Superior Court Judge Dismisses Latest Legal Challenge Against CON | Beaufort County Now | A Durham County Superior Court judge has dismissed a New Bern eye surgeon’s lawsuit challenging the state’s certificate-of-need law.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

Dr. Jay Singleton can't perform a five-minute cataract surgery without admitting his patients to a hospital. | Photo: Contributed

    A Durham County Superior Court judge has dismissed a New Bern eye surgeon's lawsuit challenging the state's certificate-of-need law.

    Judge Michael O'Foghludha heard roughly two hours of arguments Thursday, June 3, before agreeing with state lawyers' motion to kill the suit. The ruling can be appealed.

    Dr. Jay Singleton argues that North Carolina's CON law is unconstitutional when applied to him.

    Singleton has performed more than 30,000 eye surgeries. State law allows him to perform outpatient procedures like cataract surgeries at his New Bern-based Singleton Vision Center on an "incidental, limited basis." But state regulators force the doctor to perform most of those same procedures at a hospital.

    Requiring patients to use a hospital increases cost and decreases convenience, Singleton argues. That's despite the fact that performing the procedures at Singleton Vision Center is just as safe as the hospital option, according to Singleton's argument.

    If appellate courts eventually allow the case to proceed, Singleton hopes to have CON restrictions struck down for his business. The John Locke Foundation has filed a friend-of-the-court brief supporting Singleton's case.

    Singleton's case represents CON opponents' "third bite at the apple" in challenging the law. That's according to Derek Hunter, the assistant state attorney general representing state government defendants.

    The state's appellate courts upheld the CON law as constitutional as recently as 2010, in the case of Hope-A Women's Cancer Ctr., P.A. v. State. Just last year, Hunter argued, courts dismissed an almost-identical challenge to CON from a Winston-Salem surgeon, Dr. Gajendra Singh.

    Singleton's lawyer countered that the state argues that Singleton "needs to go begging" to government regulators, spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to win the certificate of need. That certificate would grant him state government permission to perform the additional procedures he wants to offer customers at Singleton Vision Center.

    "He doesn't want a CON — he doesn't want to be a monopolist," said Renee Flaherty, the Institute for Justice attorney representing Singleton.

    O'Foghludha rejected the state's argument that Singleton's case should be tossed because the doctor never applied to secure a CON. But the judge agreed with state lawyers that the CON law should be upheld based on a legal test known as "rational basis."

    Under that test, a law is constitutional if legislators could have had any "rational basis" for approving it. That's a much easier standard for the government to meet than "strict scrutiny." That's an alternative legal standard courts can adopt when a plaintiff argues that his fundamental constitutional rights have been violated.
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

On Friday, famed actor James Woods, an outspoken conservative, which makes him an anomaly in the vast leftism of Hollywood, tweeted a photo of a rib-eye steak with its exorbitant price and added one rapidly mushrooming meme.
Last week, the Martin Center reported on the UNC system’s mandated move to Raleigh in 2022. Now, members of the UNC Board of Governors are questioning the speed and the process behind the decision.
State Controller Linda Combs is going to court to block a recent ruling in the long-running Leandro school funding case.
Next week we are entering the most critical time of any election. Registration to run in the November 2022 elections begins tomorrow, Monday December 6 at 12:00 Noon and ends Friday December 17 at 12:00 Noon.
Former “Today” show contributor and “Access Hollywood” host Billy Bush blasted NBC on Friday, the fifth anniversary of the day he was fired for a recorded private conversation he had with then-Presidential candidate Donald Trump when Trump was a guest on “Access Hollywood.”
oday, Governor Roy Cooper and Attorney General Josh Stein filed an amicus brief in the North Carolina Supreme Court that urges the Court to quickly hear and decide two cases that challenge the constitutionality of congressional and state legislative districts enacted by the Republican members.

HbAD1

President Biden is no different from the rest of us. He’s living his life, browsing in a store over a holiday weekend.
To preserve liberty, it is essential that the whole body of the people always possess arms and be taught how to use them.
On Monday, a Virginia juvenile court essentially found a 15-year-old guilty (the word “guilty” is not used in juvenile court) of sexually assaulting a fellow classmate in a girls’ bathroom at a high school in Loudoun County, Virginia.
Supreme Court stops legislative, Congressional filing
Face it. Everyone has someone on their list for whom it is difficult to shop. What do they like? Is it the right color or size? Do they already have it?

HbAD2

If the state Supreme Court decides to remove two Republican justices from hearing a high-profile case involving voter ID, the court also should remove Democratic Justice Anita Earls. That’s according to a new motion filed Wednesday in the case.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top