When parental involvement is too much of a good thing | Beaufort County Now | This fall a “We Are Teachers” blog post, lamenting an upsurge in over-involved parents, went viral, eliciting coverage from myriad media outlets and the national teachers’ union. | parents, students, teachers, opinion, march 28, 2019

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

When parental involvement is too much of a good thing

    Publisher's note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal, and written by Kristen Blair, Carolina Journal Contributor.

    There's a new twist to an ongoing debate - this one about parents and the students they create. This fall a "We Are Teachers" blog post, lamenting an upsurge in over-involved parents, went viral, eliciting coverage from myriad media outlets and the national teachers' union. Written anonymously by a middle school teacher, the post described "lawnmower parents," so named because of attempts to "mow obstacles down so kids won't experience them in the first place." When parents request project extensions or deliver insulated (BPA-free!) water bottles to school, this teacher wondered: How will kids rebound after bombing their first test in college?

    Then there were revelations in mid-March of extreme (and felonious) lawnmower parenting. To guarantee spots at elite colleges, wealthy parents paid bribes to have children identified falsely as athletic recruits, or to arrange for cheating on admissions exams. Reeking of parental entitlement, this scandal elicited justifiable outrage. But what about everyday, well-intentioned instances of parental over-involvement? Where to draw the line on those?

    First, clarification: Benefits of healthy parental involvement are buttressed by abundant research. Kids need parental involvement, loads of it, to do school and life. But when involvement becomes interference, casualties accrue. Among them: long-term learning, autonomy, and self-esteem.

    Lawnmower parenting often springs from a loving desire to shield kids from pain. "I don't think any of it comes from a bad place," says Rita Platt, a principal in Wisconsin's St. Croix Falls School District. I sought out Platt's input after reading her excellent parenting post on Middle Web's blog.

    Problems arise when "parents do too much for kids and they don't let them learn how to fail or how to experience hardship," says Platt. "There used to be natural consequences. If kids forgot their gloves at recess, then their hands were cold. If they forgot their lunch, then they had to share a lunch with a friend or go a little hungry. It's not going to hurt them."

    Safeguarding against short-term pain seems kinder. Think: warm hands, full tummy - today. But it deprives kids of experiences that shape tomorrow and beyond. "That's what learning is," says Platt. "It's a whole bunch of failures and productive struggle."

    Powerfully effective parents, longstanding research shows, are those whose style is warm, firm - and democratic. They mirror the authoritative parenting style outlined by psychologist Diana Baumrind decades ago. Research links authoritative parenting with educational achievement, attainment, and healthy attitudes about work.

    How to do this practically? "Letting kids speak for themselves is really important," says Platt. Chores build self-esteem, giving kids "a sense of what it means to contribute." Stepping away from online grade portals also helps. Platt, who employs this strategy with her own middle school-age children, says that might mean a heart-to-heart with mom when report cards come out. But kids learn responsibility.

    The road to self-esteem, says Platt, is through "supported failure" and learning to do things yourself. Parents are there, offering kids hugs and saying, "'Get back out there' ... It's a better way for kids to build self-esteem than to guard them, pamper them, and coddle them through."

    Funny thing: I bombed my first test in college. My mother, who believed in productive struggle, had prepared me. I sought help and doubled down on effort. That bad grade was a powerful teacher, fueling academic accolades. I've shared that experience with my own children, almost grown, after their school setbacks.

    Parenting is hard, imperfect work. It's normal to rev up that lawnmower occasionally. I have. But it's wise to throttle back. Ultimately, kids are the better for it.

    Kristen Blair is a Chapel Hill-based education writer.


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

At the Request of President Biden, Acting Secretary of Education Will Extend Pause on Federal Student Loan Payments
She's impressive and hopefully isn't finished in public service.
Chicago prosecutors say 36-year-old Aditya Singh lived in the city’s O’Hare International Airport for three months to avoid flying home to Los Angeles, California, amid the coronavirus pandemic.
Are you spending your precious time wisely, or are you a pawn, an infinitesimal cog, in someone else's Global Plan?
As of Jan. 18, North Carolina had received about a million doses of COVID-19 vaccines.


Come with us on Part II of Wolfman and The Guardians' journey through the streets of our nation's capitol. These stories are only available exclusively here at BCN!
Joy Pullmann of the Federalist explains how right-of-center partisans can respond well to a Biden presidency.
Joe Biden, a man with the mental acuity and awareness of an oyster is now in the White House, where he will be taken by the hand, guided into a closet and handed some coloring books to keep him busy while Kamala Harris runs the government
Kevin Daley of the Washington Free Beacon highlights one of the consequences of this month’s Capitol riots.


Most college professors applaud what American higher education does and want to see it expand to include even more students.


Back to Top