JLF Report Urges ‘Reverse Logrolling’ Approach to N.C. Budget Deal | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's note: The author of this post is the CJ Staff, who is a contributor to the Carolina Journal, John Hood Publisher.

Method would offers increased flexibility for tax reform, Medicaid expenses

    RALEIGH     North Carolina legislators can maximize their flexibility for tax reform and unanticipated Medicaid spending by using a "reverse logrolling" approach to the final state budget deal. That's the conclusion of a new John Locke Foundation Spotlight report.

    This approach would lead to surpluses of almost $600 million in the new budget year that starts July 1, and almost $1 billion in 2014-15, before taking tax reform into account.

    "Traditional logrolling is a tried-and-true tactic in which lawmakers otherwise predisposed not to favor an expenditure or program agree to support it because fellow lawmakers agree to do the same for other items," said report author Sarah Curry, JLF Director of Fiscal Policy Studies. "This practice often results in a poor outcome for average citizens, as lower-priority or so-called 'pork-barrel' items are funded and mediocre legislation enacted."

    "Reverse logrolling flips this practice on its head," Curry explained. "Rather than one set of budget negotiators accepting particular programs or higher levels of spending from their counterparts, with the expectation that those counterparts will do the same, legislators should agree to accept the lower spending numbers for each departmental budget."

    "After all, a majority of voters in at least one chamber already has decided that the expenditure in question will satisfy citizens' needs under current budgetary constraints," Curry said.

    The report offers a department-by-department listing of potential savings from the reverse logrolling approach. For example, the total education budget would be $11.422 billion in 2013-14, roughly $56 million less than the House plan and $67 million less than the Senate's proposal. State Health and Human Services spending would total $4.975 billion in the first year of the two-year budget plan, about $8 million less than the Senate plan and $44 million less than the House budget.

    The bottom line is a $20.6 billion General Fund budget in 2013-14, and a $20.8 billion General Fund budget the following year, Curry said. "This leaves approximately $594 million in surplus in the first year and more than $940 million in the second year without tax reform adjustments."

    Factoring in the revenue changes linked to competing tax reform proposals, lawmakers would see $851 million in surplus over two years with the Senate plan, and $1.1 billion from the House plan.

    Those numbers also incorporate an "ever-growing" Medicaid shortfall, which was expected to reach $330 million by the time the report was finalized. That shortfall had been pegged at $123 million when the governor released his original budget plan.

    "Even with significant tax reform changes and a large, unanticipated Medicaid shortfall, the legislature still has many options," Curry said. "If state budget negotiators use the reverse logrolling method and leave their chamber's pride at the door, then everyone will benefit from the large surplus, taxpayers and state government alike."
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

CJ Flashback: Rural Center Under Fire John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics #NCSEN Poll: Brannon, Berger are Hagan's strongest GOP foes


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Former President Donald Trump was fined hundreds of millions of dollars in a civil fraud trial on Friday and was banned from running his businesses in the state for three years.
Former President Trump's civil trial in New York has concluded with Judge Arthur Engoron ordering that Trump pay whatever dollar amount is necessary to bankrupt his Presidential campaign.
The Senate passed a $95 billion foreign aid bill early Tuesday morning that allocates money for Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan. The bill passed on a 70-29 vote, with over half of Senate Republicans voting against the measure.
Tom and I got married on a cold December Wednesday in the Ayden Christian Church at three o’clock in the afternoon.
A news report published on Wednesday undercuts President Joe Biden‘s criticism of special counsel Robert Hur over an investigation into the commander-in-chief’s handling of classified documents.
The state Supreme Court will take another look at a 29-year-old court case dealing with state education funding.
Kansas City Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce admitted to letting his emotions get the best of him during Sunday’s Super Bowl matchup against the San Francisco 49ers.
In a powerful moment during last week's episode of SNL, the show's brilliant writers and comedians produced an unfunny comedy sketch to show the world that antisemitism is no laughing matter.


Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) is reportedly urging Republicans in the Senate to vote against a border bill that was unveiled in the Democrat-controlled chamber on Monday.
RALEIGH: Today, Governor Roy Cooper announced judicial appointments to North Carolina Superior and District Courts.
New footage emerged this week of the moment a private jet attempted to land on an interstate in Florida after experiencing catastrophic engine failure and ended up crashing and bursting into flames.
A day after being forced out of the University of Pennsylvania, Liz Magill has been announced as the new President of the Hamas Institute of Technology.
A judge ruled Monday that the divorce case of Nathan Wade, who is the special prosecutor in the Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis’ racketeering and election interference case against former President Donald Trump, be made public.
The state Supreme Court will not take up a case involving Winston-Salem State University's 2019 decision to fire its football coach. A unanimous state Appeals Court had ruled against former coach Kienus Boulware.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis shot down a longshot measure on Monday night that would use Florida taxpayer money to pay for former President Donald Trump’s legal bills.
The State Board of Elections has launched a multifaceted public education campaign designed to ensure the state’s 7.5 million registered voters know that they will be asked for photo identification when voting in 2024.


Back to Top