Legislative leaders, Leandro plaintiffs clash over court-ordered N.C. education spending | Eastern North Carolina Now | Legislative leaders and Leandro plaintiffs offer contrasting arguments to the N.C. Supreme Court in the latest stage of the long-running education funding lawsuit.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Less than a month before the N.C. Supreme Court takes its latest look at the long-running Leandro school funding lawsuit, state legislative leaders and Leandro plaintiffs are unveiling their competing arguments.

    Those arguments arrive in new briefs filed Monday with the state's highest court.

    Justices will determine whether a trial judge can order state government to spend an additional $785 million on education-related expenses. That money is tied to a court-sanctioned comprehensive remedial plan written to help resolve the Leandro dispute.

    The state Supreme Court will also decide whether a trial judge can force state government officials to transfer money out of the state treasury without input from the General Assembly. Judge David Lee ordered a forced money transfer of $1.75 billion in connection with Leandro in November 2021.

    Lee's successor in the Leandro case, Judge Michael Robinson, dropped the forced money transfer in April and cut the size of Lee's order from $1.75 billion to $785 million.

    Legislative leaders say "no" to both the court-ordered spending and the forced money transfer. They argue that Leandro court proceedings have turned into a joint venture between the lawsuit's plaintiffs and state government's executive branch to secure more taxpayer money for education. That's been true since longtime Leandro trial Judge Howard Manning stepped down from the case in 2016, lawmakers assert.

    "Plaintiffs hope to make an end-run around the legislative process - capitalizing on the Executive Branch's cooperation and the lack of any genuine adversarial proceedings in the years since Judge Manning's retirement to wrest control of the State's education system from the people and their representatives so they can dictate how North Carolina's public school system will be administered and funded through judicial orders," wrote attorney Matthew Tilley, who represents top legislative officers.

    "No doubt, Plaintiffs mean to do good. Indeed, Legislative-Intervenors do not doubt that Plaintiffs sincerely believe the Comprehensive Remedial Plan ('CRP') they developed in cooperation with the Executive Branch is a 'good plan,'" Tilley added. "That does not entitle them, however, to an exemption from the legislative process or to substitute their judgment for that of the people's elected representatives. Nor does it entitle them to spend public money without an appropriation as required under the Appropriations Clause found in Article V, Section 7 of the State Constitution."

    On the other side of the case, Leandro plaintiffs point to the General Assembly's failure to comply with its constitutional duties.

    "This case is - and has always been - about the fundamental constitutional right of every child in North Carolina to the opportunity to receive a sound basic education in the public schools," wrote plaintiff's attorney Melanie Black Dubis. "This case is now also about the General Assembly's disregard of its affirmative constitutional duty to 'guard and protect' that fundamental right for over two decades. In light of the State's admitted and continuing constitutional violations, and after 17 years of deference to the other two branches of government, the trial court was correct to order certain state actors to transfer the funds necessary to implement the only constitutional remedy before it."

    A second set of intervening plaintiffs' echoed Dubis' concerns.

    "This is no ordinary case. It is a case that demands a remedy consistent with the judiciary's duties and powers to right constitutional wrongs," wrote attorney Christopher Brook. "That wrong here is a violation of a constitutional right that this Court has deemed paramount and fundamental. It is a violation of an affirmative constitutional obligation due from the Defendants State of North Carolina and State Board of Education ... to ensure all children ... have the opportunity for a sound basic education."

    "It is a continuing violation that has spanned at least 17 years and remains without a remedy, as the harms have mounted with each class passing through the halls in dismal, inadequate learning conditions - conditions even worse for the state's at-risk students," Brook added. "It is a violation identified by the judiciary, but on which the trial court has deferred again and again to the executive and legislative branches to present a remedy to no avail, until 2021."

    Lawyers from Attorney General Josh Stein's N.C. Justice Department took aim at legislators' arguments.

    "Strikingly, Legislative Intervenors' sudden desire to actively relitigate this case comes after years of refusing to participate - either in litigation or through legislative enactments," wrote Senior Deputy Attorney General Amar Majmundar. "But their arguments and approach, rather than finally showing a true willingness to become constructively involved, provide further evidence that the legislative leaders are either unable - or simply unwilling - to lead their respective chambers to fulfill the State's constitutional duty to provide a sound, basic education for all of its children."

    Final briefs in the case are due Aug. 12. The state Supreme Court will hear oral arguments Aug. 31. Justices will issue a decision at an undetermined later date.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

[State Board of Elections] State Board Extends Public Comment Period for Two Proposed Rules Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Chicago Health System pays $10M over vaxx mandate


Latest State and Federal

Health officials from the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services today announced the state’s first death this year associated with West Nile virus. To protect the family's privacy, no other information regarding the deceased will be provided.
The Child and Adult Care Food Program helps eligible children and adults access healthy, nutritious food by reimbursing qualified child care programs, adult day programs and other non-residential care programs for meals and snacks served to participants.
To ensure beneficiaries can seamlessly receive care on day one, the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services will delay the implementation of the NC Medicaid Managed Care Behavioral Health and Intellectual/Developmental Disabilities Tailored Plans until April 1, 2023.
As North Carolinians begin to feel the impacts, including power outages and flooding, from the remnants of Hurricane Ian, officials from the NC Department of Health and Human Services are urging residents to properly prepare for impacts from the storm.
Pope Francis asked for prayers on Sunday ahead of a trip this week to the former Soviet republic of Kazakhstan for an international meeting with religious leaders.
Russia announced Saturday that it is pulling back troops from two areas as Ukraine’s counteroffensive advances in the country’s eastern region.
The North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services is working with the U.S. Department of Agriculture to help prevent the spread of rabies. Starting next week, Wildlife Services will be distributing oral rabies vaccine for wild raccoons in Western North Carolina.
N.C. State Budget Director Charlie Perusse will retire Nov. 1 after serving in the role for Democratic Governors Mike Easley, Bev Perdue, and now Roy Cooper. Cooper announced on Monday that Perusse’s successor will be Deputy Budget Director Kristin Walker, who has served in her role since 2017.
The North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services will host a live fireside chat and tele-town hall on Tuesday, Sept. 20, 6-7 p.m., to discuss updated COVID-19 boosters, testing and treatments, as well as the flu and monkeypox vaccines.


Back to Top