NC Appeals Court urged to throw out Chapel Hill’s short-term rental ordinance | Eastern North Carolina Now

A lawsuit at the N.C. Court of Appeals argues that Chapel Hill had no legal authority for the owner residency requirement in its short-term rental ordinance.

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The latest filing in a lawsuit at the N.C. Court of Appeals challenging Chapel Hill's short-term rental ordinance argues that the town had no authority to put that ordinance in place.

    The brief filed Wednesday urges appellate judges to reverse a trial court order favoring the town.

    "This case poses a simple issue," wrote attorney Celie Richardson, representing the plaintiff challenging the ordinance. "Defendant-Appellee Town of Chapel Hill did not have statutory authority to enact the Short-Term Rental Ordinance to regulate zoning and land use based on where the owner or owner's agent lives or doesn't live, and for what length of time."

    "Ultra vires" is a legal term for acting beyond one's power or authority.

    "For a defense of this ultra vires ordinance, the Town is trying to create issues that may look friendlier to its position but are not part of this case," Richardson wrote.

    The town tries to "mischaracterize" the lawsuit, Richardson argued. The town labels the challenge of an "unlawful owner-agent residency requirement" as a "nonsensical attempt" to regulate the type of person who can own property.

    Chapel Hill also tries to create two separate legal standards for ordinances with and without fees. "No authority is presented in support of this proposition, because there is none," Richardson wrote.

    The brief also challenges Chapel Hill's characterization of the residency requirement as a type of land use, comparing the requirement to single-family or multi-family designations. "If successful, this would be a fundamental change in the nature of land use regulation," Richardson wrote.

    "In short, the Town is seeking reversal of well-settled law," according to the plaintiff's brief. "What the authorities cited by the Town for these propositions actually stand for is the principle that all municipal authority is limited by the enabling statutes."

    Chapel Hill approved new short-term rental restrictions in June 2021, then set an 18-month deadline for property owners to comply. That deadline passed in December 2022.

    Property owners who offer rentals - rooms, apartments, or full homes - for more than two weeks a year and for people who stay up to 30 days face new regulations. They need a zoning compliance permit and have to follow other rules linked to safety and nuisances. The rules apply to off-site owners and on-site owners renting out extra rooms or apartments. Chapel Hill set limits on the number of short-tern rental properties permitted in multifamily developments.

    Town staff estimated in June 2021 that Chapel Hill had about 250 short-term rental properties.

    Plaintiff Eric Plow owns Chapel Hill Rentals, which bills itself online as the "#1 rental agency providing short-term and long-term housing that is within close proximity of the University of North Carolina campus."

    He filed his complaint against the town in September 2021. Orange County Superior Court Judge Allen Baddour ruled in favor of Chapel Hill in July 2022.

    No date has been set for the Appeals Court to consider the case.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

NC medical marijuana bill moves through first senate committee Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal NC will have $3.25 billion in excess revenue for 2022-23


Latest State and Federal

Republican congressman Byron Donalds said it would be a “great honor” if former President Donald Trump were to ask him to be his running-mate for 2024, saying the ultimate goal is for Trump to win and he’ll do whatever he’s asked to help him do that.
Voters in Arizona will have the opportunity to enact broad border security measures in November as the state faces a flood of illegal immigration after the Republican-led state legislature passed a resolution that will put the measures on the general election ballot.
The former White House physician for Presidents Barack Obama and Donald Trump says that a new report this week about how President Joe Biden is struggling to function behind closed doors represents a serious threat to the U.S.
The Tikva Forum for Families of Hostages, an Israeli group created to represent the families of those taken during Hamas’ October 7 terrorist attack, urged President Joe Biden to stop interfering with Israel’s campaign to destroy the terrorist group.
After saying the six-foot social distancing guideline during the COVID-19 pandemic “sort of just appeared,” Dr. Anthony Fauci on Monday testified that his statement had been “distorted” and that it “actually” came from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
The state Supreme Court has agreed to hear one of two pending cases involving North Carolina bar owners challenging Gov. Roy Cooper's COVID-related shutdowns in 2020.
The Biden administration canceled over 350,000 asylum cases, allowing migrants to stay in the United States indefinitely in a move that experts called “mass amnesty.”
Former White House medical advisor Anthony Fauci changed his view of COVID vaccines from 2021 to 2024, clips show.
The Department of Justice announced on Friday that 75-year-old Paula Paulette Harlow was sentenced to two years in prison for violating the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act by taking part in a “conspiracy” to block pregnant women from entering an abortion clinic in Washington, D.C.


A GOP-led House panel is seeking access to Dr. Anthoni Fauci‘s personal email accounts and cell phone records as part of an investigation into the origins of COVID-19.
Former President Donald Trump is considering having Tesla CEO Elon Musk serve in an advisory role if Trump reclaims the White House, according to a new report.
On Tuesday, special counsel Jack Smith‘s bid for a gag order against former President Donald Trump in his classified documents case got rejected by the presiding federal judge in Florida.
On Thursday, the GOP-led House passed a bill that pressures the Biden administration not to withhold arms from Israel as the U.S. ally fights Iran-backed Hamas following a deadly terrorist attack in October of last year.
The Islamic Republic of Iran’s president and foreign minister and other officials have been confirmed dead after a helicopter crash on Sunday while they were traveling in the eastern part of the country, according to Iranian state media.
President Joe Biden challenged former president Donald Trump to debates last week because Biden needs to swivel the political spotlight away from his record ahead of the election, according to Daily Wire editor emeritus Ben Shapiro.
The 2024 second primary election will be held statewide on Tuesday, May 14, 2024. In-person early voting ends at 3 p.m. Saturday, May 11, in all 100 counties.
For the second time in a week, President Joe Biden made a false claim about inflation — and he did not get away with it as journalists and political rivals called him out on it.


Back to Top