You Know Those Studies That Say Conservatives Are More Authoritarian Than Leftists? They're Basically Garbage. | Eastern North Carolina Now | You've undoubtedly seen those preening headlines from major outlets about how conservatives are more "authoritarian" by nature than Leftists.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
&    Publisher's note: This informational nugget was sent to me by Ben Shapiro, who represents the Daily Wire, and since this is one of the most topical news events, it should be published on BCN.

    You've undoubtedly seen those preening headlines from major outlets about how conservatives are more "authoritarian" by nature than Leftists. See, for example, here and here and here. But it turns out that this is nonsense. Such studies are generally vague and deliberately constructed to make it appear that conservatives are more "authoritarian" than Leftists. In reality, authoritarian personality types exist across the political spectrum. All you have to do is change the incentive structure in the questions, and you'll suddenly find Leftists who hate freedom and conservatives who love it.

    Jesse Singal of New York Magazine has a long and worthwhile piece about the scientific flaws in the authoritarian modeling. But the concept itself goes back to the Frankfurt School, members of which argued that Americans were members of an "authoritarian" mold since they didn't agree with Marxist precepts about redistribution of wealth. Thus, for example, Erich Fromm argued that fascism would rise in the United States thanks to its devotion to capitalism - and that capitalism sprang from social structures that had urged "compulsive conforming in the process of which the isolated individual becomes an automaton," breeding "authoritarian character."

    Leftists in science took the bait and began constructing clearly flawed studies to support this dubious and self-flattering conclusion. As Singal writes:

    These scales, in short, are all too often structured in a way in which respondents' tendencies toward dogmatism or close-mindedness or intolerance are ascertained by asking them about issues that are politicized. And while social and political psychologists have sometimes asked about rigidity in ways designed to tap liberal ideas - the famed authoritarianism researcher Bob Altemeyer, for example, did publish a left-wing authoritarianism scale - this has been the exception rather than the norm.

    Thus, when you encounter an "authoritarian" quiz online, it will likely bear questions that ask whether you want flag burning banned - but none on whether you want hate speech banned, for example. When studies were constructed to reverse the politics of the original studies - surprise, surprise! - the results were reversed:

    As it turned out, these tweaks affected which group responded more "dogmatically" a great deal. Liberals scored as more dogmatic than conservatives when it came to their agreement with sentiments like "When it comes to stopping global warming, it is better to be a dead hero than a live coward" and "A person who thinks primarily of his/her own happiness, and in so doing disregards the health of the environment (for example, trees and other animals), is beneath contempt," while conservatives, by contrast, scored higher than liberals on items tuned in the opposite political direction. (In fact, there was little difference between how conservatives scored on the original scale and the tweaked-to-be-more-explicitly-conservative version, lending credence to the claim that the original scale was biased in a direction that captured more conservative than liberal dogmatism.) "By making only small adjustments to a popularly used dogmatism scale, results show that liberals can be significantly more dogmatic if a liberal domain is made salient," explained the authors.

    Confirmation bias has allowed too many members of the Left to ignore embarrassing scientific reversals like this one from 2016, when a study suggesting that conservatives were psychotic was actually recalibrated to show the reverse.

    Yet virtually every political science course continues to carry nonsense about how conservatives are only conservative because they like authority.
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

I watched with great interest the small comments made by DOJ Attorney General Merrick Garland, in an even shorter press conference, about a most serious matter, and yet, I took nothing he said seriously.
On Friday, Israel Defense Forces announced Operation “Breaking Dawn” to attack Palestinian Islamic Jihad terrorists in the Gaza Strip. Reports state that the IDF killed Tayseer al-Jabari, a senior Islamic Jihad terrorist commander who supervised terrorist forces.
Former President Donald Trump avoided incriminating himself in a deposition with New York A.G. Letitia James by pleading the fifth amendment right to remain silent.
Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis sent law enforcement officials to remove woke State Attorney Andrew Warren of the 13th Judicial Circuit, who was backed by Democrat mega donor George Soros, from office this week.
An independent Pentagon review of a drone strike that killed 10 Afghan civilians, including 7 children, during the final days of the U.S. military’s presence in Afghanistan recommends that no disciplinary action be taken.

HbAD1

President Joe Biden’s spending agenda climbed another hurdle and now appears to have enough votes to pass the Senate after Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ) agreed to the package Thursday.
The FBI raided the home of Nicholas Cage in the early morning hours Friday after an anonymous tip that he had stolen the Declaration of Independence.
Former television news anchor Kari Lake has won the Arizona GOP primary to be the state’s next governor.
“A Tale of Two Carts” - Featuring the Heartbreak of Working Families Being Crushed by Bad Biden/Beasley Policies had Inaccurate Data
Democrat President Joe Biden claimed that reports from multiple mainstream newspapers that the administration could pay illegal aliens who were separated at the border under the previous administration up to $450,000 each to settle lawsuits were untrue.
U.S. District Judge William Osteen is ending his injunction of North Carolina's abortion law, allowing a ban on most abortions after 20 weeks to take effect.

HbAD2

California State Senator Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco) was interviewed Thursday by The Washington Post about the response to his state’s monkeypox outbreak and said that people have to make their own decisions about having sex.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top