HB 447, Restore Teaching Fellows Program | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's note: This post, by Bob Luebke, was originally published in the Bad Bill of the Week section of Civitas's online edition.

    Facing a multi-billion dollar budget deficit in 2011, the state legislature reduced and eliminated a variety of programs in order to balance the budget. One program the legislature ended future funding for was the North Carolina Teaching Fellows program. The Teaching Fellows program awarded renewable scholarships of up to $6,500 annually to 500 high school students who were interested in becoming teachers and who promised to work in North Carolina public schools for at least four years after graduation.

    Recently state Reps. Deb McManus (D-Chatham) and Joe Sam Queen (D-Haywood) introduced legislation (HB 447, Restore Teaching Fellows Program) to provide $3.25 million to restore the North Carolina Teaching Fellows program for this year and subsequent years.

    Understandably, eliminating the Teaching Fellows program produced an outcry of support from teachers, alumni and other supporters of the program. Still there were valid reasons why the state stopped funding it.

    The Teaching Fellows program was created in 1986 as part of a 10-point teacher recruitment plan. At the time North Carolina population and student enrollment was increasing at record rates and more teachers were needed. Those conditions don't exist today. With all the cutbacks and demographic changes, North Carolina actually has 231 fewer teachers than in 2009-10.

    While there is no denying there are areas of growth, we can't forget that almost half of North Carolina's counties are expected to lose population in the coming years. There are areas where teachers are in demand, but the problem is a maldistribution of teachers, not a shortage.

    How are localized shortages addressed? North Carolina is contracting with Teach for America to serve parts of North Carolina. So far the experiment has worked well for both sides. Alternative certification programs can also help to meet the need. Both of these options can help to meet the need for teachers at far less cost than Teaching Fellows.

    And speaking of cost, it's important to note the bill requests $3.5 million for tuition and scholarships. However, that is only for one class of teachers. In subsequent years, second- third- and fourth-year classes would also be added. Hence, the $3.5 million figure is really $14 million to keep the program running. Add to that another $810,000 annually - the amount think tank Public School Forum of NC was being paid to administer the program - and you're looking at a very different bill.

    In 2009, the News & Observer ran a story about the difficulty Teaching Fellows were having finding jobs. According to the state's Department of Public Instruction, less than half of all graduates of UNC education schools had a job in education a year after graduating. Yes, it's true the job market is slightly better than in 2009, but that's not saying much. Teachers with math and science background have better options, but an informal check in 2011 revealed only a smattering of Teaching Fellows had such a background. It's unlikely the figure has changed much since then.

    Program supporters say Teaching Fellows shouldn't be eliminated because the program is working. They forget that North Carolina is not where it was in 1986, nor is the demand for teachers.

    An abundance of research attests to the important link between quality teaching and student achievement. North Carolina needs quality teachers more than it needs more teachers. While the Teaching Fellows program has certainly produced some good teachers, our needs today are different.

    Because it ignores the ability to improve teacher quality through other less expensive options, (professional development, alternative certification, raising academic standards, etc.), and conceals the true long-term costs, restarting the Teaching Fellows program is a bad idea for North Carolina, and makes HB 447 this week's Bad Bill of the Week.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Cyprus can't happen HERE, huh? (Guess what? Big Barry wants your 401K.) Civitas Institute, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics The VOTER ID saga: House goes wobbly while Senate doubles down


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

The Biden administration announced on Wednesday that it would be canceling oil and gas leases in the Arctic National Wildlife Preserve and move to ban drilling in Alaska’s National Petroleum Reserve.
Comedian Bill Maher slammed the media for not covering the scandals involving Hunter Biden, noting that if former President Donald Trump’s eldest son, Donald Trump Jr., engaged in the same behavior it would be covered constantly.
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg dropped his appeal of a ruling that determined a former prosecutor from his office must testify to the GOP-led House Judiciary Committee about the criminal investigation into former President Donald Trump.
President Joe Biden told a story at a Manhattan campaign event, appearing completely oblivious to the fact that — just moments earlier — he had told the exact same story, almost word for word.
Members of the UNC System’s Board of Governors and UNC-Chapel Hill’s Board of Trustees are asking questions and offering pushback to university administrators following a “surprise” announcement last week
Democratic legislators in California are pushing to establish diversity audits of gubernatorial appointments.


Fox News has scored exclusive TV rights for what many are already calling the debate of the century. The political bloodbath will pit Gavin Newsom, governor of the state people are fleeing from in terror, against Ron DeSantis, governor of the state people are fleeing to.
Thousands of parents in Mexico took to the streets last week to burn education materials that featured “Marxist-communist” indoctrination from the country’s department of education.
A federal judge ruled on Wednesday that former President Donald Trump is liable for allegedly making defamatory remarks about writer E. Jean Carroll after she first publicly accused him four years ago of sexually assaulting her at a Manhattan department store during the mid-1990s.
North Carolina U.S. Sens. Ted Budd and Thom Tillis are among a contingent of 10 Republican senators seeking answers from the Department of Justice (DOJ) about seven “service centers” with ties to the Chinese Communist Party operating across the U.S.
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) said this week that he believes that Democrats will likely seek to replace President Joe Biden ahead of the 2024 presidential election and that they will do so by bringing in Michelle Obama.
Since June 1, at least 18,000 people have lost health care coverage who likely would have been able to keep it under Medicaid Expansion


“Sound of Freedom” is dominating in 18 Latin American countries after it took over the number one spot at the box office on its opening weekend following the film’s release on August 31.


Back to Top