Superior Court Judge Sanctions N.C. DOT for Missing Deadline for MAP ACT Property Appraisals | Eastern North Carolina Now | Forsyth Superior Court Judge John O. Craig III issued a July 6 sanction penalizing the N.C. Department of Transportation for missing a May 28 deadline for appraising Winston-Salem properties affected by the Map Act

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's note: The author of this post is Lindsay Marchello, who is an associate editor for the Carolina Journal, John Hood Publisher.

    Forsyth Superior Court Judge John O. Craig III issued a July 6 sanction penalizing the N.C. Department of Transportation for missing a May 28 deadline for appraising Winston-Salem properties affected by the Map Act.

    The department was supposed to submit 191 appraisals by May 28, but a substantial number were either submitted after the deadline or aren't completed. The court believes about 100 appraisals have yet to be submitted to the plaintiffs' counsel and estimates about 150 deposits remain unsatisfied.

    Under the 1987 Map Act, the N.C. DOT was able to prevent properties in the path of roadways from developing without officially taking and paying for the land. Property owners in Winston-Salem turned to the court to make the state buy their properties and pay them interest from the time the lands were designated as within the protected corridor of future roadways.

    The issue made it all the way to the N.C. Supreme Court, and in June 2016 the state Supreme Court ruled N.C. DOT did take landowners' property and thus had to pay. But the court didn't specify what kind of taking had occurred, which is necessary in determining how much N.C. DOT owed property owners.

    Following a dismissal of an N.C. DOT appeal, Forsyth County Superior Court issued an order Nov. 28, 2017 outlining a six-month timeline for N.C. DOT to begin appraisals and make deposits by the end of May. NCDOT missed the deadline, leading plaintiffs in the Forsyth Map Act case to file a motion requesting sanctions.

    Craig's sanctions order forbids the department from using the late appraisals in future court hearings, as well as all expert testimony from appraisers concerning these appraisals.

    The judge chastised NCDOT for failing to inform the court the department wouldn't be able to meet the deadline and for only filing a motion for an extension three weeks after the deadline had passed.

    The sanctions order also said N.C. DOT didn't keep track of the appraisals and almost immediately fell behind on schedule, in part because the department failed to retain enough appraisers to handle the caseload. Furthermore, no one at N.C. DOT was given the role of supervising compliance with the court order.

    "No one sounded the alarm that delays were occurring," the sanctions order reads.

    Matthew Bryant, a Winston-Salem attorney representing hundreds of property owners in the Map Act lawsuits, said they still stand ready to deal fairly with the transportation department, despite the delays.

    "While the sanctions order is a strong reaction by the trial court to N.C. DOT's approach to the Map Act litigation, the order itself does not change our goal to get owners just and fairly paid nor lessen our reliance on the legal rights we have won," Bryant said. "We trust NCDOT now shares that goal."

    Jamie Kritzer, assistant director of communications at N.C. DOT , sent the following in an emailed statement:

  • "We have reviewed Judge Craig's ruling and are identifying processes and improvements to fix the deficiencies he identified. We will accelerate and focus our efforts in resolving these cases fairly and expeditiously."

Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Ratings Agencies Confirm: Tax Cap Amendment Would NOT Hurt State Bond Ratings Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics John Locke Foundation: Prudent Policy / Impeccable Research - Volume CCCX


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Former President Donald Trump responded to Friday’s big news that the Justice Department was handing over its criminal investigations into him to a special counsel to avoid potential political bias by claiming that the DOJ was being “weaponized” against him.
The FBI has dispatched surveillance teams after several reports surfaced of Christian Nationalists planning to spend a day thanking God for His blessings and praying for America.
The Washington Post slammed President Joe Biden in a statement Friday for shielding Saudi Arabia’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman from a lawsuit on Thursday over his involvement in the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, one of the newspaper’s columnists.
It turned out that some services like speedy justice and border security were provided more efficiently under the Taliban than under Western-influenced bureaucracies.
Program-value and debt-to-income data are sufficient to protect the public interest.
As flagged by Barstool Sports, Qatar just pulled one of the greatest “bait-and-switches” of all times by pulling the plug on beer being sold at the stadium roughly 48 hours before the World Cup is set to kick off in the Islamic nation.
New evidence suggests that some of the people present at Jesus Christ's famous Sermon on the Mount had to sit in an overflow section on the eastern side of the mount where a large jumbotron screen had been set up.
Mike Rowe told Fox News this weekend that men are becoming soft and lazy in part due to how much time they are spending on screens instead of working.


The Biden administration asked the Supreme Court to weigh in on its student loan forgiveness plan on Friday and let the program resume.
Democratic operatives are reviving a partisan watchdog group to “investigate the investigators” and hound House Republicans who are preparing congressional investigations into the Biden administration.
Attorney General Merrick Garland named Jack Smith, a former war-crimes prosecutor, on Friday as special counsel over two Department of Justice (DOJ) investigations into former President Donald Trump.
Local man Robert Thurdriftle took the day off work to tackle some of the 74 different things he had to do but, after puzzling about what to do first, eventually settled on doing nothing.
Senator Rand Paul (R-KY), a fierce defender of American civil liberties, harshly confronted FBI Director Christopher Wray about the communication between social media companies and the FBI regarding social media users’ private information.
Law enforcement in the Bahamas revealed on Thursday that officials seized assets belonging to defunct cryptocurrency platform FTX and moved them to a government-controlled wallet for “safekeeping.”
Few things shock me regarding political campaigns, whether that be an extreme exaggeration of candidates’ positions, overblown scandals spread on social media, or blatant fearmongering to get just a few more voters to come out for their preferred candidate.
Speaking at the 59th Annual Economic Forecast Luncheon in Phoenix, Arizona, Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller implied that employers should slow down any wage increases they hand out so that the American economy can temper inflation.
Amid plunging stock price, unprofitable streaming, and a business model intensely focused on sexualizing children as young as possible, Bob Chapek has been ousted from Disney and replaced with former CEO Bob Iger.


Back to Top