Appeals Court rules against Wilson County school board in pension-spiking dispute | Eastern North Carolina Now

The Wilson County Board of Education owes more than $400,000 to help fund a former assistant superintendent's retirement benefits, based on a ruling Tuesday from the state Court of Appeals.

ENCNow
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The Wilson County school board will have to contribute another $400,000 toward a former assistant superintendent's retirement, based on a state Court of Appeals ruling Tuesday. It's the latest legal battle over North Carolina's 2014 pension-spiking law.

    The unanimous three-judge Appeals Court decision reverses a trial judge's ruling in favor of Wilson schools. The Appeals Court restores an administrative law judge's earlier decision in favor of the Retirement Systems Division in the Department of State Treasurer.

    "I applaud the Court of Appeals opinion that unanimously overturned a lower court ruling," said State Treasurer Dale Folwell in an emailed statement. "The law was implemented by the previous treasurer. It is not our job to tell school boards or others what to pay administrators. It is our job to protect and defend others in the plan who are asked to pay for it."

    The Wilson County Board of Education had challenged the pension-spiking law as unconstitutional. "[T]he Act does not violate Article I, Section 10, of the United States Constitution; does not violate Article IX, Section 7(a), of the North Carolina Constitution; and is not retroactively applied to Petitioner," wrote Appeals Court Judge Allegra Collins.

    The Wilson school board is the petitioner in the case.

    The dispute stemmed from Assistant Superintendent Susan Bullock's retirement in 2018. Because her final annual compensation exceeded $100,000, retirement system officials applied the state's anti-pension-spiking law, NC Gen. Stat. 135-5(a3).

HbAD0

    A calculation required by the law found that Wilson County schools owed $401,763.96 to cover costs of Bullock's retirement benefits. The school board appealed the ruling. An administrative law judge ruled in favor of the retirement system in September 2021, but the school board appealed to Superior Court.

    "Petitioner alleged that the ALJ's final decision was erroneous because the [pension-spiking] Act is unconstitutional and impermissibly retroactive," Collins wrote. A trial judge ruled in favor of the school board in June 2022.

    Appellate judges rejected the school system's argument that the pension-spiking law violates the US Constitution's prohibition on state laws "impairing the Obligation of Contracts."

    "If the employee's salary increase took effect after the Act was enacted on 30 July 2014 and resulted in the contribution-based benefit cap factor analysis concluding that an additional contribution was required, then the Act did not impair the employment contract," Collins wrote. "Accordingly, Petitioner has failed to establish that the Act substantially impaired its employment contract with the employee. As such, we need not analyze whether the impairment was reasonable and necessary to serve an important public purpose."

    Collins and her colleagues also rejected the notion that the Wilson County school board had an implied contract with the retirement system. "Petitioner cites no authority to support its proposition that such an implied contract existed, or that it has a vested right in keeping constant its amount of contribution to the TSERS pension fund."

    TSERS is the Teachers' and State Employees' Retirement System.

    "There is no set rate that an employer must contribute, but rather it fluctuates to remedy gaps in the pension fund," Collins wrote. "Petitioner has therefore failed to show that the General Assembly manifested a clear intention to be contractually bound to keep constant the amount an employer is required to contribute to the pension fund. Accordingly, Petitioner has failed to show that a contractual obligation was present. As such, we need not analyze whether the Act impaired a contract or whether the impairment was reasonable and necessary to serve an important public purpose."

    The Appeals Court rejected the school board's argument that the additional retirement contribution would hurt its ability to provide a "sound basic education" to students. That would amount to a violation of the NC Constitution.

    "Petitioner has failed to present ... any facts in the form of affidavits, testimony, or otherwise that the payment at issue in this case would undermine its ability to provide a sound basic education to Wilson County children," Collins wrote. "Furthermore, Petitioner has failed to show that paying its employees the deferred compensation to which they are entitled is not a use that maintains free public schools."

HbAD1

    Nor did the retirement system apply the law retroactively, according to the Appeals Court. "The plain language of the Act indicates that it applies to any retirement allowance for a member who retires on or after 1 January 2015. Because the employee in this case retired on 1 January 2018, three years after Act took effect, the statute was not retroactively applied to Petitioner," Collins wrote.

    Judges Chris Dillon and Toby Hampson joined Collins' opinion.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




Dershowitz says GA Trump indictment is for what Dems did in 2000. Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Poland submits illegal immigration issue to referendum vote


HbAD2

Latest State and Federal

Republican congressman Byron Donalds said it would be a “great honor” if former President Donald Trump were to ask him to be his running-mate for 2024, saying the ultimate goal is for Trump to win and he’ll do whatever he’s asked to help him do that.
Voters in Arizona will have the opportunity to enact broad border security measures in November as the state faces a flood of illegal immigration after the Republican-led state legislature passed a resolution that will put the measures on the general election ballot.
The former White House physician for Presidents Barack Obama and Donald Trump says that a new report this week about how President Joe Biden is struggling to function behind closed doors represents a serious threat to the U.S.
The Tikva Forum for Families of Hostages, an Israeli group created to represent the families of those taken during Hamas’ October 7 terrorist attack, urged President Joe Biden to stop interfering with Israel’s campaign to destroy the terrorist group.
After saying the six-foot social distancing guideline during the COVID-19 pandemic “sort of just appeared,” Dr. Anthony Fauci on Monday testified that his statement had been “distorted” and that it “actually” came from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
The state Supreme Court has agreed to hear one of two pending cases involving North Carolina bar owners challenging Gov. Roy Cooper's COVID-related shutdowns in 2020.
The Biden administration canceled over 350,000 asylum cases, allowing migrants to stay in the United States indefinitely in a move that experts called “mass amnesty.”
Former White House medical advisor Anthony Fauci changed his view of COVID vaccines from 2021 to 2024, clips show.
The Department of Justice announced on Friday that 75-year-old Paula Paulette Harlow was sentenced to two years in prison for violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act by taking part in a “conspiracy” to block pregnant women from entering an abortion clinic in Washington, D.C.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top