Destin Hall’s “Concept Maps:” Gamechanger or Nothingburger? | Beaufort County Now | Judges in redistricting trial refused to sanction defendants over maps drawn by Rep. Destin Hall and staffers during "strategy sessions."

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Dr. Andy Jackson.

    The trial phase of North Carolina's latest redistricting trial ended Friday, January 6.

    During the trial, Rep. Destin Hall (R - Caldwell) testified that he and legislative attorney Dylan Reel had produced some "concept maps" in what he called "strategy sessions" out of public view while drawing the official North Carolina House districts on a public terminal. The maps were discarded after the official maps were drawn but before the plaintiffs' lawsuits against the enacted maps were filed.

    Reel no longer works at the General Assembly and so was not included in the discovery phase of the trial.

    In response to the revelation about Hall and Reel's concept maps, plaintiffs asked the court to impose "discovery sanctions," on the defendants. Two of those sanctions would have had a significant impact on the trial:

    Drawing an "adverse inference" that the concept maps would have proven that Hall used racial and political data when drawing maps

    Banning legislative defendants from introducing testimony or evidence demonstrating that they did not use racial or political data

    Social media was aflutter over Hall's testimony, with claims such as it demonstrated a "lack of transparency" in the redistricting process and that Hall is a "liar."

    The three judges in charge of the trial were less impressed with plaintiffs' claims about Hall's concept maps, however. They refused to impose any of the sanctions plaintiffs asked them to impose on the defendants. They also pointed out that plaintiffs had the means to get testimony from Reel about the concept maps (page 4):

    So plaintiffs could have gotten testimony from someone who had direct knowledge of Hall's concept maps but chose not to get it. Their lack of curiosity about what Reel knows about the concept maps is curious.

    Was it laziness that caused plaintiffs' attorneys not to subpoena Reel? Probably not. A more likely "adverse inference" is that they were not interested in discovering the truth about those maps but simply wanted to use their existence to get the court to toss out evidence detrimental to their case.

    The court was not buying what plaintiffs were selling, at least in regards to discovery sanctions.

    It is possible that the court will hold Hall's testimony about concept maps against the defendants when they rule on the case. The acid test for that is if they treat the North Carolina House map (drawn by Hall) differently than they treat the North Carolina Senate and congressional maps (drawn by the senate).

    We will know that soon: the court will render its verdict by Tuesday, January 11.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Houston police are walking back a claim that a security guard at Astroworld was injected with drugs after saying he felt a prick in his neck.
According to sources, local feminist business executive Sarah McAndrews prefers to unwind after a hard day at work by sitting on the couch with a pint of ice cream while fantasizing about being a happily married stay-at-home mom.
A former Minuteman commander at an underground nuclear silo with launch facility secrets blasted Pentagon officials for not mentioning a 1967 incident where an alleged UFO reportedly shut down ten nuclear missiles.
Researchers working on an experiment with carbon atoms found evidence that could suggest an alternate reality actually exists.
Two Massachusetts Institute of Technology graduates have taken issue with their alma mater’s recent moves to become more woke, saying the decisions are “damaging” to the school and its commitment to academic freedom.
Paper straws in the Golden City will now come with a 15-second self-destruct timer to help customers understand how close they are to having their straw dissolve into a pile of useless goo.


Following his damaging testimony at the trial of Kyle Rittenhouse, Gaige Grosskreutz was brought on “Good Morning America” to mock the teen accused of killing two rioters in Kenosha, Wisconsin, and injuring Grosskreutz.
The Carolina Journal makes a wide sweeping evaluation of the news that most effects us here in North Carolina, and is distilled, here on BCN, for your clear understanding by the electronic means of video broadcast.
Elon Musk’s SpaceX, an aerospace company that he created, reportedly paid a woman $250,000 to settle a sexual misconduct claim against him stemming from an alleged incident several years ago.
A disturbing report from the DOJ has revealed that up to 50,000 wives go missing each year in Cracker Barrel's country store, never to be seen again. This phenomenon has been occurring for decades but is only just now coming to light.
Analysts at a top U.S. bank are warning that nationwide gas prices could skyrocket from their current $4.589 average per gallon to more than $6 per gallon by the end of summer.


Especially during an election season, taxpayers must be wary of calls to expand government


Back to Top