‘Media advisory’ boards would review complaints over certain books in schools | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Within the 2023 N.C. House budget there is policy intended to improve transparency regarding classroom materials in K-12 schools. One directs every local board of education to form a local "community media advisory committee," tasked with "evaluating challenges from parents, teachers, and members of the public to instructional materials and supplemental materials because they are unfit."

    In recent years, school boards across the state have had a fragmented approach to addressing concerns about material in k-12 classrooms or libraries. Individual schools would independently review and remove content, but the results of their review often failed to reach other schools within the same district. The policy written into the budget is an effort by lawmakers to establish consistency and coordination.

    In light of the fragmented approach across the state, the New Hanover County Board of Education is among the systems to set up their own process to handle complaints. In early April, Melissa Mason, a newly-elected Republican, brought forward a District-Wide Book Review Committee Proposal with the mission to "establish excellence in our libraries and classrooms and provide students with the highest quality literature in every library, classroom, and textbook."

    "The current process directs parents to communicate with individual schools to remove objectionable content," Mason told Carolina Journal. "If it is deemed inappropriate, it is removed from one school only. It stands to reason that if the content of a book is unacceptable in one school, it is unacceptable for all schools within that age bracket."

    Under the policy in the proposed budget, at least 12 members would comprise each local community media advisory committee, including a principal, teacher, parent, and library media coordinator from a district's high school, middle school, and elementary school. Challenges to materials inside the schools would be made to the Board of Education in writing, and must be made on the grounds of content "being obscene, inappropriate to the age, maturity, or grade level of the students, or not aligned with the standard course of study."

    The committee would have two weeks to hold a hearing in which the challenger would present their case for the material to be removed. Following the hearing, the committee would have two weeks to make a required recommendation to the full board of education. The board would decide whether the "challenge has merit and whether the challenged material should be retained or removed as unfit material."

    Mason has seen some of this content in local New Hanover County Schools.

    "The content within the literature was both disturbing and obscene, involving vivid descriptions of sexual acts and molestation," she said. "As I have a background in education, including the study of cognitive development in children, it has been apparent to me that this type of media was not suitable for students and offered little to no educational value."

    Along with the creation of a local committee, the House budget forms a State Community Media Advisory Committee under The State Board of Education. The state committee has a similar number of members to the local committees and is responsible for hearing any appeals of a local board of education decision. The state committee would generate a recommendation to be voted on by the State Board of Education. All decisions would be final and not subject to any further review.

    The House budget was passed by lawmakers in that chamber on, moving on to the made its North Carolina Senate. View our continued coverage here.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Leandro judge sets $677 million as outstanding NC education spending obligation Carolina Journal, Statewide, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal A primer on Education Savings Accounts


Latest State and Federal

One of the largest public state pension funds in the nation has routinely accepted shareholder resolution advice from a woke proxy advisory firm based in San Francisco
Special counsel John Durham‘s long-awaited report serves as a guide for how Congress can further investigate the Russiagate controversy, according to a top GOP lawmaker.
Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) slammed ABC’s “The View” during a presidential campaign stop over the weekend in Iowa while announcing that he was going on the show this week.
The NAACP Board of Directors issued a statement on Saturday warning black Americans that the state of Florida was not a safe place for them and included an official “travel advisory” calling the state “openly hostile” – but the board’s chairman, Leon Russell, apparently lives in Florida himself.
Children in grades K-3 in North Carolina have surpassed the rest of the nation when it comes to their early-literacy skills. That’s according to N.C. Superintendent of Public Instruction Catherine Truitt, who shared the news at Tuesday’s Council of State meeting.
Ty Cobb, a former White House lawyer for President Donald Trump, said that he believes that the former president will get convicted in the federal criminal investigation into his handling of classified materials and that he will ultimately go to prison over it.
The GOP-led House may have reached a breakthrough in its standoff with the FBI over a file believed to contain bribery allegations concerning President Joe Biden.
President Joe Biden said he would discuss the debt limit with House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) via telephone from Air Force One as he returns home from Japan after the top Republican accused him of being beholden to “radical socialists” as a potential default looms.


Republican and independent voters in Nassau County, New York, this week were shocked to find out that they had changed parties after all the voter information cards mailed out before an upcoming primary mistakenly identified every voter as a Democrat.
North Carolina Republican Dan Bishop said this week that the Bank of America provided the FBI with private financial information about anyone who was in Washington, D.C., from January 5-7, 2021.
Media outlets and others scrambled this week after a white pregnant woman was widely vilified on social media as a racist after a video went viral of a confrontation over a bike, and the woman’s lawyer has said they plan to file defamation lawsuits.
The reason Disney canceled constructing a $1 billion office complex in Orlando has little to do with Governor Ron DeSantis’ battle against the company’s woke priorities, Daily Wire editor emeritus Ben Shapiro said on his show Friday.
A unanimous N.C. Court of Appeals panel is allowing a woman to move forward with her lawsuit against the city of Raleigh and one of its employees. The employee injured the woman in an auto accident in 2018.
South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott has filed paperwork to run for president of the United States, according to a Federal Election Commission filing.
Charlotte City Council member Braxton Winston has thrown his hat in the ring in the 2024 race as a Democratic candidate for North Carolina’s Commissioner of Labor.
The lawyer for a white pregnant New York City physician’s assistant who was vilified as a racist on social media after a confrontation with a group of young black men who claimed that one of them paid for a city bike she was taking has reportedly produced receipts showing she paid for the bike.


Back to Top