The K-12 Roots of the UNC Scandal | Eastern North Carolina Now | Kenneth Wainstein’s report, “Investigation of Irregular Classes in the Department of African and Afro-American Studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill,” detailed a long history of academic fraud at North Carolina’s flagship public university.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's note: The author of this post is Dr. Terry Stoops, who is director of research and education studies for the Carolina Journal, John Hood Publisher.

    RALEIGH — Kenneth Wainstein's report, "Investigation of Irregular Classes in the Department of African and Afro-American Studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill," detailed a long history of academic fraud at North Carolina's flagship public university.

    More than 3,100 students, nearly half of them student-athletes, received (often favorable) grades in Afro-American Studies courses that required no attendance, no meaningful faculty participation, and no consistent standards for student work. Although many nonathletes enrolled in these courses, they were designed to boost the grade point averages of student-athletes, preserving their NCAA eligibility.

    Understandably, much of the reaction to the report has focused on ways that faculty and staff enabled students to circumvent the university's academic requirements. According to Wainstein, faculty and staff conspired to do this because they "felt sympathy for underprepared students who struggled with the demanding Chapel Hill curriculum." But we should be outraged equally that high schools granted diplomas to students who appeared to be functionally illiterate. Calling them "underprepared" is an understatement. Calling them high school graduates is a travesty.

    First, it is necessary to acknowledge that none of the 3,100 students has been identified. As such, it is impossible to identify the high schools that awarded their diplomas. According to the university's institutional research office, nearly 70 percent of incoming UNC-Chapel Hill undergraduates graduated from a North Carolina public school. Another 14 percent graduated from a public school in another state. In other words, this is likely a public and private school problem in North Carolina and beyond.

    Regardless of the type or location of schools, the Wainstein report summarizes research and writing deficiencies that are common in middle and high school classrooms — excessive outside assistance, adoption of informal writing styles, and cut-and-paste essays. These are learned, harmful, and often-accepted behaviors aided by complicit parents, negligent teachers, peer pressure, and easy access to online resources.

    One problem, which often begins in middle school, is that struggling students receive inordinate assistance from a parent, tutor, or teacher. By the time these students reach college, they are required to complete research and writing projects on their own, a skill we should expect any college-bound student to possess.

    Yet, one Chapel Hill tutor recounted that a number of students she encountered simply "could not write a paper on their own." Another tutor agreed, saying "players were so woefully underprepared that they could not draft a paper without assistance." In some cases, tutors or academic counselors simply wrote or edited significant portions of student-athletes' essays. Of course, these students were more than happy to allow them to do so.

    In addition, it appeared to be an accepted practice for UNC-Chapel Hill students and student-athletes to submit essays that, according to the Wainstein report, "were largely 'cut and paste' jobs that simply copied text from publicly available sources." Unfortunately, middle and high school students knowingly submit essays full of passages that plagiarize various online sources. It is a pervasive problem. A 2013 Pew survey of 2,500 middle and high school teachers found 68 percent agreeing that "digital tools make students more likely to take shortcuts and not put effort into their writing."

    The fact that students arrived at Chapel Hill with few writing or research skills does not excuse the systematic fraud perpetrated by university faculty and staff. But it does call into question the value of a high school diploma. A high school diploma should signify students' attainment of the skills and knowledge that undergird the roles and responsibilities of adulthood. Perhaps the problem is that many consider college to be a respite from adulthood, rather than its initiation.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Smaller Firms Brace For Obamacare Price Shocks Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Friday Interview: Fighting College Free-Speech Restrictions


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

An assistant U.S. attorney found to have sexually assaulted his or her date will not be held accountable by prosecutors.
As part of ongoing celebrations for Latinx Heritage Month, millions of revelers gathered to remember that day just a few years ago when someone made up the word "Latinx" out of thin air.
Small businesses are concerned about profit margins amid inflationary pressures, as well as issues such as crime rates and stricter tax enforcement, according to a poll released by Job Creators Network.
Is this the next pandemic? Health experts claim that a sudden, unexpected illness is expected to cause many American employees to stay home, some for a week or more, on May 12, 2023.
MSNBC anchor Chuck Todd appeared to have a difficult time accepting Vice President Kamala Harris’ assertion that the U.S.-Mexico border was secure.
North Carolina’s unemployment rate increased to 3.5% in August after remaining flat at 3.4% for four consecutive months prior, according to the latest release from the North Carolina Department of Commerce.
Pope Francis asked for prayers on Sunday ahead of a trip this week to the former Soviet republic of Kazakhstan for an international meeting with religious leaders.
After being removed from a scenic island off the coast of Massachusetts and placed on a bus headed for a nearby military base, immigrant José Valdez has reportedly begun suspecting that the Martha's Vineyard resident who promised to be his pen pal was not actually being serious.


Retired Gen. Frank McKenzie warned on Sunday that the U.S. has limited intelligence capacity in Afghanistan 21 years after the terrorist attacks of 9/11.
N.C. lawmakers accuse redistricting plaintiffs of trying to "disestablish" the General Assembly's authority to draw state election maps.
On the 21st anniversary of the 9/11 terrorist attacks on America, Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA) invoked the January 6th Capitol riot.
Everyone is either a member of a family, or has close association with a family that is forced to shelter a pathetic character, ignobly tolerated; a family member that exists only to be a monumental embarrassment on their best days; their worst days are horror stories.
Superstar Chris Pratt sent a message Sunday to all those people who died in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 — who “risked their lives for us and our country.”
Prison reform advocates are celebrating the NYPD's unprecedented move to put dangerous criminals back out on the street as quickly as possible with the unveiling of the new giant slide.
A new poll indicates that Georgia GOP candidate Herschel Walker is gaining speed in the Peach Tree State’s senate race against incumbent Senator Raphael Warnock (D-GA).
Russia announced Saturday that it is pulling back troops from two areas as Ukraine’s counteroffensive advances in the country’s eastern region.


Back to Top