Will State University Systems Punish Underperforming Schools? | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of The James G. Martin Center. The author of this post is Maggie Szura.

    The California State University System is implementing a plan that will encourage universities to hit enrollment targets, but at great cost. In January, Cal State leaders announced the blueprints for the new strategy. As Inside Higher Ed reported, the plan will pull five percent of enrollment funding from colleges that fall short of their enrollment targets by 10 percent or more. This puts several Cal State colleges in a tricky situation.

    According to Cal Matters, the seven colleges that are underperforming in enrollment are CSU Channel Islands, Chico State, Cal State East Bay, Cal Poly Humboldt, Cal Maritime, Sonoma State, and San Francisco State. Since these colleges are already struggling to enroll students, some concerns have arisen about the plan to kick schools while they're already down. According to board members, the details of the plan are not final, and the goal is not to punish schools but to encourage growth. Nevertheless, the blueprints for the plan have not yet been changed, and its implementation is scheduled for 2025.

    Cal State's new strategy could very well be the future for university systems across America if enrollment rates continue to decline. Because of the looming demographic cliff for college-age Americans, there will soon be fewer incoming college students than in previous years. This will result in colossal enrollment pressures if schools wish to remain up and running.

    To be sure, California's plan has a few potential benefits, such as increasing schools' competitive advantages as they invest in innovation to pull enrollment rates up. However, looking at the bigger picture, the new strategy could well lead to increasingly dire budgetary situations. Under-enrolled institutions already face financial pressures. To undermine schools' budgetary footing further, as Cal State's plan threatens to do, may be to introduce a financial death-spiral. Some of the schools under enrollment pressure may ultimately close or require expensive bailouts.

    It should be noted that Cal State's plan isn't the only one of its kind. Recently, Texas unveiled a new strategy that seems to be an offshoot of California's plan. As Higher Ed Dive describes, the Texas plan institutes a process whereby student outcomes are the deciding factor for community-college funding. These outcomes include the number of "credentials of value" colleges award, the number of students who transfer to four-year colleges, and the number of students who complete dual-credit classes. Such performance-based metrics seem to be spreading across the U.S., as Oregon is also intending to head down a similar path with its community colleges.


    If Cal State and other university systems implement outcomes-based funding, new problems could arise. (Among them: Will campuses intentionally enroll non-college-ready students in an attempt to boost their numbers?) However, these initiatives could also do good. In any case, genuine community growth will be hard to come by unless colleges begin once more to offer true education and training, not just credentialing.

    Maggie Szura is an intern at the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal and a junior studying psychology at Rollins College.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )


magzilla said:
( August 7th, 2023 @ 1:32 pm )
I work for one of these campuses under threat of %5 pulling of funds. Thank you for stating the obvious that the "system" kicks these universities when they are down. Already we are losing positions and other critical positions are not filled. We will not be able to add viable academic degrees if the "system" pulls funding. I appreciate the transparency of this article.

Alabama Racial Gerrymandering Case Will Likely Have Little Impact on North Carolina A Bite of Reality, Educating our People, NativeFront, James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Mass Exodus? Biographer Claims Fox Staffers Are Ditching Network For Tucker


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

The state Supreme Court will not bypass an intermediate court's consideration of two parents' lawsuit against a Charlotte private school. Doug and Nicole Turpin accuse Charlotte Latin of expelling their children to retaliate against criticism of changes in the school's focus.
NBC sketch-show “Saturday Night Live” delivered a series of comedic slaps to an increasingly gaffe-prone President Joe Biden, focusing on his recent conversation with Chinese President Xi Jinping in California.
Elon Musk‘s SpaceX made headway in the second test flight of its Starship rocket despite the demo on Saturday ending with explosions.
state law also allows state judges to order deportation of illegal aliens who enter thru Texas


North Carolinians were more generous in their giving to charities in the state this past year.
Comedian and HBO host Bill Maher told former Democratic National Committee chair Donna Brazile that he couldn’t see President Joe Biden winning a second term in the White House.
The scab covering the still-fresh wound of his removal from office was ripped back open today, as Kevin McCarthy's long-awaited "Speaker of the House" nameplate finally arrived from the engraver.
House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Turner (R-OH) said over the weekend that the terrorist threat to the U.S. is the highest that it’s been in over a decade following Hamas’ attack on Israel last month.
Texas Governor Greg Abbott endorsed former President Donald Trump for a second term as president on Sunday during a campaign event in Edinburg, a city about 30 miles away from the Mexico border.
Charlotte has joined a list of major US cities who recently placed a formal bid to designate the Queen City as a nationally recognized regional tech hub.


Rep. Kevin McCathy (R-CA) praised his successor in the role of House speaker, Mike Johnson (R-LA), on Sunday for overseeing the long-awaited release of more January 6 footage to the public.


Back to Top