Supreme Court Strikes Down N.C. Legislative Districts, Rejects Special 2017 Election | Eastern North Carolina Now | The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld a lower court's ruling striking down 28 North Carolina legislative districts as cases of unconstitutional racial gerrymandering. But the high court has rejected the idea of holding special legislative elections this year

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's note: This post was created by the staff for the Carolina Journal, John Hood Publisher.

    The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld a lower court's ruling striking down 28 North Carolina legislative districts as cases of unconstitutional racial gerrymandering. But the high court has rejected the idea of holding special legislative elections this year.

    The Supreme Court had issued a stay on Jan. 10 blocking a three-judge panel's order of a special election. Today's unsigned Supreme Court order chides the trial-court panel for ordering a special 2017 legislative election without making a convincing argument why that remedy is needed.

    Justices say their trial-court colleagues should have used an "equitable weighing process" to determine the proper remedy for dealing with the racially gerrymandered election maps. "Rather than undertaking such an analysis in this case, the District Court addressed the balance of equities in only the most cursory fashion," the Supreme Court order states. "As noted above, the court simply announced that '[w]hile special elections have costs,' those unspecified costs 'pale in comparison' to the prospect that citizens will be 'represented by legislators elected pursuant to a racial gerrymander.'

    "That minimal reasoning would appear to justify a special election in every racial-gerrymandering case - a result clearly at odds with our demand for careful case-specific analysis," the order continues. "For that reason, we cannot have confidence that the court adequately grappled with the interests on both sides of the remedial question before us."

    "And because the District Court's discretion 'was barely exercised here,' its order provides no meaningful basis for even deferential review," according to the Supreme Court.

    Gov. Roy Cooper responded to the ruling with an official statement. "Whether the election is November 2018 or earlier, redrawing the districts is good for our democracy by leveling the playing field for free and fair elections," the statement reads. "The people should be able to choose their representatives in competitive districts instead of the representatives being able to choose the people in lopsided, partisan districts."

    The primary legislators handling redistricting issues produced a joint statement supporting the decision.

    "We are encouraged the Supreme Court unanimously rejected the lower court's politically motivated attempt to force a special legislative election in 2017 and its efforts to 'suspend provisions of the North Carolina Constitution,' ignore voters' constitutional right to elect representatives to two-year terms, and effectively nullify their votes from 2016," said Sen. Ralph Hise, R-Mitchell, and Rep. David Lewis, R-Harnett.

    Today's order represents the third action from the U.S. Supreme Court on N.C. redistricting cases in the past three weeks. After striking down two congressional districts used in 2012 and 2014 in Cooper v. Harris, the high court sent the Dickson v. Rucho case back to the N.C. Supreme Court for a third time. That case deals with both congressional and legislative redistricting.

    The high court could act at least once more in the not-too-distant future on N.C. redistricting. The parties involved in Cooper v. Harris have been asked to submit briefs by Tuesday in Harris v. Cooper, which challenges the 2016 congressional election maps drawn to comply with an earlier court order throwing out the maps last used in 2014.
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

President Biden fired FBI Director Christopher Wray Friday and appointed a new director that he hopes will restore American trust in the organization.
China sanctioned Nancy Pelosi on Friday and announced other new measures it will take against the Biden administration in the wake of the Democrat house speaker’s visit to Taiwan.
The Republican Party dominated the blue state of Virginia, where Democrat President Joe Biden won by 10 points just last year, as backlash builds to Biden’s numerous crises and far-left Democrat policies.
I watched with great interest the small comments made by DOJ Attorney General Merrick Garland, in an even shorter press conference, about a most serious matter, and yet, I took nothing he said seriously.
On Friday, Israel Defense Forces announced Operation “Breaking Dawn” to attack Palestinian Islamic Jihad terrorists in the Gaza Strip. Reports state that the IDF killed Tayseer al-Jabari, a senior Islamic Jihad terrorist commander who supervised terrorist forces.
Former President Donald Trump avoided incriminating himself in a deposition with New York A.G. Letitia James by pleading the fifth amendment right to remain silent.
Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis sent law enforcement officials to remove woke State Attorney Andrew Warren of the 13th Judicial Circuit, who was backed by Democrat mega donor George Soros, from office this week.
An independent Pentagon review of a drone strike that killed 10 Afghan civilians, including 7 children, during the final days of the U.S. military’s presence in Afghanistan recommends that no disciplinary action be taken.

HbAD1

President Joe Biden’s spending agenda climbed another hurdle and now appears to have enough votes to pass the Senate after Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ) agreed to the package Thursday.
The FBI raided the home of Nicholas Cage in the early morning hours Friday after an anonymous tip that he had stolen the Declaration of Independence.
Former television news anchor Kari Lake has won the Arizona GOP primary to be the state’s next governor.
“A Tale of Two Carts” - Featuring the Heartbreak of Working Families Being Crushed by Bad Biden/Beasley Policies had Inaccurate Data
Democrat President Joe Biden claimed that reports from multiple mainstream newspapers that the administration could pay illegal aliens who were separated at the border under the previous administration up to $450,000 each to settle lawsuits were untrue.
U.S. District Judge William Osteen is ending his injunction of North Carolina's abortion law, allowing a ban on most abortions after 20 weeks to take effect.
California State Senator Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco) was interviewed Thursday by The Washington Post about the response to his state’s monkeypox outbreak and said that people have to make their own decisions about having sex.
“We hold these truths to be self-evident,” begins the second paragraph of the Declaration of Independence. And yet the self-evident truth of unalienable rights has never been fully lived as what is true in America.

HbAD2

 
Back to Top