Liberal Majority on NC Supreme Court Ramps up Healthcare Costs Amid Pandemic | Beaufort County Now | The Liberal Majority On The NC Supreme Court Hand Trial Bar a Win at the Expense of Doctors and Patients | NCGOP, supreme court, healthcare costs, pandemic, trial bar, doctors, patients, august 19, 2020

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

Liberal Majority on NC Supreme Court Ramps up Healthcare Costs Amid Pandemic

Press Release:

    Raleigh, NC     The radical liberal majority on the North Carolina Supreme Court sided with their trial lawyer donors against healthcare providers fighting the scourge of COVID-19 in their decision in DeSilva v. WakeMed. In yet another example of a liberal activist court run amuck, the liberal majority rewrote the rules of evidence and weakened the established burden of proof needed to hold medical professionals liable for malpractice.

    Last week's decision from the liberal majority weakens the requirements for medical "expert" witnesses and broadened the scope of liability for healthcare providers in medical malpractice suits. This particular case involved a woman who had to be admitted to the hospital with an infection. The doctors prescribed antibiotics with a tiny chance of a negative interaction with her medications. After being released from the hospital, she began rehab, five days after leaving rehab she suffered a foot injury leading to a hospitalization where she sadly succumbed to pneumonia. After her death, the executor of her will filed a medical malpractice suit against the hospital alleging that a complication with the medication led to the foot injury, and the foot injury led to deadly pneumonia.

    One of the flaw in the plaintiff's case was that their sole medical "expert" witness did not meet the requirements under the rules of evidence. The plaintiff's "expert" did not regularly practice medicine in a hospital as the rules required prior to this ruling. Their ruling also weakened the burden of proof required to link a causal chain of events to malpractice claims, increasing the risk to physicians for actions they take, which now may be completely unrelated to the doctor's actions.

    "The ultra liberal majority has significantly weakened protections for physicians against frivolous lawsuits," said NCGOP Spokesman Tim Wigginton. "This attack on healthcare workers by the radical justices is a significant blow against our frontline warriors fighting COVID-19. Their reckless actions that benefit their donors over North Carolinians' safety show why we need the Right Justices to prevail this November."

    While this medical malpractice case may seem like a wonky issue only impacting medical community, given the global pandemic underway, this ruling adversely affects every North Carolinian. The liberal majority's actions significantly weakened the protection against frivolous medical malpractice cases, which is likely to become a significant issue as litigation follows the COVID-19 pandemic.

    This ruling underscores the importance of electing judges who will uphold the rule of law instead of the current majorities' preference for writing their own.

  • Contact: Tim Wigginton


Latest Bloodless Warfare: Politics

The State Board of Elections will hold a remote meeting beginning at 11:00 a.m. on Tuesday, February 23, 2021.
The Constitution Party and the Green Party are no longer recognized political parties in North Carolina.
The North Carolina Council on Health Care Coverage held its last meeting today to finalize principles to help guide Governor Roy Cooper and legislative leaders as they consider options to increase affordable and comprehensive health coverage for North Carolinians.
At the Request of President Biden, Acting Secretary of Education Will Extend Pause on Federal Student Loan Payments
Governor Roy Cooper has appointed William “Bill” Wolfe to serve as a Superior Court Judge in Judicial District 7C, serving Edgecombe and Wilson counties.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper and North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services (NCDHHS) Secretary Dr. Mandy Cohen visited a large-scale vaccine site at UNC-Chapel Hill’s Friday Conference Center to witness health care workers and North Carolinians over age 65 receive the COVID-19 vaccine.


Governor Roy Cooper announced today that the North Carolina Executive Mansion will be illuminated on January 19, 2021, at 5:30 PM in remembrance of the lives lost as in the COVID-19 pandemic.
North Carolina Republican Party Chairman Michael Whatley released the following statement in response to the impeachment vote in the House of Representatives
In 2021, county boards of elections across North Carolina will conduct several important and required processes designed to keep the state’s voter rolls accurate and up to date.
Governor Roy Cooper has mobilized approximately 550 North Carolina National Guardsmen to assist with upcoming security needs in Washington, DC and North Carolina.
Governor Roy Cooper has named retired Lieutenant General Walter Gaskin to lead the North Carolina Department of Military and Veterans Affairs.
State Representative Keith Kidwell was officially sworn-in and seated on the House floor today to serve the people of House District 79, which includes Beaufort and Craven counties.
Governor Roy Cooper today announced two judicial appointments, one to the North Carolina Superior Court and one to the North Carolina District Court.
Transitions are a time for reflection, and a time for looking forward.


Back to Top