Cooper, Stein hope to influence redistricting rehearing at NC Supreme Court | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Gov. Roy Cooper and N.C. Attorney General Josh Stein, both Democrats, argue against Republican legislative leaders in a new court filing at the N.C. Supreme Court.

    Cooper and Stein filed a motion Friday to submit a friend-of-the-court brief in this month's rehearing of the Harper v. Hall redistricting case.

    Friday marked the deadline for briefs opposing state lawmakers in two cases scheduled for rehearing. The high court will reconsider Harper v. Hall on March 14. It will hold new arguments in the Holmes v. Moore voter identification case on March 15.

    "Our state constitution is meant to establish a democracy, under which the people of our State are empowered to choose their representatives, not the other way around," according to the motion from Cooper and Stein, signed by N.C. Solicitor General Ryan Park. "Partisan gerrymandering subverts our democracy by allowing legislators to manipulate district lines to entrench themselves in power."

    "Given the profound importance of these issues for the governance of our State, the Governor and the Attorney General previously filed amicus briefs in earlier appeals in these cases, asking this Court to hold that partisan gerrymandering violates our state constitution," Park added. "This Court, after hearing those arguments, correctly held that '[p]artisan gerrymandering of legislative and congressional districts violates' multiple provisions of our state constitution."

    "Now, Legislative Defendants ask this Court to take the extraordinary step of overruling this precedent, simply because the composition of this Court recently changed," Park argued. "Legislative Defendants also seek this Court's blessing to, once again, draw districts to predetermine the result of future elections to the greatest extent possible."

    "Granting this relief would undermine respect for our State's judiciary and the rule of law, by showing that the weight of the Court's precedents depends on the composition of its membership," according to the motion setting out Cooper's and Stein's views. "But more fundamentally, granting this relief would also have grave consequences for the future of self-government in our State. Because overruling Harper would so profoundly undermine the government in which the Governor and the Attorney General were elected to serve, they have strong interests in being heard."

    On Dec. 16, little more than one month after N.C. voters replaced two Democratic state Supreme Court justices with Republicans, the outgoing court's 4-3 Democratic majority issued party-line decisions in two cases that ruled against Republican legislative leaders.

    In the Harper v. Hall redistricting case, the high court threw out Republican legislators' state Senate election map and confirmed a lower court's decision to throw out a congressional election map. In Holmes v. Moore, the 4-3 Democratic majority affirmed a party-line trial court ruling throwing out the state's 2018 photo voter ID law.

    The new state Supreme Court, with a 5-2 Republican majority, granted lawmakers' request to rehear both cases.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

State Supreme Court to hear cases dealing with speedway shutdown, UNC fees Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal State Supreme Court reinstates order blocking Leandro forced money transfer


Latest State and Federal

“The world needs more fossil fuels,” according to Alex Epstein, founder of the Center for Industrial Progress. Epstein argues that the benefits of energy sources such as oil, coal, and natural gas far outweigh the costs.
Two recent news stories about educational institutions in our state illustrate the truth of that statement.
As lawmakers in the General Assembly are poised to consider a bill that would streamline the process of approving new charter schools, a statewide charter advocacy organization reports that more than 77,000 students remain on waitlists to join charter schools.
Even a supposed federal government watchdog has gone radically woke, prompting harsh criticism from conservatives.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis announced on Tuesday that he is sending more than 1,100 assets to Texas to assist Governor Greg Abbott in combatting the illegal immigration crisis that President Joe Biden caused on the southern border with his policies.
Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador accused the Pentagon of spying on Mexico’s government, vowing to safeguard classified military information to protect its national security after a spate of documents leaked in U.S. media.
America is in freefall. Cities are crumbling, with open drug abuse and homeless everywhere, overdose deaths are soaring, there’s a mental health epidemic, and then there are the crises, oh the crises: the border, the federal debt, lack of affordable housing, flat-out unaffordable health care.
On Tuesday, the House Health Committee will consider several bills that critics say are likely to raise insurance costs for consumers.
Refusing to look inward, opponents of school choice insist the only thing needed to improve public schools is more money


The North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services will host a live Cafecito and Spanish-language tele-town hall on Wednesday, April 26, from 6 to 7 p.m.
Former U.S. Attorney General William Barr said during an interview this week that special counsel John Durham’s report on the origins of the FBI’s investigation into former President Donald Trump “vindicated” the former president and that Trump was right from the beginning
A woman arrested during an April 2020 ReOpenNC COVID shutdown protest is suing the governor, the city of Raleigh, and state and local law enforcement officials. She argues that defendants violated her constitutional rights.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis hit back at Donald Trump on Tuesday over a criticism the former president leveled at DeSantis’ decision to sign a six-week abortion ban into law.
A barrage of Russian missiles damaged a U.S.-made Patriot air defense system near Kyiv early Tuesday morning, weeks after the $1 billion system shot a Russian hypersonic missile out of the sky.
Daily Wire editor emeritus Ben Shapiro on Tuesday said that the Durham report released the day prior detailed “one of the most shocking scandals in the history of American law enforcement.”
In a much-anticipated rally at Ace Speedway in Elon, Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson declared his candidacy for governor of N.C., joining N.C. State Treasurer Dale Folwell in the Republican primary field.
The monthly local jobs report reveals unemployment rates and related economic indicators at the county level.


Back to Top