Questionable criteria on NC worker ranking begs a deeper dive | Beaufort County Now | North Carolina’s economic health seems strong. Taxes are low, cost of living is below average, and a recent CNBC study gave the state a No. 2 ranking as “Best for Business” because of solid growth, quality workforce, business friendliness, and technology.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is Donna King.

    A study out recently grabbed media attention rating N.C. "worst for workers," but what are they measuring?



    North Carolina's economic health seems strong. Taxes are low, cost of living is below average, and a recent CNBC study gave the state a No. 2 ranking as "Best for Business" because of solid growth, quality workforce, business friendliness, and technology.

    It's all meant that more individual workers are making this state home every year, with average full-time wages at $54,000 annually in 2021. But a recent study from Oxfam, a Boston advocacy group that lobbies for government interventionist policies, rated N.C. dead last for workers.

    Why the disparity? The two studies paint different pictures of our great state because they look at different data from a different point of view. Reading between the lines is revealing.

    The Oxfam study got more local media coverage by labeling N.C. as one of the "Worst States for Work" in the United States. Oxfam cites the reason as the lack of intervention policies by the state government, such as the fact that N.C. minimum wage aligns with federal law, and its Right-to-Work status means it isn't fertile for unionizing. The authors did not calculate in the large number of people moving to North Carolina for work, a cost of living at least 6% lower than they national average, or the overall wage growth.

    "This index is specifically just looking at state level policies for workers," said Kaitlyn Henderson, Ph.D. and lead researcher for Oxfam, in an interview with Carolina Journal. "We really wanted to celebrate those states that are seeking to support even the worker who earns the least amount of money."

    The Oxfam study gave three criteria for judging a good environment for workers: The presence of a minimum wage law compared to the cost of living, power of labor unions and collective bargaining, and regulatory laws mandating some benefits, such as requiring that all businesses give paid sick and vacation days.

    Oxfam held up New York and California as among the best places for workers because they have a $14 and $13.50 an-hour minimum wage, respectively, and state policies encourage unions. However, the two have some of the highest unemployment rates in the country and notoriously high cost of living. According to Forbes, New York's job growth is stagnant and 60% of the moves recorded were people moving out, not in. For California, it's a similar story. From 2000 to 2020, California had a net loss of 2.6 million people to other U.S. states, and lost a congressional seat in the most recent census. More than 265 companies have moved their headquarter out of California since 2019, at an average of six HQ losses per month. Still, prices are 16% higher than in most other states. Those factors are driving people out of the state in record numbers.

    Oxfam said they did not calculate in worker satisfaction, either.

    "This index is supposed to just be a capture of the policies that do and don't exist," said Henderson. "It's kinds of a resource for people at the state level and at the federal level to say where do these policies exist and where do they not."

    "This is more of a left-wing progressive ideological wish list of interventionist policies rather than which states are actually creating jobs, creating opportunities and creating income growth for workers," said John Locke Foundation's Brian Balfour. "What they favor are things that make it more expensive to hire workers, which means that fewer workers are hired."

    The Oxfam study also gave ratings based solely on minimum wage workers, which is about 5% of N.C.'s full-time workforce.

    "If you are going to create a ranking of states that are best states to work, I would think you'd include states are actually putting people to work," said Balfour. "States have higher rates of employment and job growth and higher wage growth - more jobs and higher wages, that sounds pretty good for workers to me."
Go Back

HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Montana State University (MSU) professors and other faculty members have taken it upon themselves to verbally accost students protesting MSU’s mask mandate. In emails obtained by The Daily Wire, at least five MSU professors and faculty used work emails to harass and swear at engineering students.
Today, Governor Roy Cooper and North Carolina Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Mandy K. Cohen, M.D. provided an update on the state’s COVID-19 key metrics and trends.
A federal judge in Kentucky issued a preliminary injunction on Tuesday against Democrat President Joe Biden’s coronavirus vaccine mandate for federal contractors and subcontractors in three states.
A top N.C. Senate education leader is criticizing Attorney General Josh Stein for his handling of the state’s defense in the long-running Leandro school funding lawsuit.
John Lacava explains why he is running for School Board
Socialist Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) refused to sign onto a statement condemning far-left activists who chased Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (D-AZ) into a bathroom where they proceeded to record and berate her.

HbAD1

The N.C. Supreme Court will decide in the months ahead whether a nurse can face greater legal liability for a patient’s injuries. The decision could reinforce or throw out a nearly 90-year-old court precedent.
Firefighters are still battling a wildfire that engulfed North Carolina’s Pilot Mountain over the weekend.
Excellent hit from press conference
We will offer this allotment of three with more to come; some old, most new, but all quite informative, and, moreover, necessary to understanding that in North Carolina, there is a wiser path to govern ourselves and our People.
Comedian and actor Damon Wayans last week praised Dave Chappelle for his Netflix special “The Closer,” saying the politically incorrect content “freed the slaves,” referring to fellow comedians feeling trapped to perform within the confines of the Left’s terms, lest they be canceled.

HbAD2

I have been following the Sheppard case and the Franks case the last couple of years with a somewhat dispassionate interest. The wheels of justice grind and they do grind slow.

HbAD3

 
Back to Top