Did You Know? Survey Finds Trouble in Campus Support for Free Speech | Beaufort County Now | The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) came out with the largest survey of students and campus life, showing the predictable divisions along class, political beliefs, and gender. | james g. martin center, did you know, survey, campus support, free speech, october 8, 2020

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Did You Know? Survey Finds Trouble in Campus Support for Free Speech

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of The James G. Martin Center. The author of this post is Sumantra Maitra.

    The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) came out with the largest survey of students and campus life, showing the predictable divisions along class, political beliefs, and gender. However, overall, it painted a scenario that is mostly positive, and policy reforms can fix the drawbacks.

    FIRE surveyed 20,000 students across 55 institutions. Female students reported less tolerance for speakers than male students, and LGBT students reported less tolerance for speakers than their straight counterparts. Likewise, African American students were less tolerant of dissenting views than Hispanic, Asian, and white students.

    Students at Ivy League schools are more favorable toward using violence to stop speech. A total of 21 percent expressed some form of acceptance toward violence, with 1 percent saying it was always acceptable and 3 percent saying that violence is sometimes acceptable. Compared to that, 18 percent of students nationally thought violence was acceptable.

    Liberals prefer violence more than conservative students, with atheists and African American students at around 25 percent approval, and LGBT students at around 27 percent approval.

    Likewise, students who are self-declared "extreme-liberals" find violence always acceptable at a much higher rate than average liberals and conservatives.

    This variation is also in line with socio-economic strata. For example, 10 percent of students at Columbia say violence is "always" or "sometimes" acceptable, and 23 percent say it is "rarely" acceptable. At Rutgers, 12 percent of students think violence is "always" or "sometimes" acceptable. That is more than double the national average. At Brigham Young University, however, only 2 percent of students said violence was sometimes acceptable. Absolutely no students at BYU said that it was "always acceptable."

    Among critical free speech issues, censorious tendencies seem to be rising, but these tendencies follow liberal social norms prevalent among the American elite and upper-middle class. For example, around 71 percent of students "strongly" oppose an advocate who would argue or speak on the racial difference in intelligence.

    A majority of students would also oppose speech for anyone saying anything controversial like transgenderism is a mental disorder, or that Black Lives Matters is a hate group (51 percent and 50 percent, respectively.)

    When it comes to self-censorship, about 60 percent of students self-censored at least once, in fear of how others would respond. Men and women are equal in their self-censorship (61 percent), but conservatives self-censor at a higher rate than liberals, for fear of causing offense or ostracism, which is around 72 percent for conservatives and around 55 percent for liberals.

    Around 73 percent of self-described "strong Republicans" self-censor, compared to around 52 percent of self-declared "strong Democrats." Only 15 percent of students can publicly disagree with a professor comfortably about a controversial topic, and only 11 percent of women feel comfortable doing it, compared to 19 percent of men.

    The overall American trend isn't much different from Canada, where there have been free speech problems. The rising tide against free speech is a cross-continental trend, as the Martin Center's recent Blueprint for Reform briefs also suggested.

    The University of Chicago came highest in the survey, gaining a green light rating and the top post for freedom of speech, with DePauw University being the worst. The Ivy League underperformed compared to national results, with Harvard earning a red light rating. Both UNC and Duke performed well, getting green lights in the final survey.

    Sumantra Maitra is a doctoral scholar at the University of Nottingham, UK; he is a columnist for Providence Magazine and a senior contributor to The Federalist.


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Rep. Keith Kidwell will chair the Banking and Finance Committees (Finance is the "tax" committee)
So many families are dealing with it. Someone close to you is troubled to the point that you’re worried about their future.
Back in the 15th, 16th, and 17th centuries, church officials felt it necessary to scrutinize every book or pamphlet for the slightest hint of heresy.
While an annual report from a financial watchdog shows most U.S. cities are poorly prepared to face the fiscal fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic, the three North Carolina cities examined showed stronger numbers.
The State Board of Elections will hold a remote meeting beginning at 11:00 a.m. on Tuesday, February 23, 2021.
Ghislaine Maxwell is hoping a judge will drop the federal sex-trafficking charges against her thanks to Jeffrey Epstein’s 2007 plea deal, which was supposed to protect himself and his close contacts from sex-trafficking charges.


Sheriff Coleman gives big raises while many taxpayers in Beaufort County are hurting badly
The coronavirus pandemic has created a window of opportunity for school choice, says a panel of experts at a John Locke Foundation Shaftesbury.
The Constitution Party and the Green Party are no longer recognized political parties in North Carolina.
Inez Feltscher Stepman writes for the Federalist about the odd cast of characters engaged in the recent Capitol violence.
Mairead McArdle writes for National Review Online about one high-profile Republican senator’s response to the second impeachment of Donald Trump.


A Texas man who took part in the Capitol riots earlier this month has been hit with new charges related to him allegedly threatening to “assassinate” the radically liberal Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY).


Back to Top