Scrapping the Electoral College Would Bring About Negative Unintended Consequences | Beaufort County Now | Those who want to get rid of the Electoral College might reconsider their views after scanning Richard Brookhiser’s recent history lesson on the topic in American History magazine. | john locke foundation, electoral college, getting rid of electoral college, unintended consequences, december 8, 2020

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Scrapping the Electoral College Would Bring About Negative Unintended Consequences

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Mitch Kokai.

    Those who want to get rid of the Electoral College might reconsider their views after scanning Richard Brookhiser's recent history lesson on the topic in American History magazine.

  • Is the Electoral College still a shield against fraud? Foreign countries have been trying to influence American elections as far back as 1796, when France was threatening grave consequences unless a Francophile candidate, meaning Jefferson, won, and as recently as 2016, when Russia reached out to the Trump campaign with multiple tentacles. But foreigners could not tamper with the vote.
  • One unintended consequence of the Electoral College may be the blunting of homegrown vote-stealing in presidential contests. Every political machine tries to thumb the scale, but perhaps only in 1844 did that tip an election. Historian Daniel Walker Howe argues that Henry Clay lost New York's electoral votes, and thus the race, not only because the abolitionist Liberty Party diverted anti-slavery Whigs from Clay — the view taught in textbooks — but also through Tammany Hall skullduggery on behalf of victor James Polk. Richard Nixon's 1960 campaign, believing vote stealing had thrown that contest to JFK, demanded recounts in several states. When Illinois, one of the largest, examined its returns, officials found fraud, but not enough to have changed the result. A recount in Hawaii actually moved that state from Nixon's to Kennedy's column.
  • Targeting decisive races in a continent-sized republic is difficult enough for the purposes of ordinary campaigning. For vote stealing it is a more difficult undertaking yet.
  • In a tight race decided by a national popular vote, however, any vote stolen anywhere would be worthwhile. The temptation to run up one's candidate's tally would be almost irresistible — and none would resist. National recounts would inevitably follow, like nightmares after a bad dinner. Such a system could work only with a national voter ID card.


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

In the forthcoming print edition of Carolina Journal, I make the case that the General Assembly should expand Second Amendment protections in North Carolina.
Back in the 15th, 16th, and 17th centuries, church officials felt it necessary to scrutinize every book or pamphlet for the slightest hint of heresy.
On the first day of bill filling, House Majority Leader John Bell (R-Wayne) filed legislation (HB 6) to provide $215 million for the construction of a new Brody School of Medicine facility at East Carolina University.
Editors at Issues and Insights are preparing for a greater crackdown on conservative voices.
Nobody runs for Governor hoping he or she will be confronted with a major disaster while in office. At least we hope not.
With President Biden in the White House and Democrats in control of both houses of Congress, conservatives are bracing for a flurry of policy changes on issues they care about.
Rep. Keith Kidwell will chair the Banking and Finance Committees (Finance is the "tax" committee)
So many families are dealing with it. Someone close to you is troubled to the point that you’re worried about their future.


While an annual report from a financial watchdog shows most U.S. cities are poorly prepared to face the fiscal fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic, the three North Carolina cities examined showed stronger numbers.
The State Board of Elections will hold a remote meeting beginning at 11:00 a.m. on Tuesday, February 23, 2021.
Ghislaine Maxwell is hoping a judge will drop the federal sex-trafficking charges against her thanks to Jeffrey Epstein’s 2007 plea deal, which was supposed to protect himself and his close contacts from sex-trafficking charges.
Sheriff Coleman gives big raises while many taxpayers in Beaufort County are hurting badly
The coronavirus pandemic has created a window of opportunity for school choice, says a panel of experts at a John Locke Foundation Shaftesbury.
The Constitution Party and the Green Party are no longer recognized political parties in North Carolina.
Inez Feltscher Stepman writes for the Federalist about the odd cast of characters engaged in the recent Capitol violence.
Mairead McArdle writes for National Review Online about one high-profile Republican senator’s response to the second impeachment of Donald Trump.


A Texas man who took part in the Capitol riots earlier this month has been hit with new charges related to him allegedly threatening to “assassinate” the radically liberal Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY).
Today, America's second Fake Impeachment of Donald J. Trump, just days before he leaves office, may speak more about those Impeaching the President than he who is indicted.
Days after leaving office, former President Donald Trump has reportedly floated the idea of forming his own political party.
On Monday night, GOP Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell declared that his battle to keep the Senate filibuster in place had been won.
We will offer this allotment of three with more to come; some old, most new, but all quite informative, and, moreover, necessary to understanding that in North Carolina, there is a wiser path to govern ourselves and our People.
Cindy McCain, the widow of the late Republican Senator John McCain, has broken her silence after being censored by the Arizona GOP for supporting Joe Biden over Donald Trump in the last presidential election.
In a letter the local directors spell out the shortcomings of the state's mismanagement of the supply of vaccines
N.C. Attorney General Josh Stein wants lawmakers to use millions won from a settlement with Dish Network for violating telemarketing laws to expand internet access for students, but legislative leaders are so far non-committal on the proposal.


Back to Top