Put Politics Aside and Focus on the Science of Reading | Eastern North Carolina Now

Publisher's note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal, and written by Dr. Terry Stoops.

    Earlier this month, I was honored to attend "North Carolina and the Science of Reading," an event sponsored by the Charlotte-based Belk Foundation. Speakers from the Barksdale Reading Institute in Mississippi and The Reading League outlined the ways policymakers and state education leaders responded to disappointing test scores and inequitable reading instruction by embracing methods and strategies that apply insights gleaned from cognitive science. Keynote speaker Natalie Wexler gave an overview of the critical relationship between knowledge accumulation and reading comprehension.

    It may surprise some to hear that a literacy expert from Mississippi came to North Carolina to tout the success of reading instruction in the Magnolia State. The October 2019 release of fourth- and eighth-grade reading results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress explains why. Mississippi has made tremendous gains in reading performance over the past two decades. In fourth-grade reading, Mississippi was 10 points below the national average in 1998. By 2019, the state average score reached the national average. In eighth-grade reading, Mississippi was 10 points below the national average in 1998 but moved to within six points of the national average in 2019. But that only tells half the story.

    Overall performance of the state requires measures that account for its demographics. The Urban Institute's America's Gradebook tool adjusts NAEP scores to account for demographic differences across students in each state. Urban Institute researchers incorporate controls for age, race or ethnicity, special education status, free and reduced-price lunch eligibility, and English language learner status. In 2019, Mississippi ranked second in the nation in fourth-grade reading performance and 17th in the nation in eighth-grade reading performance when adjusted for these factors. In other words, Mississippi's performance is even more impressive when its student population is taken into account.

    Of course, these results raise questions about how Mississippi was able to achieve these gains. Emily Hanford contends that part of the state's success was due to its focus on the science of reading. She notes that, in 2013, Mississippi legislators funded an initiative designed to teach the science of reading to prospective educators. This included an emphasis on decoding and language comprehension with phonological awareness (sound structure of spoken words), phonics, fluency, and vocabulary at its core.

    The Excellent Public Schools Act of 2019 would have followed suit. Sponsored by Senate leader Phil Berger, the Excellent Public Schools Act of 2019 would have made critical improvements to North Carolina's Read to Achieve initiative by ensuring that educators and those who train them focus on the science of reading.

    For example, the legislation required individual reading plans that included information on the "evidence-based reading instructional programming" used by the teacher to develop "oral language, phonological and phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, fluency, and comprehension." In addition, the bill required state education officials to include these elements in the development of a digital children's reading initiative and a statewide comprehensive plan to improve literacy instruction. State approval of teacher education programs would have required evidence that these programs teach prospective educators how to deliver evidence-based reading instruction. In sum, the Excellent Public Schools Act of 2019 would have ensured that the science of reading formed the foundation of literacy instruction in North Carolina public schools and teacher education programs.

    Of course, the transformation of reading instruction in North Carolina will have to wait. Gov. Roy Cooper vetoed the bill in August.

    Cooper's veto was somewhat surprising. The Excellent Public Schools Act of 2019 was a good-faith effort to get Read to Achieve implementation back on track. The legislation received bipartisan support in the state House and Senate. J.B. Buxton, a Cooper appointee to the State Board of Education, had a role in drafting the legislation and spoke favorably of it. So why did Cooper veto the bill? News & Observer editors concluded his veto "put politics ahead of a Read to Achieve remedy."

    In other words, Cooper wanted to send a message to his political opponents in the General Assembly, even if it meant torpedoing research-based reforms that have the potential to improve reading instruction for more than 400,000 children in kindergarten through third-grade classrooms. Lawmakers in Mississippi and elsewhere have put politics aside and approved legislation that advances research-based literacy instruction and teacher training in their respective states. It's time North Carolina does the same.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Independent Surgery Center Offers Cashed-Based, Transparent Prices Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Did You Know? At UNC-Chapel Hill, 25% of Students Would Block Controversial Speaker


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Former executives from Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank told members of the Senate on Tuesday that their institutions failed as a result of panic from depositors.
Tennessee House Republicans have sent a letter to the Nashville chief of police asking for the release of the writings and toxicology reports for the trans-identifying shooter who killed six people at a Christian school in March.
In regard to your recent "Sound Off" section of the WDN, May 20th issue, an anonymous "caller," whose sole objective was to denigrate a duly elected county commissioner, I wondered what the purpose really was here.
A Florida apiarist was bee-reft of over a million bees after a truck slammed into him while hauling his hives.
Despite the addition of other candidates seeking the Democratic Party's nomination in the 2024 Presidential Election, incumbent Joe Biden's campaign has announced the President will not be participating in the debates due to the looming strike of the Writers Guild of America.


Residents of several cities in the United States require a salary much higher than $100,000 to feel as if they are earning six figures due to elevated costs of living and aggressive taxes, according to a recent analysis from SmartAsset.
Special counsel John Durham’s report on the Department of Justice’s conspiracy-fueled investigation into alleged Trump-Russia collusion again raises questions about Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA) and the extent to which he may have knowingly misled the American people.
Planned Parenthood CEO Alexis McGill Johnson issued a dire warning in response to Mattel's new Down Syndrome Barbie, saying it might cause young, impressionable girls to think that all human life has value.
The FBI had evidence that Danchenko was a Russian spy, and Danchenko could provide no evidence that Trump was tied to Russia. It paid Danchenko anyway to try to mount a flimsy case against Trump, the Durham report found.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed three bills into law on Monday that placed further restrictions on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives as Florida was recently ranked as the top state in the country for education.


A local man found himself in a jam when his toilet failed to flush yesterday morning. Rather than call a professional plumber to fix the issue, the man called upon the entire backlog of plumbing knowledge he has accumulated during his life: jiggling the toilet handle.


Back to Top