Choice And Regulation Form Spectrum | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's note: This article appeared on John Hood's daily column in the Carolina Journal, which, because of Author / Publisher Hood, is linked to the John Locke Foundation.

    BURLINGTON     Parental choice in education is popular. About a fifth of North Carolina students are educated outside of district-run public schools, and this share will probably grow to a quarter or more in the coming years.

    The North Carolina Institute of Political Leadership, a nonpartisan organization that schools candidates in how to run for and serve in public office, is sponsoring a series of "Hometown Debates" on education. Its Oct. 16 forum at the historic Paramount Theater in Burlington focused on the question of whether tax-funded schools of choice, chartered public schools or scholarship-accepting private schools, ought to be more heavily regulated by the state.

    Two of the panelists at the debate, State Rep. Graig Meyer (D-Orange) and North Carolina Justice Center policy analyst Matt Ellinwood, said yes. They argued that because taxpayers are footing at least some of the bill, their representatives in state government are entitled to ask more questions, demand more measurements, and exercise more oversight.

    "We don't have any way of assessing student performance in voucher-funded schools right now," Meyer said during the debate, broadcast on television by Spectrum News and on radio by the North Carolina News Network. "And so we can't even do an apples-to-apples comparison on the very limited basis of the state testing that we use. So we don't know whether that's a good investment for our kids or for our public."

    The other two panelists at the IOPL debate, state Rep. Jeff Elmore (R-Wilkes) and John Locke Foundation Vice President Terry Stoops, opposed heavier regulation.

    Elmore argued that while private schools accepting state-funded opportunity scholarships don't have to administer North Carolina's own end-of-grade exams, they are required to administer a nationally normed test. "So in a way, really, what privates are allowed to do, it gives us a better nationwide comparison as a policymaker looking at the bigger numbers," said Elmore, who works as a public-school teacher when the legislature isn't in session.

    Many private-school parents appreciate this fact. They often lack confidence in state-generated tests, for good reason, and find their annual reports from the Iowa Test of Basic Skills or other independent national assessments to be useful and reliable.

    During his remarks, Stoops argued that top-down accountability based on tests isn't the only answer. Bottom-up accountability based on parental choice employs scores along with information about other concerns such as school safety, discipline, shared values, or post-graduation success. "We shouldn't just narrow it down to test scores," Stoops said.

    Do parents always make the best choices? It depends on your definition of "best." Perfection is impossible. And as Ellinwood pointed out, some innovations in such fields as virtual learning haven't always delivered on their initial promises.

    On balance, however, there is likely no better mechanism for identifying and replicating successful schools over time than allowing parents to make choices - and for education dollars to follow those choices.

    The knowledge problem here is enormous. Some educational approaches work better than others in general, but not for every child or in every situation (such as when teachers aren't trained or don't really believe in the curriculum or techniques in question).

    In my view, the right model for the tradeoff between school autonomy and regulation is a spectrum. District-run public schools receive the most money from government and thus merit the most oversight by public officials. Chartered public schools get somewhat less tax money and deserve more freedom. Private schools in which some students enroll with government subsidy deserve still more freedom, but a few requirements are necessary to give families useful consumer information. And private or home schools that receive no government appropriations should for the most part simply be left alone.

    Imposing tight regulation on scholarship programs won't deter desperate private schools of dubious quality from seeking to participate. But it may create too high a paperwork burden for high-performing private schools that aren't hurting for students. That would be a perverse outcome - the kind of outcome in which politicians seem to specialize.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




ESPN Suspends Host Jemele Hill Over Tweets Calling For A Boycott Of NFL Sponsors Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Second Hometown Debate Tackles Charter School Accountability


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Pope Francis lambasted leftist gender ideology during an address this week, warning that it presented an extreme danger to mankind.
amnesty would just encourage more illegal aliens to storm our borders
The Christmas candy was barely off the shelves when the Valentine’s candy appeared. Red and pink hearts with caramel and nut-filled chocolate goodness caught our eye. We are reminded of how we love love. Young love, especially.
far left sugar daddy has also funded anti-Israel groups and politicians in US
Be careful what you wish for, you may get it
America needs to wake up and get its priorities right

HbAD1

Former President Donald Trump suggested this week that if he becomes president again, he might allow Prince Harry to be deported.
It's a New Year, which means it's time to make resolutions — even for prominent evangelical leaders. The Babylon Bee asked the following well-known figures in the faith what they hope to accomplish in 2024:
Vice President Kamala Harris will visit a Minnesota Planned Parenthood clinic, reportedly the first time a president or vice president has visited an abortion facility.
An eight-mile stretch of the Blue Ridge Parkway near Asheville has been temporarily closed due to a string of “human and bear interactions,” the National Parks Service announced.
University of Wisconsin tried to punish conservatives for the fact that liberals regularly commit crimes to silence opposition
most voters think EU officials not doing a good job on illegal immigration

HbAD2

Come from behind by GOP candidate is a blueprint to 2024

HbAD3

 
Back to Top