Pope Francis, Religious Liberty, and Capitalism | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's note: The author of this post is Dr. Roy Cordato, who is Vice President for Research and Resident Scholar for the Carolina Journal.

    RALEIGH     As part of his remarks while visiting the White House on his first day in the United States, Pope Francis made a strong plea on behalf of religious liberty, which he specifically directed at President Obama. This came shortly before he made an unscheduled visit with the Little Sisters of the Poor, who are suing the Obama administration in defense of their own First Amendment rights not to include coverage of artificial contraception as part of their health insurance plan, which is mandated by Obamacare regulations.

    Catholic teaching views the use of artificial contraception as sinful. The connection between his comments to the president and his visit with the Little Sisters was apparent.

    This laudable and welcome stance comes from a Pope who has, out of a concern for the poor, made several misguided statements that are quite critical of capitalism. I would suggest that these two positions, while seemingly unrelated, when combined represent a profound contradiction in the Pope's thinking. In reality, the only socio-economic arrangement that can guarantee the rights of all people to exercise their religious beliefs freely is capitalism, with its emphasis on the rights of people to own and use property as they wish and to contract freely with others on any mutually agreeable terms.

    It is a system that is based strictly on voluntary cooperation and that delegitimizes the use of force and fraud. (As an aside, I personally think that, for this reason, it is the system most consistent with Christianity.) Under such institutional arrangements, there would be no need for specific legal or constitutional protections for religious liberty. These liberties are inherent in the system itself.

    Consider, for example, the contraception mandate that is being challenged by the Little Sisters of the Poor. This mandate, a word that gives the game away at the outset, comes in direct conflict with one of the most basic rights under capitalism; that is the right to trade and make contracts freely with others.

    Under true capitalism - or "unfettered capitalism," which is what some have suggested the Pope has been referring to - coverage under any health insurance policy purchased by the Little Sisters of the Poor would be a private matter among the Little Sisters, their insurance company, and possibly any employees who would also be covered under the plan.

    If the health insurance plan that was being offered by the insurance company was unacceptable to the Little Sisters, for whatever reason, they would be free to walk away from it or negotiate different coverage with the insurance company. And if the health insurance offered by the Little Sisters to any of their employees were an unacceptable part of their compensation package, they too would be free to walk away and find employment elsewhere or forgo the employer-provided insurance and purchase a separate plan of their own choosing.

    From the perspective of the employees, this could occur as part of an exchange with the Little Sisters, their employers, for a higher wage. All of this would happen without a need for any specific discussion about religious liberty.

    Clearly the right to worship as one chooses would be pretty hollow without the right to own or contract for the rental of physical property. The right to worship implies the right of a religious organization to have physical space to assemble, to worship in that space as they see fit. Without this fundamental property right, which is only guaranteed without question under capitalism, the right to worship freely as one chooses is tentative at best and at nonexistent at worst.

    The right to deny religious liberties stems from the power of government to deny the right to use property freely. When the USSR wanted to shut down the Catholic Church, it didn't simply tell people that they weren't allow to say bedtime prayers - it confiscated their churches.

    This does not end with religious liberties. Indeed, property rights and free exchange are at the heart of one's ability to exercise what have come to be known as civil liberties more generally. The right to freedom of speech and of the press and the right freely to assemble, protest, boycott, etc., are all fundamental rights that are guaranteed under capitalism.

    This is because capitalism guarantees our right to disagree with one another, which is really what is being protected when all of these other liberties are being discussed. In this regard it would be useful for Pope Francis to pay attention to the words of a rather famous atheist, Ayn Rand, who noted that:

  • The right to agree with others is not a problem in any society; it is the right to disagree that is crucial. It is the institution of private property that protects and implements the right to disagree.

    Holy Father, religious liberty is nothing more than the right to disagree.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




Community Colleges Looking at 'Earning Gains' Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Tillis: Secretary Mabus Out Of Step On Camp Lejeune Water Contamination


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

far left sugar daddy has also funded anti-Israel groups and politicians in US
Be careful what you wish for, you may get it
America needs to wake up and get its priorities right
Former President Donald Trump suggested this week that if he becomes president again, he might allow Prince Harry to be deported.
It's a New Year, which means it's time to make resolutions — even for prominent evangelical leaders. The Babylon Bee asked the following well-known figures in the faith what they hope to accomplish in 2024:
Vice President Kamala Harris will visit a Minnesota Planned Parenthood clinic, reportedly the first time a president or vice president has visited an abortion facility.

HbAD1

An eight-mile stretch of the Blue Ridge Parkway near Asheville has been temporarily closed due to a string of “human and bear interactions,” the National Parks Service announced.
University of Wisconsin tried to punish conservatives for the fact that liberals regularly commit crimes to silence opposition
most voters think EU officials not doing a good job on illegal immigration
Come from behind by GOP candidate is a blueprint to 2024
Biden spending and energy policies to blame

HbAD2

Tuberculosis carried by illegal invaders has already infected Texas cattle

HbAD3

 
Back to Top