We Were Never In Kansas | Beaufort County Now | As the general election campaign begins in North Carolina, you can expect to hear a lot about Kansas

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's note: This article appeared on John Hood's daily column in the Carolina Journal, which, because of Author / Publisher Hood, is linked to the John Locke Foundation.

    RALEIGH     As the general election campaign begins in North Carolina, you can expect to hear a lot about Kansas.

    Yes, I can read a map. Kansas and North Carolina aren't exactly neighbors. But when it comes to fiscal policy, critics of Gov. Pat McCrory and the General Assembly in Raleigh would rather talk about what's happening out on the prairies of the Sunflower State rather than what's happening in the mountains, piedmont, and coastal plain of the Tar Heel State.

    Several years ago, Kansas and North Carolina each began a series of tax reforms and reductions. Because both sets of policies were championed by many conservatives and savaged by many liberals, they came to be associated with each other by national reporters and policy analysts.

    In reality, however, the two states made markedly different choices - and have ended up with markedly different results. A couple of months ago, the Kansas legislature was forced to fill a large hole in its state budget by delaying a scheduled contribution to its state pension fund as well as cutting its school, university, and road budgets across the board.

    Here in North Carolina, the latest estimates from the state controller (through May 31) show our state's General Fund budget running an operating surplus for the current fiscal year of about $1.2 billion. That reflects the difference between $20.1 billion in revenue and $18.9 billion in expenditures.

    This hefty surplus for the first 11 months of the fiscal year, combined with leftover money from last year and healthy revenue projections for next year, should explain why McCrory and the legislature will soon enact a state budget that raises teacher pay substantially, boosts pay for at least some state employees, funds other necessary services, saves more money for a rainy day, and provides North Carolinians another round of tax relief.

    How did Kansas and North Carolina end up in such different conditions? For one thing, while the two states both enacted major tax cuts, they weren't structured the same way. Kansas punched a large hole in its income-tax base by excluding self-employment income. North Carolina briefly created a version of this exclusion in the immediate aftermath of the Great Recession, but then wisely eliminated it in favor of applying a low, uniform tax rate on a broad base of personal income.

    In Kansas, lawmakers also allowed themselves to be bamboozled by some out-of-state tax "experts" claiming that cutting income taxes would generate so much new investment, entrepreneurship, and population growth that the revenue loss to the state would be substantially offset. This can actually be true, of course - in the very long run, counted in decades. In the short run of state budgeting, however, policymakers are better off making far more conservative assumptions about revenue feedbacks.

    North Carolina did precisely that. Our state policymakers didn't just reduce and reform taxes. They also controlled expenditures. Since the enactment of the 2013 tax changes, their authorized budgets have never pushed spending growth above the combined rates of inflation and population growth. Actual spending, in fact, has often come in below even these budgeted amounts. Look at the first 11 months of this year. Most of the operating surplus comes from lower-than-expected spending ($1 billion), not higher-than-expected revenues ($224 million).

    North Carolina's economy has outperformed that of Kansas, to be sure, although this was likely to occur regardless of tax reform. The real difference here was one of strategy. It's clearly better to set conservative goals and then be pleasantly surprised, rather than let rosy scenarios lead to unpleasant shocks.

    Liberals in our state can (and will) say that North Carolina should have kept taxes higher to fund more government spending. Conservatives obviously disagree. But what liberals can't say now - even though they predicted it in 2013 - is that North Carolina's tax reforms have created a fiscal crisis. Our operating budget and savings reserve are both in good shape.

    "I've a feeling we're not in Kansas anymore," Dorothy told Toto. When it comes to state fiscal policy, North Carolina never was.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

State Attorney General Josh Stein is recovering today from a “minor stroke.” He shared details through his Twitter feed.
Hybrid schools employ multiple settings, instructors, and mediums of instruction with varying degrees of standardization and regimentation
A crew member working on “Indiana Jones 5” was found dead on location in Morocco.
Readers of the Bee, As most of you know by now, we've been locked out of Twitter for the past couple of months because we allegedly violated their "hateful conduct" policy with this joke.
President Biden’s support among Hispanics has plummeted in the last 12 months to less than half of his approval numbers last year, according to a new poll.


Since 1868, a day has been set aside to remember all those who died in American wars. Monday, May 30, 2022 is this year's date. My memory of Memorial Day is largely around celebrating the beginning of Summer, parties with hot dogs and watermelon, pools opening.
A crewmember who was helping to close down the set after a fatal shooting on the set of “Rust” may lose his arm due to a venomous spider bite he suffered while working.
According to sources on the International Space Station, a sudden message appeared to astronauts stationed aboard the satellite as it passed over Texas recently.
A leading pro-life advocate left a leading leftist Democrat congressman running for cover when she exposed the hypocrisy of his party’s position on abortion.
RALEIGH: Today, Governor Roy Cooper previewed the Circle K Speed Street ahead of the Coca-Cola 600 race weekend to stop by vendor booths and highlight the significant investments the speedway will receive from the 2021-2022 state budget.
Edmond Harris became the 50th person in Chicago arrested this year for allegedly murdering, attempting to murder, or shooting someone while out on felony bond.



Back to Top