Appeals Court blocks ruling favoring DEQ in animal waste regulation dispute | Eastern North Carolina Now | The N.C. Court of Appeals has granted a temporary stay in the N.C. Farm Bureau Federation's challenge of state animal waste regulations.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    A unanimous panel of the N.C. Court of Appeals has blocked a lower court ruling that would have allowed state environmental regulators to move forward with disputed animal waste regulations.

    The panel issued an order Thursday granting a temporary stay to the N.C. Farm Bureau Federation. The Farm Bureau objects to a trial judge's June 20 decision allowing the regulations to move forward.

    The case could have implications for more than 2,000 N.C. farms with hogs, cattle, and poultry. The farms use a "lagoon-and-spray-field system" to address animal waste.

    "In this case, Farm Bureau challenges the validity of three identical conditions that appear in three general permits that regulate certain animal waste activities that occur on the State's cattle, swine, and wet waste poultry farms," according to the Farm Bureau's petition to the Appeals Court. "Specifically, Farm Bureau contends that DEQ's inclusion of the three conditions in the permits (i.e., groundwater monitoring, phosphorus loss assessment tool analysis, and the filing of annual reports) violates North Carolina's Administrative Procedure Act."

    "If imposed, the three conditions will require Farm Bureau's farmer members who hold animal waste general permits to incur additional production and operational costs, comply with unnecessary and burdensome administrative requirements, restrict the use of their property, and invade the privacy of their business operations, including increasing the likelihood of disclosure of their confidential and other protected commercial business information," according to Farm Bureau attorneys.

    "Once the conditions are enforced, the resulting harm cannot be undone. Farmers cannot recover the cost of installing wells or acquiring new fields from the State, and confidential information, once disclosed, is not easily retrieved, if it ever can be."

    The Farm Bureau started the legal fight in 2019. It argues that the disputed conditions were rules that should have proceeded through the state's standard rule-making process, as set out in the APA. The Farm Bureau also argues that the conditions first appeared in a "draft swine general permit that DEQ developed behind closed doors with several nonprofit organizations." The complaint contends that DEQ never subjected that draft permit to mandated public review and comment.

    The Office of Administrative Hearings issued rulings in the case favoring the Farm Bureau, but a Superior Court judge revived the disputed conditions after state officials appealed. The N.C. Environmental Justice Network and N.C. NAACP also have intervened in the case to defend DEQ's position.

    "Farmers who operate under the animal waste permits will sustain irreparable harm if this Court fails to stay DEQ from enforcing the three conditions pending appeal," Farm Bureau attorneys argued. "Once enforced, the three conditions will make it more difficult for farmers to compete in the marketplace, make a profit, attract additional investment, and stay in business."

    The new conditions require "substantial capital and operating costs" and a larger regulatory burden, the Farm Bureau argued. "The increased costs to comply with the three conditions could not come at a worse time as the State's farmers struggle with the very real impacts that inflation and increased fuel costs are having on their operations."

    DEQ and the intervening groups will have a chance to respond before the Appeals Court decides whether to extend its temporary stay.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Parent says Chatham County public school teacher bullied daughter for faith Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Lawmakers grill Cooper team on six-year lag in hurricane recovery


Latest State and Federal

The Child and Adult Care Food Program helps eligible children and adults access healthy, nutritious food by reimbursing qualified child care programs, adult day programs and other non-residential care programs for meals and snacks served to participants.
To ensure beneficiaries can seamlessly receive care on day one, the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services will delay the implementation of the NC Medicaid Managed Care Behavioral Health and Intellectual/Developmental Disabilities Tailored Plans until April 1, 2023.
As North Carolinians begin to feel the impacts, including power outages and flooding, from the remnants of Hurricane Ian, officials from the NC Department of Health and Human Services are urging residents to properly prepare for impacts from the storm.
Pope Francis asked for prayers on Sunday ahead of a trip this week to the former Soviet republic of Kazakhstan for an international meeting with religious leaders.
Russia announced Saturday that it is pulling back troops from two areas as Ukraine’s counteroffensive advances in the country’s eastern region.
The North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services is working with the U.S. Department of Agriculture to help prevent the spread of rabies. Starting next week, Wildlife Services will be distributing oral rabies vaccine for wild raccoons in Western North Carolina.
N.C. State Budget Director Charlie Perusse will retire Nov. 1 after serving in the role for Democratic Governors Mike Easley, Bev Perdue, and now Roy Cooper. Cooper announced on Monday that Perusse’s successor will be Deputy Budget Director Kristin Walker, who has served in her role since 2017.
The North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services will host a live fireside chat and tele-town hall on Tuesday, Sept. 20, 6-7 p.m., to discuss updated COVID-19 boosters, testing and treatments, as well as the flu and monkeypox vaccines.
The N.C. Court of Appeals has granted a temporary stay in the N.C. Farm Bureau Federation's challenge of state animal waste regulations.


City leaders remain mostly ambivalent to the rising crime in one of the most popular US tourist destinations
Public health officials from the North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services are encouraging residents and visitors to take precautions to prevent mosquito-borne illness following recent cases of West Nile virus in several parts of the state.
North Carolina honored by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation & the National Academy for State Health Policy with 2022 Medicaid Innovation Award
An Army paratrooper stationed at Fort Bragg in Fayetteville, North Carolina, died after being shot outside his apartment.
Suicide is among the top five leading causes of death for people ages 10 to 65 in North Carolina.
A 17-year-old has been charged with first-degree murder in the brutal killings of two North Carolina teenagers, whose bodies were found with numerous bullet wounds.
The State Board of Elections will hold a remote meeting beginning at 9 a.m. Tuesday, September 20, 2022.
A Brunswick County charter school operator is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to reverse a lower court's decision to strike down the school's student dress code.


Back to Top