Banned from the Legislature | Eastern North Carolina Now

Tom Campbell
    Few of us like it when others disagree with us. Fewer still like it when others protest our actions, but elected or appointed public officials have to recognize that disagreements and sometimes protests come with the territory. Often these protests are respectful and are dealt with responsibly, however the recent instance where 32 people were banned from entering our legislature is troubling on several fronts.

    On May 30th, more than 100 people assembled in the legislative building petitioning for better healthcare. 32 conducted a sit-down in front of legislative leaders' offices. When the Capitol Police ordered the protestors to clear the hallways they refused, were arrested on charges of second-degree trespassing and taken to jail. As a condition for their release from jail, Wake County Magistrate Jeffrey Godwin banned them from again entering the legislative building.

    Our first concern is whether any magistrate has (or should have) the authority to ban anyone from any public building. Magistrates are not generally lawyers and, while they have prescribed authorities we can't find banning people from public buildings among them. Here are the qualifications to become a magistrate in North Carolina. First, magistrates have to be a resident of the county to which they are appointed. Secondly, the appointee must have one of the following: be a college graduate, have 8 years of experience as the clerk of superior court or have a two-year associate degree and 4 years of experience in a related field. Godwin appears to have exceeded his authority in this case.

    Our second concern regards the constitutionality of the action. Article 1, Section 12 of the North Carolina Constitution states clearly, "The people have a right to assemble together to consult for their common good, to instruct their representatives, and to apply to the General Assembly for redress of grievances...." There have been more than 1,000 arrests at the legislative building since 2013. In one instance where protestors were banned, a court overturned the edict as a violation of a citizen's right to assemble and instruct their representatives.

    That raises our third concern. While everyone has the right to assemble and even to protest, no one should have the right to be violent or disruptive so as to preclude public officials from the conduct of their duties. There is evidence that the protestors became very loud and blocked the entranceway to lawmakers' offices. We can certainly understand the frustration that results when lawmakers or other elected officials refuse to meet with or hear people's concerns, but we wonder whether the groups motives in this instance were to meet with lawmakers or to create a disturbance to the point of getting arrested.

    Finally, we are concerned by the reactions of our legislators to this and similar protests. In recent decades we have witnessed a reduction in access to and a corresponding unwillingness by legislators to meet with groups petitioning them. Perhaps the disruptive noise and sit-ins might have been avoided if the representatives had been more responsive and willing to listen to and dialogue with them. We will never know because the protestors never had that opportunity.

    This instance represents the state of our political climate today. This culture will only change when there is a willingness by all to be more responsive, respectful and responsible.

    Publisher's note: Tom Campbell is former assistant North Carolina State Treasurer and is creator/host of NC SPIN, a weekly statewide television discussion of NC issues airing Sundays at 11:00 am on WITN-TV. Contact Tom at NC Spin.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




Tillis Statement on the Senate Health Care Discussion Draft My Spin, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Tillis Statement on DHS Commitment to Expand H-2B Visas for FY2017


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

After suffering a record-tying 28th straight loss, basketball fans across the country and the other 29 NBA teams voted unanimously to demote the Detroit Pistons to the WNBA.
David Draiman, the lead singer of the heavy metal band Disturbed, paused in the middle of a concert to give an impassioned speech about Israel, saying of Hamas’ claims that they were “freedom fighters,” “Freedom fighters, my f***ing a**.”
The North Carolina Supreme Court heard arguments recently in a lawsuit brought by The Society for the Historical Preservation of the 26th North Carolina Troops against the City of Asheville over the removal of a monument
Independent presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has secured a spot on the ballots in Arizona and Georgia, according to the political action committee backing his White House bid.
Like many other states, the North Carolina has received a lot of money from the federal government to address the impacts of the corona virus pandemic.
A local wife began training to join her regional women's hockey team when she discovered the grand prize for winners of the National Hockey League is a Stanley Cup.
it is time to prosecture them for election interference

HbAD1

A Chinese national was detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement after the bust of a massive marijuana operation in rural south Georgia last week.
Felon voting advocates argue in a new court filing that North Carolina's new election law should have no impact on their federal lawsuit.
That is one that was stopped how many weren't stopped
The game show “Jeopardy!,” in which gives contestants must give answers in the form of a question, embraced the woke agenda by including so-called “neo-pronouns” as an answer.
City employing all-of-government effort aimed at finding work for illegal immigrants, emails indicate
Embattled former New York Congressman George Santos has landed on his feet following his ouster from the U.S. House of Representatives, with the announcement that he has been hired as a fact-checker at The New York Times.
Former President Donald Trump won Michigan’s Republican Party presidential primary on Tuesday night, beating former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley by more than 30 points.

HbAD2

 
Back to Top