SB 150: Paging Karl Marx | Beaufort County Now | One of the ten planks of Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto is "Centralization of credit in the hands of the State." Apparently of like mind is North Carolina state Senator Ellie Kinnaird (D-Orange), primary sponsor of Senate Bill 150, Study State-Owned Banks. | Karl Marx, Communist Manifesto, SB 150, Centralization of credit in the hands of the State, Senator Ellie, Kinnaird D-Orange

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

SB 150: Paging Karl Marx

    Publisher's note: This post, by Brian Balfour, was originally published in the Bad Bill of the Week section(s) of Civitas's online edition.

    One of the ten planks of Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto is "Centralization of credit in the hands of the State." Apparently of like mind is North Carolina state Senator Ellie Kinnaird (D-Orange), primary sponsor of Senate Bill 150, Study State-Owned Banks.

    Basically, the "state-owned bank" would take taxpayer dollars, then loan these funds to select businesses (including privately owned banks). You don't think there'd be any political preferences to who receives these loans, do you? And what interest rates would the state-owned bank charge - would they reflect the riskiness of the loans and the market's rate of time preference?

    Moreover, the bill states that "excess earnings" of the bank could be "used to supplement General Fund purposes." But what if the bank loses money? By definition a state-owned bank would primarily be lending to investments deemed unworthy by private lending institutions, meaning the state-owned bank's loan portfolio would be especially high-risk. Is there any doubt North Carolina taxpayers would be forced to bail it out? Have we learned nothing about the dangers of the system of socialized risk from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac?

    Worse still is this: Kinnaird's bill represents another shift of power from individuals to the political class. By establishing a state-owned bank, decisions over creditworthy business investments would be centralized to a purely political organization, rather than left in the hands of private citizens. In a free society, however, the use of scarce resources and means of production is dictated by consumers - based according to their purchasing decisions. Capital goods, land, labor and other resources are directed toward satisfying the most urgent needs of consumers.

    Under a state-owned bank, unaccountable political appointees will determine which investments are funded, and in turn determine the use of the means of production. Scarce resources are used not in response to the needs of the masses, but rather according to the whims of the political class. More power is taken from the many and concentrated in the hands of the few.

    Because it takes a page out of the Karl Marx playbook, and would further erode freedom by politicizing more of our economy, SB 150 is this week's Bad Bill of the Week.

    Posted on May 24, 2013 by Brian Balfour in Bad Bill of the Week

    One of the ten planks of Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto is "Centralization of credit in the hands of the State." Apparently of like mind is North Carolina state Senator Ellie Kinnaird (D-Orange), primary sponsor of Senate Bill 150, Study State-Owned Banks.

    Basically, the "state-owned bank" would take taxpayer dollars, then loan these funds to select businesses (including privately owned banks). You don't think there'd be any political preferences to who receives these loans, do you? And what interest rates would the state-owned bank charge - would they reflect the riskiness of the loans and the market's rate of time preference?

    Moreover, the bill states that "excess earnings" of the bank could be "used to supplement General Fund purposes." But what if the bank loses money? By definition a state-owned bank would primarily be lending to investments deemed unworthy by private lending institutions, meaning the state-owned bank's loan portfolio would be especially high-risk. Is there any doubt North Carolina taxpayers would be forced to bail it out? Have we learned nothing about the dangers of the system of socialized risk from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac?

    Worse still is this: Kinnaird's bill represents another shift of power from individuals to the political class. By establishing a state-owned bank, decisions over creditworthy business investments would be centralized to a purely political organization, rather than left in the hands of private citizens. In a free society, however, the use of scarce resources and means of production is dictated by consumers - based according to their purchasing decisions. Capital goods, land, labor and other resources are directed toward satisfying the most urgent needs of consumers.

    Under a state-owned bank, unaccountable political appointees will determine which investments are funded, and in turn determine the use of the means of production. Scarce resources are used not in response to the needs of the masses, but rather according to the whims of the political class. More power is taken from the many and concentrated in the hands of the few.

    Because it takes a page out of the Karl Marx playbook, and would further erode freedom by politicizing more of our economy, SB 150 is this week's Bad Bill of the Week.


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Gov. Roy Cooper has signed into law House Bill 4, extending the delay on payment deadlines for the renewal of certain alcohol permits.
Our legislators were correct in forcing the issue to reopen our schools.
A government watchdog criticized a plan by the Guilford County Board of Commissioners that could send $7 million to High Point to help pay for improvements around Truist Point ballpark, home of the High Point Rockers minor league baseball team.
The answer is that each of us must take a stand and stop accepting the unacceptable

HbAD1

Suppose you’re a donor interested in steering a college in a more sensible direction with your grants.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper announced that the State is offering a reward of up to $20,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible for the murders of Tammy Lynette Pearce, Dominique Nicole Privette, Paul Shane Pearce and Selby Gene Outland.
Stephen Gutowski of the Washington Free Beacon reports on new legislation designed to protect military veterans’ basic rights.
A group of Wake County parents has written Gov. Roy Cooper asking him to reopen schools for in-person instruction.
Facebook posted an update Wednesday on their current response to the Feb. 1 military coup in Myanmar that has continued to spark protests and violence in the country.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper announced that the State is offering a reward of up to $5,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible for the murder of Reginald Tyrice Edwards, age 34.

HbAD2

Brandon Morse of RedState.com dissects the latest pronouncement from the Biden administration’s chief spokeswoman.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top