Federal Appeals Court rejects challenge of Chapel Hill’s inclusionary zoning fees | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld a trial court's ruling favoring Chapel Hill in a dispute over fees charged to developers for affordable housing. Appellate judges agreed the plaintiff waited too long to file suit.

    The complaint stemmed from the $803,250 fee charged to developers of Courtyards of Homestead, a 63-unit single-family housing development.

    The project secured a special-use permit in 2014, four years after the town adopted an ordinance "to create and preserve affordable housing opportunities for its residents" and "to provide a structure for cooperative participation by the public and private sectors in the production of affordable housing," according to the 4th Circuit court opinion.

    Developers must include affordable housing in any project in Chapel Hill with at least five single-family homes. The town also can agree to let the developer pay a fee instead.

    Epcon, owner of the Courtyards of Homestead property, chose to pay the fee in installments. The last payment reached Chapel Hill in May 2019. The company filed suit to recover the fee in October 2019.

    In addition to state constitutional claims, Epcon argued that Chapel Hill's affordable housing fee amounted to an "unconstitutional taking" under the U.S. Constitution's Fifth Amendment and a "due process violation" under the 14th Amendment.

    A trial judge dismissed the case, ruling that Epcon had failed to file suit within a three-year statute of limitations.

    "There is no dispute that the applicable statute of limitations for Epcon's federal claim is three years," wrote Appeals Court Chief Judge Roger Gregory. "[T]he parties disagree about when the clock on Epcon's ... claim began to tick."

    "Here, Epcon alleges that it suffered an injury ... stemming from the application of an unlawful special use permit condition," Gregory wrote. "As the district court concluded, Epcon first had reason to know of this injury no later than 2015, when it began purchasing the land subject to the special use permit. Thus, its claim that the permit condition violated its rights to just compensation and due process accrued at that point and extinguished three years later. By the time Epcon filed suit in October 2019, the sun had set on its federal claims."

    Judges rejected the company's argument that each fee payment amounted to a new constitutional violation. A new violation would have extended the state of limitations.

    "Epcon's federal claims allege the Town imposed an unconstitutional condition on its permit - a single act. Epcon's payments pursuant to that permit were not repeated constitutional violations but rather continual ill effects of the original violation alleged," wrote Judge Allison Jones Rushing in a concurring opinion.

    Judge Stephanie Thacker joined Gregory's opinion.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Lawyers for legislature, executive branch take opposing views in latest Moore v. Harper filings Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal WY becomes 19th state to ban men from womens sports


Latest State and Federal

The most interesting candidate in the 2024 election has to be Democratic hopeful Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. – if not for his career path and family history, then for his willingness to buck the D.C. establishment narrative and attack The Uniparty.
57% of North Carolinians support legislation to prohibit abortions after the first trimester, with exceptions.
Former President Donald Trump’s social media company is seeking $3.78 billion in damages in a defamation lawsuit against The Washington Post for publishing “an egregious hit piece” earlier this month that accused the company of securities fraud and other wrongdoings.
Special provisions continue to thrive in North Carolina. The last biennium budget was loaded with special projects, and the forthcoming one may be no different.
The University of Minnesota was the subject of a civil rights complaint last week for enacting a research program that offers applicants a $6,000 stipend but is restricted to students of color.
South Carolina Republican Sen. Tim Scott announced his entry into the 2024 presidential election on Monday, smacking President Joe Biden while touting his own up-from-poverty story.
One of the largest public state pension funds in the nation has routinely accepted shareholder resolution advice from a woke proxy advisory firm based in San Francisco
Special counsel John Durham‘s long-awaited report serves as a guide for how Congress can further investigate the Russiagate controversy, according to a top GOP lawmaker.
Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) slammed ABC’s “The View” during a presidential campaign stop over the weekend in Iowa while announcing that he was going on the show this week.


The NAACP Board of Directors issued a statement on Saturday warning black Americans that the state of Florida was not a safe place for them and included an official “travel advisory” calling the state “openly hostile” – but the board’s chairman, Leon Russell, apparently lives in Florida himself.
Children in grades K-3 in North Carolina have surpassed the rest of the nation when it comes to their early-literacy skills. That’s according to N.C. Superintendent of Public Instruction Catherine Truitt, who shared the news at Tuesday’s Council of State meeting.
Ty Cobb, a former White House lawyer for President Donald Trump, said that he believes that the former president will get convicted in the federal criminal investigation into his handling of classified materials and that he will ultimately go to prison over it.
The GOP-led House may have reached a breakthrough in its standoff with the FBI over a file believed to contain bribery allegations concerning President Joe Biden.
President Joe Biden said he would discuss the debt limit with House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) via telephone from Air Force One as he returns home from Japan after the top Republican accused him of being beholden to “radical socialists” as a potential default looms.
Republican and independent voters in Nassau County, New York, this week were shocked to find out that they had changed parties after all the voter information cards mailed out before an upcoming primary mistakenly identified every voter as a Democrat.
North Carolina Republican Dan Bishop said this week that the Bank of America provided the FBI with private financial information about anyone who was in Washington, D.C., from January 5-7, 2021.
Media outlets and others scrambled this week after a white pregnant woman was widely vilified on social media as a racist after a video went viral of a confrontation over a bike, and the woman’s lawyer has said they plan to file defamation lawsuits.


Back to Top