DHHS's Own Data Don’t Support Its Mask Mandate | Beaufort County Now | North Carolinians have been bound to this mandate for over 100 days but never truly got a clear answer on the state’s evidence for such an order. | john locke foundation, department of health and human services, DHHS, mask mandate, october 16, 2020

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

DHHS's Own Data Don’t Support Its Mask Mandate

Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Brenee Goforth.

    On June 24, Democrat Gov. Roy Cooper issued a statewide mask mandate. North Carolinians have been bound to this mandate for over 100 days but never truly got a clear answer on the state's evidence for such an order. Recently, Dr. S. Stanley Young, an EPA Scientific Advisory Board member and applied statistician, requested and analyzed the 'science and data' the governor and DHHS have been using to defend their mask mandate. Our Jon Sanders covered his findings in a recent research brief:

  • Young petitioned the NC Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) under state health bureaucrat Mandy Cohen for the oft-proclaimed "data and science" behind Gov. Roy Cooper's extraordinary order forcing face masks on healthy people...
  • Eventually, he heard back. What did he get?
  • "I presented my opinion to Dr. Cohen and her staff. After some prodding, I heard from Mr. Fleischman, a senior official on Mandy's staff. He provided me with another study that dealt specifically with the COVID-19 virus. Here is what I found.
  • The study he sent was a meta-analysis that looked at transmission of the virus. A total of 19 randomized studies were summarized. Here is what they had to say, 'Medical masks were not effective, and cloth masks even less effective.' They also noted that '....respirators, if worn continually during a shift, were effective but not if worn intermittently.'"

    Sanders comments:

  • Wait. DHHS's own case for forcing masks is based on a meta-analysis that finds masks are not even effective? That's even worse than what Cohen presented to the General Assembly just before the mask mandate — uncompelling research that, upon further review, wasn't even applicable to North Carolina.

    Sanders continues:

  • Maybe it also explains the recent CDC finding that 85% of symptomatic people testing positive for COVID-19 had always worn face coverings (70.6%) or often worn them (14.4%), with roughly the same proportion of symptomatic people testing negative (88.7% — always, 74.2%; often 14.5%).

    Read Sanders' research brief HERE. View Dr. Young's full comments HERE.


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Pot calling kettle black: Another example of the hypocrisy of the Left/Democrats
More and more school districts are making decisions not to return students to in-class instruction until early spring
Today, America's second Fake Impeachment of Donald J. Trump, just days before he leaves office, may speak more about those Impeaching the President than he who is indicted.
Former State Board of Elections Chairman Josh Howard says there could be dire consequences for future elections if the governor is allowed to appoint a judge to a newly created Wake County District Court seat.
Two banks that previously did business with President Donald Trump are cutting him off following the Jan. 6 riot in the U.S. Capitol.
Alan Jacobs’ new book, Breaking Bread with the Dead: A Reader’s Guide to a More Tranquil Mind, is a coaxing argument to read “old books that come from strange times.”
Hayden Ludwig writes for the Washington Free Beacon about a new method for left-of-center money men to bankroll their favorite political causes.

HbAD1

The Supreme Court struck a blow for good government Wednesday when it upheld Texas' restrictions on mail in ballots
Nearly a month after COVID-19 vaccines made it to North Carolina, the state has administered only a quarter of the doses it has on hand — one of the slowest roll-outs in the country.
Mark Zuckerberg of Facebook has now joined the ranks of those of us who have created moderated informational platforms that act as a hybrid publication.
The number of Republican lawmakers in the House who support impeaching President Donald Trump is growing, which could make the move just seven days before the president leaves office a bipartisan effort.
Christopher Bedford of the Federalist explores the political left’s attempt to turn last week’s disgusting Capitol attack for political gain.
COVID-19 and the ongoing fallout from the pandemic will likely dominate the 2021-22 session of the General Assembly.
Just a few months ago Democrats in Congress blocked a bill to condemn mob violence
Elite media fails to show the comparison between Capitol 1983 bombing and last week's demonstrations

HbAD2

North Carolina Republican Party Chairman Michael Whatley released the following statement in response to the impeachment vote in the House of Representatives
A Georgia man was arrested by the FBI in Washington D.C. this week after he was allegedly contemplating trying to assassinate House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA).
We will offer this allotment of three with more to come; some old, most new, but all quite informative, and, moreover, necessary to understanding that in North Carolina, there is a wiser path to govern ourselves and our People.
The Democrats may soon wish they did not play games with impeachment
In 2021, county boards of elections across North Carolina will conduct several important and required processes designed to keep the state’s voter rolls accurate and up to date.
A senior GOP aide said Tuesday that House Republicans are not whipping votes against impeachment.
Governor Roy Cooper has mobilized approximately 550 North Carolina National Guardsmen to assist with upcoming security needs in Washington, DC and North Carolina.
Does it ever get old? The never-ending wash, rinse, repeat cycle of liberals throwing out the race card every time they don’t like conservatives doing or not doing something, even when completely legal, normal and appropriate?

HbAD3

 
Back to Top