a court to evaluate its jurisdiction at the outset, lest it inadvertently breach the 'bounds of authorized judicial action,'" Harris wrote. "And if jurisdiction is lacking, 'the court cannot proceed at all in any cause'; the 'only function remaining to the court is that of announcing' the absence of jurisdiction 'and dismissing the cause.'"

    The case now heads back to the U.S. District Court. As an unpublished opinion, the decision in Hensley v. City of Charlotte does not set a binding precedent in the 4th Circuit.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Education bill would require Computer Science and make Earth Science an elective Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Bill would make Wake County commissioner races nonpartisan


Latest State and Federal

House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Turner (R-OH) said that communist China is using TikTok to make its way into U.S. data systems as calls grow for the federal government to ban the app.
Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) brought up left-wing riots during an interview over the weekend when asked about the recent media coverage surrounding the January 6 riot following the release of thousands of hours of video footage from the incident.
General Assembly leaders agreed to a bottom-line budget number last week, kicking off the biennium budget season. Senate Leader Phil Berger (R-Rockingham) and House Speaker Tim Moore (R-Cleveland) announced that General Fund spending would increase by 6.5% in the first year
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Turner (R-OH) slammed Dr. Anthony Fauci, former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, over the weekend for making statements about the origins of COVID that are not supported by the findings of the U.S. intelligence
Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) said during an interview on Sunday that when he approached President Joe Biden about using the U.S. military to take out Mexican drug cartels, the president rebuffed him and said that it was a “bad idea.”
In a press conference Thursday, Senate Leader Phil Berger and House Speaker Tim Moore announced that an agreement has been reached between the chambers to expand the federal Medicaid entitlement program in North Carolina.


The U.S. Navy announced this week that it would be renaming a ship named for oceanographic pioneer Matthew Fontaine Maury because of Maury’s ties to the Confederacy during the later years of his life.
School staff, mental health professionals and the community can learn how to expand support for K-12 students and families experiencing mental and behavioral health issues in a webinar from 10 a.m. to noon, Wednesday, March 15.
Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis’ first memoir, which was launched ahead of an expected announcement that he will run for president in 2024, sold more copies in its first week than books from Donald Trump, Barack Obama, and Hillary Clinton.
North Carolina’s state motto offers a great guide to policymakers
White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre faced backlash late this week after falsely claiming during a White House press briefing that Daily Wire host Michael Knowles called for the “eradication of transgender people” during a speech at CPAC.
Energy Department Secretary Jennifer Granholm gushed about China’s approach to green energy in a Friday interview, saying she hoped that the U.S. could learn from China’s approach.


Are you currently looking for a new job? Scammers have ramped up efforts to take advantage of job seekers to trick them out of their money or steal their identity.


Back to Top