Fired Durham police sergeant bolsters his case to N.C. Supreme Court | Eastern North Carolina Now | A fired Durham police sergeant is asking the N.C. Supreme Court to permit his lawsuit accusing the city of violating his state constitutional rights.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    A Durham police sergeant fired after he allowed a suspect to smoke a marijuana blunt has filed new paperwork with the N.C. Supreme Court. The sergeant reminds the court that his controversial action helped end an armed standoff.

    "A law enforcement officer carried out his job duties in literal compliance with the pertinent Durham law enforcement operational policies, protected everyone's safety, de-escalated the armed suicidal barricaded subject who had already fired off a shot with his gun - and was consequently terminated," wrote attorney Michael McGuinness in his latest filing Monday on behalf of fired officer Michael Mole'. "At its core, this is a case about the enforceability of law enforcement rules and policies designed to promote both officer and citizen safety."

    The case stemmed from a June 2016 incident. Called in as a police hostage negotiator, Mole' spoke for two hours with Julius Smoot. Smoot had threatened to shoot himself while barricaded in an apartment bedroom.

    "During this time, Smoot said he planned to smoke a 'blunt,' a marijuana cigarette," according to the N.C. Appeals Court opinion in the case. "Sergeant Mole', reluctant to allow an armed and barricaded subject to impair his mental state, asked Smoot to refrain. Sergeant Mole' promised Smoot that if he disarmed and peacefully surrendered, he would be allowed to smoke the blunt."

    "Smoot then dropped his gun, handcuffed himself, and surrendered to Sergeant Mole' in the apartment," the opinion continued. "Still in handcuffs, Smoot asked for his pack of legal tobacco cigarettes and lighter, which were on a nearby table, and Sergeant Mole' handed those items to him. Smoot then pulled a marijuana blunt from behind his ear, lit it with the lighter, and smoked approximately half of it."

    Durham police investigated Mole's actions. Four months after the incident, his supervisors gave him one day's notice of a pre-disciplinary hearing. Departmental policy required three days' notice. After the hearing, Mole's immediate supervisors recommended a reprimand. Durham fired him instead.

    Mole' filed suit against the city in November 2018. A trial court dismissed his complaint. But the Court of Appeals responded in October 2021 to Mole's "fruits of their own labor" claim.

    "Article I, Section 1 of the North Carolina Constitution, in a provision unique to that document as compared to the federal constitution, protects the people's rights to enjoy the fruits of their own labor," noted Judge Lucy Inman for the unanimous Appeals Court. "This provision was recently applied by our Supreme Court in Tully v. City of Wilmington. Following the Supreme Court's reasoning in Tully, we hold that Sergeant Mole's complaint adequately pleads a claim for violation of Article I, Section 1."

    While reviving Mole's claim under the "fruits of their own labor" provision, the Appeals Court rejected the rest of the fired officer's arguments.

    Now Mole' is appealing to the state Supreme Court.

    "As the streets of America and North Carolina have grown increasingly more dangerous and deadly, little is more important than effective law enforcement policies and procedures to safely manage police operations," McGuiness wrote in Monday's brief. "All North Carolina law enforcement officers, of every rank and position, are ethically mandated to "be exemplary in obeying the law and the regulations of my department."

    In addition to his claim that Durham violated his rights under the state constitution's "fruits of their own labor" clause, Mole' asserts violations of Article I, Section 19's guarantee of "equal protection of the laws."

    "Durham has offered no case that provides support for its assertion that Sergeant Mole's complaint fails to state any claim for relief, either the Fruits of Labor claim or Mole's' equal protection claim," McGuinness wrote. "Both are enumerated claims under Article I, Sections 1 and 19 of the North Carolina Constitution, and both are grounded in historical precedent."

    Mole's dispute involves Durham's alleged violation of its own law enforcement policies, McGuinness argued.

    "The respect for and compliance with law enforcement policies by everyone, is arguably far more important than the enforcement of employment policies," he wrote. "Non-compliance with law enforcement policies often has deadly consequences both for first responders and for the public. These enormously important law enforcement policies cannot be disrespected or ignored without jeopardizing public safety."

    "The law enforcement policies at issue in this case are especially worthy of protection because they promote the safety of everyone, including the public, suspects, and the officers involved," he added.

    Monday's brief marks the final paperwork scheduled in Mole's case. The state Supreme Court has announced no timetable for addressing Mole's arguments moving forward.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

North Carolina County Will Put AR-15s In Every School Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Poll: Only 12% Of Americans Believe Democrat ‘Inflation Reduction Act’ Will Actually Reduce Inflation


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

We are expected to pretend
Local man Jimmy Blanco spent the past six months painstakingly going over player stats, injury reports, and strategy articles as he prepped for his fantasy draft that occurred the last week of August.
Former U.S. Attorney General William Barr said Wednesday that he does not believe that New York Attorney General Letitia James’ civil lawsuit against the Trump family is going to go anywhere, and what convinced him that she overreached on the case was that she decided to go after his children
Credit card debt jumped again in the second quarter of 2022 as inflation caused people to spend more money to consume the same basket of goods.
Former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo (D) lashed out at some he had considered his “political friends” before scandal brought an early end to his time in office.
Edgecombe Early College High School Scholar Teachers Program is Training High School Students to Become Edgecombe County Teachers Upon College Graduation


Two U.S. veterans from Alabama branded “soldiers of fortune” by Moscow after being captured fighting for Ukraine have been spared their date with a firing squad after a Saudi-brokered prisoner swap.
The state got $780 million for 2016's Hurricanes Matthew and Florence, yet some victims remain homeless.
Current and former conservative officials outlined an eight-pronged plan on Wednesday to encourage economic development under a Republican Congress.
The 41-year-old man who allegedly admitted to murdering a Republican teenager over politics has been released from jail after posting $50,000 bond.
Brothers of Italy going from 5th rank to largest party



Back to Top