Dispute Over a K-3 Reading Contract Heats Up | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal, and written by Lindsay Marchello.

N.C. Superintendent of Public Instruction Mark Johnson, pictured here in his office. | Photo: Don Carrington/Carolina Journal

    A dispute over a K-3 reading contract is heating up after the company at the center of the controversy, Istation, sent a cease-and-desist letter to three people who have publicly criticized a decision to grant the contract to Istation.

    "The cease and desist notices provided are a lawful and appropriate starting point to end the misinformation, set the record straight, protect Istation's interests, and let the state move forward," Kieran Shanahan, Istation's attorney, wrote in a statement.

    The controversy surrounding the K-3 reading contract dates to when Istation was awarded the contract, which was June 7. The announcement prompted swift backlash from some educators, school leaders, educational activists, and Amplify, one of the companies competing for the contract.

    Amplify filed a legal protest challenging the decision on the grounds that Istation wasn't developmentally suitable for young children and failed to satisfy requirements in the law. Under Istation, students' reading skills would be tested on computers, and a progress report would be printed out for the teacher. With Amplify's Mclass, a student reads aloud to a teacher so the teacher can assess reading ability.

    Amplify has demanded the contract be delayed or terminated. Ossa Fisher, president of Istation, released a statement claiming Amplify's protest is "frivolous" and "without any substantial basis or merit." DPI and Amplify plan to meet July 18 to discuss the protest.

    The state has used Amplify's Mclass since 2013 to monitor progress with Read to Achieve. But on June 7, State Superintendent Mark Johnson announced Istation would receive the multi-million dollar contract.

    In a Facebook post, Amy Jablonski, a former DPI employee, claimed Johnson picked Istation over the contract evaluation committee's recommendation to stick with Amplify. Jablonski is running to challenge Johnson for the state superintendent position.

    Johnson and the Department of Public Instruction have denied Jablonski's claim, and instead have said no consensus was reached among the evaluation committee.

    Documents disclosed in a public records request reveal a complicated picture.

    DPI disclosed July 12 more than 100 pages worth of internal documents relating to the selection process, which led to Istation winning the contract. WRAL posted the documents online.

    Meeting notes from November 2018 appear to show the evaluation committee ranked Amplify as its top choice, followed by Istation, Curriculum Associations, and NWEA.

    Amplify led in categories such as strength of references, proof of concept, substantial conformity to specifications, and desired specifications, but was last in categories such as cost proposal and financial stability. Istation was first in the cost-related categories.

    Six voting members recommended negotiating with Amplify, three with Istation, and one voting member recommended negotiating with both Amplify and Istation.

    The RFP process was canceled twice, and instead DPI negotiated directly with Amplify and Istation. One of the RFPs was canceled earlier in 2018 after it was revealed that one of the evaluation committee members failed to disclose a former business relationship with Amplify.

    "There is a great deal of misinformation in public forums regarding the Read to Achieve diagnostic selection process," Johnson wrote in a statement that was included with the documents. "DPI cannot release every detail of the procurement process until the process is complete (i.e. until after the protest is decided)."

    DPI and the State Board of Education are moving forward with preparing teachers to use Istation instead of Mclass.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Beaufort County Commissioners Make Another Bad Decision Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics North Carolinians in Health Insurance “Coverage Gap” Discuss Medicaid Expansion with Governor Cooper and Secretary Cohen


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

The reason Disney canceled constructing a $1 billion office complex in Orlando has little to do with Governor Ron DeSantis’ battle against the company’s woke priorities, Daily Wire editor emeritus Ben Shapiro said on his show Friday.
Legendary NFL running back Jim Brown, one the league’s first superstars, has died. He was 87 years old.
After word got out that an FBI whistleblower was accusing Joe Biden of taking bribes during his time as Vice President, the President quickly told his advisors that he needed to spin the "Wheel of Distraction" to get everyone talking about something else.
Author and crime expert Heather Mac Donald said during an interview Tuesday night that recent acts of mass lawlessness in inner cities that have gone viral on social media are the direct result of the political Left’s demonization of law enforcement as “racist.”
Several social media influencers filed a lawsuit against the state of Montana asserting that a recent TikTok ban constitutes a violation of the First Amendment.


A unanimous N.C. Court of Appeals panel is allowing a woman to move forward with her lawsuit against the city of Raleigh and one of its employees. The employee injured the woman in an auto accident in 2018.
Tim Keller, a prominent Christian author and the longtime pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City, passed away on Friday morning at the age of 72 after a battle with cancer.
anti-immigration party now tied in polls with governing Social Democrats
South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott has filed paperwork to run for president of the United States, according to a Federal Election Commission filing.
Charlotte City Council member Braxton Winston has thrown his hat in the ring in the 2024 race as a Democratic candidate for North Carolina’s Commissioner of Labor.
The lawyer for a white pregnant New York City physician’s assistant who was vilified as a racist on social media after a confrontation with a group of young black men who claimed that one of them paid for a city bike she was taking has reportedly produced receipts showing she paid for the bike.



Back to Top