NC Appeals Court wrestles with latest pension spiking dispute | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The N.C. Appeals Court will decide in the coming months whether the Harnett County school system must pay $197,000 to resolve a pension-spiking case. An appellate panel heard oral arguments Monday.

    The State Treasurer's Retirement Systems Division says the school system owes the money to comply with provisions of a 2014 state law against pension spiking.

    The school board disagrees. The board paid the money but has pursued a refund. School lawyers argue that the retirement division refused to refund the money, even though earlier court rulings made the $197,000 assessment invalid.

    Attorney Lindsay Vance Smith used a family game to make the Harnett County school board's case.

    "Imagine you're playing monopoly with your kids," she said. "Your daughter lands on Boardwalk, which isn't owned by anyone, so she doesn't have to pay anything."

    A few turns later, your son buys Boardwalk, Smith continued. "He puts a hotel on it, then he goes to your daughter and demands that she pay him rent for the night that she spent on Boardwalk a couple of turns previously."

    "I think you would rightfully instruct your son that's not fair," Smith said. "That's not how we play the game."

    N.C. Solicitor General Ryan Park, representing the State Retirement Division, countered with a different Monopoly scenario.

    "There is a rule that says you have to get a certain amount of money when you pass 'Go,'" Park explained. "And that's the statute here. ... The dad says it's $200, and so they operate under the $200 for a couple of years. Then the mom comes along later and says, 'Yep, that's $200.' Therefore, under the rules of the family, it's set at $200."

    Park argues that the $197,000 pension-spiking contribution has not changed because of any prior court rulings. He says state law gives the retirement system little discretion in setting the formula that determines Harnett County's contribution.

    "There's really only a narrow range of numbers that the retirement system could possibly choose," Park said. "It's just a number, and there really isn't a lot of policymaking discretion."

    It's the latest legal dispute tied to implementation of the state Fiscal Integrity Act of 2014. It was designed to fight "pension spiking." That practice occurs when employers give employees large pay raises near the end of their careers that boost their retirement benefits. Critics argue that those pay increases leave the pension fund short of contributions that should help fund the benefits.

    The 2014 law set a contribution-based benefit cap on state retirement benefits. For affected employees who had been members of the pension fund before 2015, the law required a retiree's last employer to pay money into the system to cover any shortfall in the amount of funding expected to cover the retirement benefit.

    The law also required the retirement division to adopt a "cap factor" to determine when government employers would need to pay the lump sum, known as an "additional contribution."

    Four local school boards went to court. They argued that the retirement division should have gone through the state's rule-making process when adopting the "cap factor." The state Supreme Court agreed in 2020.

    During that legal fight, the retirement division pursued the state's rulemaking process. It adopted a cap factor through that process effective March 2019.

    Multiple legal challenges related to the assessments have moved through the state court system.

    There's no deadline for Judges Hunter Murphy, Tobias Hampson, and Michael Stading to issue a decision.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

NC Appeals Court ponders dispute over Currituck’s tourism tax money Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Voters prefer Robinson over Stein, DeSantis over Biden and Trump in 2024 matchups


Latest State and Federal

The State Board of Elections will hold an in-person meeting at 10 a.m. on Tuesday, March 28, 2023. The meeting will be held in the Surry County Courthouse, 201 E. Kapp St., Dobson, N.C.
BlackRock CEO Larry Fink told investors on Wednesday that the asset management company views climate change as a risk to portfolio companies.
North Carolina Democrat Gov. Roy Cooper gave his fourth and final State of the State address Monday night to what appeared to be, at times, a divided room between Democrats and Republicans.
Fox News regular Geraldo Rivera voiced his frustration on Tuesday with Republicans who are continuing to investigate President Joe Biden’s embattled son Hunter, telling them to “put up or shut up.”
President Joe Biden made the unlikely claim Tuesday that it is Republicans who are pushing for “defunding the police,” despite near universal GOP support for law enforcement and the fact that cutting police budgets was his own party’s rallying cry in 2020.
Eight months after an Illinois woman reported her husband missing, she found him dead in their home.


Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson, the assumed Republican primary frontrunner for North Carolina governor in the 2024 election, was a keynote speaker at CPAC in Maryland on Saturday.
The Republican Party establishment erupted in anger at Florida Governor Ron DeSantis after he told Tucker Carlson Ukraine is not a vital interest of the U.S. and the White House should be trying to broker peace instead of offering a “blank check.”
The N.C. Supreme Court has reinstated a lower court's order blocking a forced money transfer in the Leandro education funding case.
California Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom cheered the federal government’s decision to protect Silicon Valley Bank’s depositors without mentioning that he is one of them.
The state of Ohio filed a lawsuit against rail company Norfolk Southern in federal court on Tuesday over the train derailment in East Palestine and subsequent chemical fallout.
Students at a woman-only private liberal arts college in Massachusetts supported a non-binding referendum on Tuesday that would allow women who identify as men and “non-binary” individuals to apply to the institution.


Artificial intelligence software development firm OpenAI released GPT-4, its latest AI language model, with a massive array of new capabilities.


Back to Top