EEOC judge awards $1.3 million to two NC magistrates in same-sex marriage dispute

Latest Polls (view all)

Where do you stand on the Transgender Issue now that the issue has gotten to the overt point of the open celebration of this lifestyle choice, dictated by certain direct and explicit actions.

86.84% I do not approve of behavior that has within its expressed tenants policies that harm children.

11.84% I do support the Trans Community in all its many facets because diversity is at a premium in today's society.

1.32% What is a "Children's Drag Queen Story Hour?"

Click Here to Vote
76 Vote(s)

View all Polls

EEOC judge awards $1.3 million to two NC magistrates in same-sex marriage dispute

Published: Thursday, July 31st, 2025 @ 11:01 am
By: Carolina Journal ( More Entries )

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Two western North Carolina magistrates who resigned in 2014 to avoid performing same-sex marriage ceremonies will collect more than $1.3 million in back pay and other damages, thanks to an order this month from an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission judge.

    Administrative Law Judge Thomas McCarthy's July 17 final order follows a 10-year legal battle. McCarthy also awarded more than $450,000 for a decade of lawyers' fees in the case.

    The 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals threw out North Carolina's ban on same-sex marriages in October 2014. John Smith, director of the state Administrative Office of the Courts, issued a memorandum after the decision calling on magistrates to begin performing same-sex marriages immediately.

    Magistrates Gilbert Breedlove in Swain County and Thomas Holland in Graham County raised concerns about the conflict between the AOC's instructions and their religious beliefs. Unable to identify a compromise that would allow them to avoid taking part in same-sex marriage ceremonies, they resigned from their jobs.

    By spring 2015, Breedlove and Holland filed religious discrimination complaints with the EEOC under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.

    "Over the ensuing eight-year period, Complainants' allegations endured protracted and, at times, circuitous cycles of dismissals, rescissions and reconsiderations, and further dismissals," with McCarthy taking over the case in 2023, he wrote in June.

    His order awards Breedlove more than $655,000 and Holland more than $680,000. The order also calls for Holland's "immediate reinstatement" as a magistrate in Graham County.

    "Complainants Breedlove and Holland have met their burden to establish their respective claims of religious discrimination against Respondents in their official capacities for failure to accommodate their respective religious beliefs and by constructively discharging them,:" McCarthy wrote. "Respondents failed to meet their countervailing burden to demonstrate that an accommodation from the employment requirement to perform same-sex marriage irrespective of religious objections would have imposed an undue burden."

    Though both magistrates resigned, they are able to collect back pay under the legal claim of "constructive discharge." A plaintiff makes that claim when he quits a job after an employer creates a hostile or intolerable work environment.

    "Complainants in this case have not 'sought to leave at the first sign of dissatisfaction,' but resigned only after their supervisors affirmed the ... warning that North Carolina magistrates 'must treat same-sex marriages for which a marriage license has been issued by the Register of Deeds the same way that marriages between a man and a woman are scheduled and conducted,' and that '[i]f a magistrate refuses to discharge the duties of his or her office, including a refusal to perform a marriage of a same-sex couple, that refusal is grounds for suspension or removal from office, as well as, potential criminal charges,'" McCarthy wrote.

    "Complainants here were not merely given a notice of intent to commence a process leading to discharge. They were instead told that a single refusal to perform a same-sex marriage ceremony would immediately expose a magistrate to suspension and potential criminal proceedings," the judge added. "In fact, when asked on direct examination whether he considered staying as a magistrate, refusing to perform a same-sex marriage, and seeing what would happen next, Breedlove responded: 'No sir. I wasn't willing to face criminal liability or civil liability. ... I would have been charged with a crime and that's something I just couldn't do. I mean, that would destroy my career.'"

    In 2015, seven months after the two magistrates' resignations, state policy changed to accommodate magistrates' religious concerns about performing same-sex marriage ceremonies. That change did not restore Breedlove or Holland to their prior jobs.

    "The Administrative Office of the Courts handled the situation poorly back in 2014, and we're grateful that the judge recognized that the state had forced these magistrates to resign when they refused to violate their Christian beliefs," lawyer Craig Schauer said in an email Tuesday to Carolina Journal. "They've been waiting over a decade for this ruling. Now that we have it, we are optimistic the current leadership at the Administrative Office of the Courts will make things right for our clients."

poll#201

Considering what real news is available for all to witness, and in great specificity, should one pursue what is true outside of the channeled realm of the corrupt corporate /legacy media, and: Is Institutionalized Corruption real, and is it a hindrance to sustaining our Constitutional Republic now, and for future generations of American citizens?

