N.C. Supreme Court Candidates Share Their Beliefs | Eastern North Carolina Now

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Brenee Goforth.

    On Thursday, Sept. 10, the Federalist Society hosted a forum with the candidates for the three contested seats this year in the North Carolina Supreme Court. JLF's Vice President of Marketing and Communications, Donna Martinez, moderated the event.

    The event began with introductions from all the candidates followed by questions for the candidates for Seat Two, Appeals Court Judges Lucy Inman (D) and Phil Berger, Jr. (R). Moderator Donna Martinez began with the question, "Section 35 of the Declaration of Rights in the North Carolina Constitution reads this way, 'A frequent recurrence to fundamental principles is absolutely necessary to preserve the blessings of liberty.' Candidates, what does that statement mean to you?"

    Inman stated that the statement was a proclamation of stability, which she defined as respecting precedent and always referring to the US and state constitutions. Berger, Jr. echoed that he believes it means a constant referral to our constitution, and additionally added that constitutional interpretation should be grounded in liberty and God-given rights.

    After Martinez presented questions to Inman and Berger, Jr., she directed more questions to Justice Mark Davis (D) and state Senator Tamara Barringer (R) — both running for Seat Four. Martinez asked them, "Is it appropriate for a judge to try to right societal injustices, and, if you are elected, would you do that?" Mark Davis held that a judge's role is to apply the law as it is written and that personal feeling about a case should not impact the way they decide the case. Tamara Barringer stated that she was a textualist and believes the law should be interpreted as written.

    Following the questions for Seat Four, Martinez turned the questions to the candidates for Chief Justice. That candidates are sitting Chief Justice Cheri Beasley (D) and Sr. Associate Justice Paul Newby (R). Cheri Beasley was appointed Chief Justice by Dem. Gov. Roy Cooper in 2019 following a vacancy and Paul Newby is the longest serving justice on the court. When the conversation between Beasley and Newby turned to the way the courts have been affected by COVID-19, the justices had disagreements. Reporter A.P. Dillon wrote about them in North State Journal:

  • Beasley touted that she was the first chief justice in the nation to implement COVID-related emergency directives and the use of virtual hearings. She did not get into the delays in jury trials, which are still paused until at least Oct. 1. Beasley said that district courts were "being allowed to create their own plans" for how to resume jury trials.
  • "One size doesn't fit all," said Newby in response to Beasley's blanket COVID orders. He added that district courts have had pandemic plans in place since 2011.
  • "The federal courts have continued with jury trials. Some of our neighboring states have continued with jury trials. Why is that?" asked Newby.
  • Beasley pivoted to the Supreme Court's existing case backlog and said, "we just don't have the funding" to clear it.

    Watch the full forum above, and read Dillon's coverage of the virtual event HERE.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

GOP Leaders, Parents Call for Cooper To Reopen Public Schools John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Cancel Culture Infecting Medicine


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

In an extraordinary display of efficiency and ruthlessness, the FBI's crack tactical team descended upon a sleepy suburban neighborhood after receiving reports of an active incandescent light bulb.
Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas complained on Monday of a “broken immigration system” when asked to respond to a warning from New York City Mayor Eric Adams about the migrant crisis.
HuffPost White House correspondent S. V. Date used the 22nd anniversary of the September 11th terrorist attacks to claim that former President Donald Trump was worse than “Osama bin Biden.”
After years of being totally obscured by Lizzo's shadow, her backup dancers have finally had enough.
Hundreds of gun owners took to the streets of Albuquerque over the weekend to openly carry their firearms in defiance of the state’s Democrat governor, Michelle Lujan Grisham, who unilaterally decided to suspend laws allowing open and concealed carry in the area.
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis responded on Thursday to a Daily Wire report about a land developer in Texas who has created an expansive settlement north of Houston where thousands of illegal immigrants are believed to have settled, saying that he, as president, will put an end to it.


Residents of a small Texas border town have expressed their sympathy for New York City as it buckles under the weight of a few thousand migrants.
Texas Governor Greg Abbott shared a video on social media this week showing President Joe Biden’s Border Patrol cutting razor wire that the state of Texas had placed alongside on the Rio Grande to stop illegal aliens from flooding into the country.
Mourners were joined by current and former politicians Monday for a somber ceremony marking the 22nd anniversary of the September 11, 2001, terror attacks.
Residents of the Village of Bald Head Island, a small community located off the coast of Brunswick County, are facing a substantial 21% tax hike as part of the recently approved budget by council.
A.I.-generated supermodels are turning heads and garnering millions of followers with their slim, lithe, fake bodies showing off fake bikinis and elegant, non-existent gowns.
No paper deeds leave your property rights at the mercy of the internet.
There is a growing push for legislation to bar wealthy foreign billionaires like Switzerland’s Hansjorg Wyss from pouring hundreds of millions of dollars in support of leftist causes in the United States


Back to Top