Media coalition targets Charlotte public records dispute at NC Appeals Court | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    A coalition of media groups is taking interest in a public records dispute at the N.C. Court of Appeals. The case involves WBTV's request for surveys completed by members of the Charlotte City Council in late 2020.

    The coalition filed paperwork Thursday seeking permission to file a friend-of-the-court brief in the case. The court granted the request Friday. The group opposes a trial court's decision rejecting WBTV's attempt to access the surveys.

    The city argued it did not have possession of the surveys and couldn't provide them to a WBTV reporter. The coalition challenging that argument includes McClatchy, the parent company of the Raleigh News and Observer and Charlotte Observer, along with WRAL-TV.

    "This case concerns whether a government agency may disclaim its obligations to disclose records under the Public Records Act, ...on the ground that the requested documents are in the actual possession of a third-party contractor, even when the agency has retained control over those records," according to the media group's court filing. "The answer to this question will have broad ramifications for government transparency in North Carolina. If this narrow interpretation of the Act is adopted, agencies could avoid scrutiny simply by transferring records to private parties."

    The media group argued "vital journalism would be hampered - and sometimes impossible - if the government's interpretation of the Act is adopted."

    "[C]ourts in multiple states have ruled that records are still subject to disclosure if the government is in constructive control of them, regardless of whether they are in the actual possession of a third party," according to the filing.

    WBTV explained the reason for its record request when filing suit.

    "The City of Charlotte Council members famously can't get along. Like other companies that turn to team-building exercises such as ropes courses and trust falls, Charlotte hired outside consulting firm Ernst & Young, signing a multi-year contract worth up to $400,000. But unlike other companies, the City of Charlotte ... is a public agency subject to the North Carolina Public Records Act, and City taxpayers are entitled to review how their tax dollars are being spent," according to the initial complaint.

    The television station sought access to surveys city council members completed in connection with the Ernst and Young contract. "This information was solicited from these public officers as part of EY's consulting services to the City, and the firm analyzed Council members' responses in order to provide recommendations on how they could learn to better work together. The survey work alone cost the City $46,500."

    "The contract between Charlotte and EY clearly states that the City has exclusive ownership of the Council members' survey responses," according to the lawsuit. "But in letters denying WBTV's public records requests, the City claims that because the survey responses are not in the City's custody, it does not have to produce these surveys. The City's position is plainly in violation of North Carolina law."

    "[P]ublic records provided to Plaintiff indicate that Defendants ordered EY to dispose of at least one survey response and to not collect Council member responses to certain survey questions," WBTV argued. The TV station "believes the City did so to evade the creation and maintenance of public records in response to requests like WBTV's."

    The lawsuit asked the court to declare that the surveys are public records, that Charlotte must collect them from the contractor and make them available "for inspection and examination," and that any city request for Ernst and Young to dispose of records violated state law.

    In addition to McClatchy and WRAL-TV, the media coalition features Gannett, Sinclair Broadcast Group, N.C. Press Association, N.C. Open Government Coalition, Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, Center for Investigative Reporting, Committee to Protect Journalists, Freedom of the Press Foundation, International Documentary Association, Media Institute, National Association of Black Journalists, National Freedom of Information Coalition, National Newspaper Association, National Press Club, National Press Club Journalism Institute, National Press Photographers Association, News/Media Alliance, Radio Television Digital News Association, Society of Environmental Journalists, Society of Professional Journalists, and Student Press Law Center.

    The Appeals Court has not scheduled a hearing in the case.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




As Mark Robinson moves toward run for governor, media pounces Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal Cooper vetoes gun bill, including pistol purchase permit repeal


HbAD0

Latest State and Federal

Former President Donald Trump suggested this week that if he becomes president again, he might allow Prince Harry to be deported.
Vice President Kamala Harris will visit a Minnesota Planned Parenthood clinic, reportedly the first time a president or vice president has visited an abortion facility.
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) said this week that the only campaign promise President Joe Biden has delivered on as president is the complete dismantling of the U.S. southern border.
Hamas is reeling after losing two of their most cherished leaders on the same day: military commander Saleh al-Arouri, and Harvard President Claudine Gay.
President Joe Biden’s brother told the Internal Revenue Service that Hunter Biden told him he was in business with a “protege of President Xi,” referring to the leader of China, according to notes by an IRS investigator that were divulged during a congressional interview of Jim Biden.
That’s the question Marguerite Roza of Georgetown University’s Edunomics Lab sought to answer in a recent webinar on the topic.

HbAD1

The University of Florida has fired all of its diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) employees and shut down its DEI office.
Glenn Beck: 'When the United States government can come after individuals, that's when you know our republic is crumbling.'
Rep. Mark Green (R-TN) reportedly blasted Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas for “stonewalling” details about the illegal immigrant accused of murdering Laken Riley, a 22-year-old Georgia college student.
“The Biden administration's plan in the Middle East is to hand over power to the Palestinian Authority, which literally pays the families of terrorists who murder Jews.”
Two Democratic members of North Carolina’s congressional delegation are ranked among the most likely to be picked off in 2024, according to a new analysis from Roll Call.

HbAD2

Former President Donald Trump dominated the North Dakota Republican Caucus on Monday as he continues to inch closer to officially securing the party’s presidential nomination.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top