Yes

No

Not sure

508 total vote(s) What's your Opinion?

Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias

Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published )

Enter Your Comment ( text only please )

Login to Leave a Comment

General Assembly overrides Stein vetos of 7 bills, incl. gender and sanctuary city bills Carolina Journal, News Services, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal The Trump economy: GDP grows at healthy rate of 3% in second quarter

Latest State and Federal

Major Teachers Union Plans Trump Walkout While Their Own Students Can Barely Read

The teachers union is pushing to cancel school on May 1 as Chicago public schools continue to report dismal student proficiency rates.

Published: Monday, April 27th, 2026 @ 7:52 pm By: Daily Wire

‘Andre the Giant’ marker puts smalltown Ellerbe into spotlight

With a new roadside plaque unveiled in Ellerbe on April 23, legendary wrestler and local resident André René Roussimoff is finally getting the formal recognition fans believe he deserves.

Published: Monday, April 27th, 2026 @ 7:40 pm By: Carolina Journal

Hollywood Still Blacklists Conservatives — Now They Don’t Even Hide It

Cheryl Hines. Dennis Quaid. Nicki Minaj. All became associated with the Trump administration. What happened next?

Published: Friday, April 24th, 2026 @ 7:18 am By: Daily Wire

KNOWLES: Do Right-Wing Podcasters Want To Lose The Midterms?

Two years ago, new media brought President Trump back to the White House. What happened?

Published: Thursday, April 23rd, 2026 @ 8:39 pm By: Daily Wire

Victims, advocates gather in Raleigh for Crime Victims’ Rights Week

Victims’ advocates, prosecutors, law enforcement officials, and families impacted by violent crime gathered Tuesday at the North Carolina State Archives building in Raleigh to recognize National Crime Victims’ Rights Week and honor those affected by crime across North Carolina.

Published: Thursday, April 23rd, 2026 @ 8:39 pm By: Carolina Journal

Illegal Immigrants Found A New Way To Get Released From ICE Detention

"It has been absolutely successful."

Published: Thursday, April 23rd, 2026 @ 8:39 pm By: Daily Wire

With Oscars Around The Corner, Even California Thinks Hollywood Is Off The Political Deep End

The POLITICO poll found that almost half of respondents think Hollywood players should "be less vocal with their political beliefs."

Published: Thursday, April 23rd, 2026 @ 8:39 pm By: Daily Wire

‘RIP ‘EM OUT’: Hegseth Declares War On Wokeness In Military Schools, Launches 90-Day Review

"They help cultivate a radical hate America agenda, and we can't afford that same toxic ideology in America's War Department.”

Published: Wednesday, April 22nd, 2026 @ 2:10 pm By: Daily Wire

Security Guard Takes Out Shooter In Michigan Synagogue Attack

A massive police presence was seen outside the synagogue.

Published: Wednesday, April 22nd, 2026 @ 2:06 pm By: Daily Wire

Our Members

ENCN Sign Up

BCN Home

Beaufort Observer

Portfolios

Current Events: A Historical Perspective

Current Weather

Latest Comments

Latest Polls

Featured Entries

Latest Entries

Advertisement

Local News & Expression

Reminder: Scheduled City Council Meeting

Grand Jury Returns Indictment in 2023 Death Investigation

4-13-26 City Council Agenda

Finding Her Footing: Zofia Cheeseman Discovers a Math and Economics Career

Death Investigation

All Latest Entries

Advertisement

Weather (7 day forcast)

Washington, NC, USA

Advertisement

Categories (view all)

Across North Carolina

Body & Soul

Business

Community

Current Events: A Historical Perspective

Government

Local Governments

Local News & Expression

Memorial

NativeFront

Op-Ed & Politics

Sports

Stewardship

The Arts

The Region

The Studio

Advertisement

Resources & Services

Local Gas Prices Check out our list of local gas prices for Washington, Greenville, and Chocowinity

Popular Articles Check out our top entries for the latest two months.

Symbiotic Networks Custom web design, online marketing/advertising, programming, and web development projects.

Advertisement

EEOC judge awards $1.3 million to two NC magistrates in same-sex marriage dispute | Eastern NC Now

EEOC judge awards $1.3 million to two NC magistrates in same-sex marriage dispute

Leave a Guest Comment