Comment Submitted in Response to Proposed Charter School Program Rules | Beaufort County Now | I strongly oppose proposed rules that would impose onerous and ultimately harmful requirements for competitive grants under the federal Charter Schools Program.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Dr. Terry Stoops.

    I strongly oppose proposed rules that would impose onerous and ultimately harmful requirements for competitive grants under the federal Charter Schools Program.

    The proposed "community impact analysis" is among the most objectionable of the proposed Charter Schools Program regulations. I do not believe that anonymous grant reviewers will offer fair and meaningful analyses employing qualitative, quantitative, and survey data to assess the actual educational and economic effects of public charter schools in a community.

    As a member of the North Carolina Charter Schools Advisory Board, I have reviewed dozens of impact statements submitted as part of the charter school application process. Unsurprisingly, most charter school "impacts" described by districts in these documents feature lists of recycled grievances about increased competition, which is the presumptive response from those supporting institutions exposed to very little of it.

    The typical objection in an impact statement is that a competitive educational market will allow per-student allotments to follow children to their schools of choice. This is undeniably true and far from the point. Implicitly, such objections signal an interest in securing the district's financial interests rather than meeting children's academic and social-emotional needs. Indeed, parents who find their district-assigned school to be satisfactory will have no desire to seek alternatives. More importantly, if the demand did not exist, my North Carolina Charter Schools Advisory Board colleagues and I would have no justification for recommending the approval of new charter schools.

    Additionally, regulations that give priority to Charter Schools Program applicants that "partner" with a school district ignore instances when such cooperation is not possible. While voluntary charter-district partnerships facilitate the exchange of information and best practices, there are few incentives for a school district to accept a proposed collaborative agreement with a charter school. After all, charters are their direct competitor for students and resources. Incompatible missions, political barriers, logistical factors, and other practical concerns impede successful partnerships between districts and charter schools.

    All public charter schools should qualify for Charter Schools Program grants without sacrificing the essential freedoms granted to them to operate in ways that benefit the students they serve. These latest efforts to find new ways to slam the federal regulatory sledgehammer on the citizens, educators, and entrepreneurs - the people who form the core of the charter school movement - will satisfy the education establishment. But these politically motivated regulations will harm the millions of children who receive an outstanding education in public charter schools.

    The most sensible public policy response to public charter schools is simple: leverage federal funds to support promising instructional models, teaching methods, and institutional configurations that benefit children regardless of the objections of entrenched interests seeking to crush successful alternatives.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Collectivists of many stripes—but one aim—have been eating away at our free society for over one hundred years.
Winning student teams selected from Wake, Durham, and Guilford Counties in third annual contest to develop mobile apps
Actor Ray Liotta, who was best known for his leading role in Martin Scorsese’s 1990 crime classic “Goodfellas,” has died at 67-years-old.
Conservative voters turned out in droves for the Republican primaries, eager to select the next candidate who will betray his supporters and completely reverse all his positions once sworn into office.
A male Texas A&M University-Kingsville student was expelled after a female student claimed he sexually assaulted her because she was too drunk to consent. The student sued, and a judge just granted a temporary restraining order, setting aside the school’s determination and allowing the lawsuit.
U.S. airlines facing a pilot shortage are considering measures that would make it easier to get pilots trained faster, including halving the number of flight hours needed to become a pilot.
A recent study has audited Joe Biden's Twitter followers to determine whether or not they are in fact real followers. The results have left the world stunned as everyone discovered half of his followers are somehow real people.
CNN host Don Lemon’s attorney has sent a letter to Megyn Kelly for doing what CNN and other media outlets have done for decades: Invite people on to discuss their sexual misconduct accusations against public figures.
In a touching moment of clarity this week, personnel from the Department of Homeland Security Disinformation Governance Board realized that the true disinformation they've been looking for was inside them all along.


A new N.C. House bill would expand administrative law judges' ability to kill state government rules.
As thousands of small businesses were forced to close for good as a result of his economic lockdowns, Gov. Cooper’s administration handed out $1.2 billion worth of corporate welfare to giant corporations like Apple, FujiFilm, and Toyota in 2021.
Sounds like a campaign speech to us
Multiple briefs filed Friday ask the U.S. Supreme Court not to take up a redistricting case from North Carolina.
The Elite Media only reports what fits their narrative
Shows why teachers should be encouraged to concealed carry


Back to Top