Unanimous Appeals Court Gives Property Owner Mixed News in Fight With Apex | Eastern NC Now

A property owner fighting with the town of Apex over an illegally installed sewer line got mixed news this morning from the N.C. Court of Appeals.

ENCNow
Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Mitch Kokai.

    A property owner fighting with the town of Apex over an illegally installed sewer line got mixed news this morning from the N.C. Court of Appeals.

    The unanimous three-judge appellate panel will not force Apex to remove the sewer line on Beverly Rubin's property. But the court agrees that Rubin could file a new trespass claim against the town that could eventually lead to the sewer pipe's removal.

    It's a case that involved a friend-of-the-court brief from the John Locke Foundation supporting Rubin.

    Judge Lucy Inman explained the court's objection to Apex's arguments. The town contended that the only relief Rubin could expect in the case is payment for the violation of her property rights.

  • Plaintiff-Appellee Town of Apex ("the Town") asks this Court to uphold the Town's continuing intrusion onto the land of a private citizen through a circuitous and strained application of North Carolina law on eminent domain and inverse condemnations. The Town's position, in essence and when taken to its logical conclusion, is as follows: (1) if a municipality occupies and takes a person's private property for no public purpose whatsoever, that private landowner can do nothing to physically recover her land or oust the municipality; (2) if the encroachment decreases the property's value, then the landowner's sole remedy is compensation by inverse condemnation; and (3) in all other instances, a landowner is powerless to recover or otherwise vindicate her constitutional rights. This is not the law, nor can it be consistent with our Federal and State Constitutions.

    Despite Apex's flawed legal arguments, Inman and her colleagues refused to grant Rubin's request: a court order for the sewer line to be removed.

  • We agree with Ms. Rubin that mandatory injunctive relief may be available to her, but hold that it is not available in the direct condemnation action that was taken to final judgment without a request for or adjudication concerning the availability of injunctive relief. Instead, she may pursue mandatory injunctive relief against the Town to remedy its continuing encroachment through a claim for trespass.

    In other words, Rubin would need to pursue another legal case if she still wants to have the sewer pipe removed.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published )
Enter Your Comment ( text only please )




School Closings as Examples of ‘Systemic Racism’ John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Critical Race Theory Foe Offers Ideas for Fighting It


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Owen O’Kane has his sights set on medical school in West Virginia, but the place he is working toward is much closer to home.
now Democrats are reluctant to give Trump DOT the $50 Billion needed to fix it

HbAD1

The outcome of the 2026 elections require evaluation for why they turned out as they did.
Democrats want to make government less affordable to citizens
Film critic Tyler Smith builds a streaming platform after suffering a horrifying illness.
Islamists threaten rape and murder police do nothing

HbAD2

yet the Democrats want to saddle our taxpayers and our economy with this madness
Discrimination, Exclusion, and Indoctrination (DEI) is in Democrats plans

HbAD3

 
 
Back to Top