Clerk takes leave from N.C. Supreme Court while campaigning for state House | Eastern North Carolina Now | A state Supreme Court law clerk is taking a leave of absence while he runs for a seat in the N.C. House of Representatives.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    A law clerk at the N.C. Supreme Court is taking a leave of absence while he campaigns for a seat in the state House of Representatives. Tim Longest's boss announced that decision in an order issued Sunday.

    Longest, the Democratic candidate in N.C. House District 34, has clerked since August 2020 for Justice Robin Hudson, a fellow Democrat. Hudson is the state Supreme Court's senior associate justice.

    The order announcing Longest's leave arrived two days after Republican legislative leaders filed paperwork questioning his potential participation in a case dealing with state election maps. That case, Harper v. Hall, is scheduled for oral arguments before the state Supreme Court Tuesday.

    Legislators had filed a "motion for clarification" Friday about Longest's role in Harper v. Hall.

    "In order to preserve the confidentiality and separation of information concerning the inner workings of a Justice's chambers, as recognized in the Motion filed by the Legislative Defendants, the Motion for Clarification is resolved as follows: Mr. Tim Longest is taking a leave of absence from his clerkship in the chambers of Justice Hudson, effective 1 October 2022, and has and will have no participation of any kind in the consideration of any case yet to be decided by the Court, including all aspects of this case, until further notice, but at least until after the election of November 2022," according to the order signed by Hudson.

    Hudson then dismissed legislators' motion as moot.

    Legislative leaders indicated on Friday that they would seek Hudson's recusal from the Harper v. Hall case if Longest had played any role in the case after becoming a state House candidate.

    "It would be a clear conflict of interest for anyone in the judicial branch to have meaningful involvement in litigation over legislative district boundaries while, at the same time, running for legislative office," wrote attorney Phillip Strach. "Accordingly, Legislative Defendants presume Mr. Longest has been walled off from any activity in the remedial phase of this appeal."

    "However, Legislative Defendants have no way to ascertain whether this in fact occurred," Strach added. "Accordingly, they respectfully request an assurance from Justice Hudson that Mr. Longest has been appropriately screened from any involvement in this matter. Alternatively, if this assurance cannot be made, Legislative Defendants move for Mr. Longest's recusal from this matter."

    Harper v. Hall will not affect election maps used for this fall's elections. The case's outcome could determine whether lawmakers will redraw maps again for the 2024 election cycle.

    The Wake County Democratic Party appointed Longest on July 26 to run as the Democratic candidate in House District 34.

    "Mr. Longest has been endorsed by the North Carolina League of Conservation Voters PAC, ... an endorsement Mr. Longest has advertised," Strach wrote. "NCLCV is among the lead plaintiffs in this lawsuit and is appealing the Superior Court's ruling concerning legislative districts."

    Longest's district has changed during the legal fight tied to Harper v. Hall. "Thus, this Court's Harper ruling directly impacts the configuration of HD-34, and its ultimately ruling on this appeal will again directly impact its configuration."

    Legislative defendants "have no way to know whether Mr. Longest is currently involved in this appeal," Strach added. "Legislative Defendants at this time have assumed that this did not occur and that Mr. Longest has been appropriately screened off from this case. They file this motion out of an abundance of caution in order to obtain assurance that such screening has occurred."

    "There can be no serious question that Mr. Longest cannot ethically be involved in this case," Strach wrote.

    "If Mr. Longest has not been screened from this case since filing to run for office, in addition to seeking his recusal, Legislative Defendants have little choice but to seek Justice Hudson's recusal," Strach wrote.

    Plaintiffs filed their own paperwork Friday opposing Hudson's recusal from the case.

    "Legislative Defendants respectfully request that Justice Hudson take appropriate steps to disclose the facts relevant to the conflict of interest of Mr. Longest and take appropriate measures to cure any conflict that may have come into existence at any time," the motion added.

    Longest replaced incumbent Rep. Grier Martin as the Democratic nominee in House District 34. Martin resigned from office on July 8 to take a new job with the Pentagon.

    Longest faces Republican Ashley Seshul and Libertarian Kat McDonald in the general election, The John Locke Foundation's Civitas Partisan Index rates House District 34 as a "safe Democratic" seat.

    Hudson is retiring from the state Supreme Court when her term ends this year. N.C. Court of Appeals Judges Richard Dietz, a Republican, and Lucy Inman, a Democrat, are running in an election for the open seat.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Bill introduced in Congress to allow states to deport illegal aliens Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics U.S. Supreme Court declines to take up N.C. State Health Plan dispute


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

In a surprise reversal from over 6 years of opposition, Democrats in Congress have officially endorsed Donald Trump for President in 2024 after he called for the suspension of the U.S. Constitution on TRUTH Social.
Deion Sanders, known as “Prime Time” for his legendary football career, accepted an offer from the University of Colorado Saturday night to become the school’s next head football coach.
As a youth growing up in a United States of America that understood the pain of sacrifice, the remembrance of Pearl Harbor was an annual event.
Twitter’s former head of trust and safety claimed Friday night that Twitter CEO Elon Musk was putting people’s lives in danger by revealing internal company documents showing how employees censored conservatives and a negative news story about then-presidential candidate Joe Biden’s son.
Local boy Linus Van Pelt has been permanently banned from the local community theater, after an episode in which he commandeered a play rehearsal and began reciting from the Bible.
A number of interest groups launched efforts on Wednesday to encourage a crackdown on organized retail crime at the federal level.
Twitter is entertaining and informative under the benevolent internet king Elon Musk.
During a courageous public statement denouncing Adolph Hitler in 2022, President Joe Biden deviated from his prepared remarks and recounted the time he personally faced off against Hitler while working as a lifeguard
The U.S. Military unveiled its new strategic long-range stealth bomber this week, Northrop Grumman’s B-21 Raider, which will serve as the backbone of the future for U.S. air power for decades to come.


Back to Top