NC Appeals Court urged to throw out Chapel Hill’s short-term rental ordinance | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The latest filing in a lawsuit at the N.C. Court of Appeals challenging Chapel Hill's short-term rental ordinance argues that the town had no authority to put that ordinance in place.

    The brief filed Wednesday urges appellate judges to reverse a trial court order favoring the town.

    "This case poses a simple issue," wrote attorney Celie Richardson, representing the plaintiff challenging the ordinance. "Defendant-Appellee Town of Chapel Hill did not have statutory authority to enact the Short-Term Rental Ordinance to regulate zoning and land use based on where the owner or owner's agent lives or doesn't live, and for what length of time."

    "Ultra vires" is a legal term for acting beyond one's power or authority.

    "For a defense of this ultra vires ordinance, the Town is trying to create issues that may look friendlier to its position but are not part of this case," Richardson wrote.

    The town tries to "mischaracterize" the lawsuit, Richardson argued. The town labels the challenge of an "unlawful owner-agent residency requirement" as a "nonsensical attempt" to regulate the type of person who can own property.

    Chapel Hill also tries to create two separate legal standards for ordinances with and without fees. "No authority is presented in support of this proposition, because there is none," Richardson wrote.

    The brief also challenges Chapel Hill's characterization of the residency requirement as a type of land use, comparing the requirement to single-family or multi-family designations. "If successful, this would be a fundamental change in the nature of land use regulation," Richardson wrote.

    "In short, the Town is seeking reversal of well-settled law," according to the plaintiff's brief. "What the authorities cited by the Town for these propositions actually stand for is the principle that all municipal authority is limited by the enabling statutes."

    Chapel Hill approved new short-term rental restrictions in June 2021, then set an 18-month deadline for property owners to comply. That deadline passed in December 2022.

    Property owners who offer rentals - rooms, apartments, or full homes - for more than two weeks a year and for people who stay up to 30 days face new regulations. They need a zoning compliance permit and have to follow other rules linked to safety and nuisances. The rules apply to off-site owners and on-site owners renting out extra rooms or apartments. Chapel Hill set limits on the number of short-tern rental properties permitted in multifamily developments.

    Town staff estimated in June 2021 that Chapel Hill had about 250 short-term rental properties.

    Plaintiff Eric Plow owns Chapel Hill Rentals, which bills itself online as the "#1 rental agency providing short-term and long-term housing that is within close proximity of the University of North Carolina campus."

    He filed his complaint against the town in September 2021. Orange County Superior Court Judge Allen Baddour ruled in favor of Chapel Hill in July 2022.

    No date has been set for the Appeals Court to consider the case.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

NC medical marijuana bill moves through first senate committee Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal NC will have $3.25 billion in excess revenue for 2022-23


Latest State and Federal

House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Turner (R-OH) said that communist China is using TikTok to make its way into U.S. data systems as calls grow for the federal government to ban the app.
Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) brought up left-wing riots during an interview over the weekend when asked about the recent media coverage surrounding the January 6 riot following the release of thousands of hours of video footage from the incident.
General Assembly leaders agreed to a bottom-line budget number last week, kicking off the biennium budget season. Senate Leader Phil Berger (R-Rockingham) and House Speaker Tim Moore (R-Cleveland) announced that General Fund spending would increase by 6.5% in the first year
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Turner (R-OH) slammed Dr. Anthony Fauci, former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, over the weekend for making statements about the origins of COVID that are not supported by the findings of the U.S. intelligence
Senator John Kennedy (R-LA) said during an interview on Sunday that when he approached President Joe Biden about using the U.S. military to take out Mexican drug cartels, the president rebuffed him and said that it was a “bad idea.”
In a press conference Thursday, Senate Leader Phil Berger and House Speaker Tim Moore announced that an agreement has been reached between the chambers to expand the federal Medicaid entitlement program in North Carolina.
The U.S. Navy announced this week that it would be renaming a ship named for oceanographic pioneer Matthew Fontaine Maury because of Maury’s ties to the Confederacy during the later years of his life.
School staff, mental health professionals and the community can learn how to expand support for K-12 students and families experiencing mental and behavioral health issues in a webinar from 10 a.m. to noon, Wednesday, March 15.
Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis’ first memoir, which was launched ahead of an expected announcement that he will run for president in 2024, sold more copies in its first week than books from Donald Trump, Barack Obama, and Hillary Clinton.


North Carolina’s state motto offers a great guide to policymakers
White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre faced backlash late this week after falsely claiming during a White House press briefing that Daily Wire host Michael Knowles called for the “eradication of transgender people” during a speech at CPAC.
Energy Department Secretary Jennifer Granholm gushed about China’s approach to green energy in a Friday interview, saying she hoped that the U.S. could learn from China’s approach.
Are you currently looking for a new job? Scammers have ramped up efforts to take advantage of job seekers to trick them out of their money or steal their identity.
The showdown over the future of the federal budget is taking shape as President Joe Biden releases his fiscal year 2024 spending proposal and House Republicans prepare to leverage their new majority to block the plan.
Stanford University’s law school is deemed the second-best in the nation in the latest U.S. News and World Report, which means its current enrollees likely include future senators, judges, and possibly even Supreme Court justices who will help shape American law over the next half-century.
On Wednesday, North Carolina legislators took a step toward repealing the literacy test requirement from the N.C. Constitution. Legislators heard House Bill 44 in the Judiciary 2 committee Wednesday. The bill would place a constitutional amendment on the 2024 general election ballot.
An African delegation bucked the UN by screening The Daily Wire’s “What Is A Woman?” in honor of a women’s conference Friday, even after they were told the hit documentary did not align with the hosting commission’s values.


Back to Top