Cases Involving Barber, CON Await N.C. Court of Appeals in-Person Hearings | Beaufort County Now | Cases involving a high-profile political activist and a controversial state medical regulation await the N.C. Court of Appeals as it returns to regular in-person hearings this week.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Cases involving a high-profile political activist and a controversial state medical regulation await the N.C. Court of Appeals as it returns to regular in-person hearings this week.

    The state's second-highest court announced recently that it will resume its regular schedule of in-person oral arguments with the start of its fall session. Three-judge Appeals Court panels will begin hearing cases again Tuesday, Aug. 10.

    Among the first cases on the docket is an appeal in a 2017 trespass case involving the Rev. William Barber. Former head of the state NAACP and current co-chair of the activist Poor People's Campaign, Barber was arrested four years ago in connection with a protest at the state Legislative Building.

    Found guilty of second-degree trespass in 2019 and fined $200 and court costs, Barber continues to fight the conviction. Judges Chris Dillon, Lucy Inman, and Jeff Carpenter are scheduled to hear the case against Barber on Wednesday, Aug. 11.

    Another case heading to the N.C. Court of Appeals that week will shine light again on the state's controversial certificate-of-need law. That law forces N.C. health care providers to get state government's permission before adding new hospital beds, expanding facilities, or purchasing major medical equipment.

    The latest CON dispute stems from the destruction of a magnetic resonance imaging, MRI, scanner during a 2018 office relocation. State regulators allowed the MRI machine's owner, the Bone and Joint Surgery Clinic, to replace its broken scanner with upgraded equipment.

    But competitor Wake Radiology challenged the decision. Now Wake Radiology is fighting state regulators' later decision to allow Bone and Joint's newer MRI scanner to be used for more purposes than the original CON permitted.

    Judges Richard Dietz, Allegra Collins, and Fred Gore will wade through the complexities of CON law Tuesday.

    "The 15 judges of the Court of Appeals are looking forward to holding oral arguments in person in the fall," said Chief Judge Donna Stroud in a news release. "And although we are pleased to welcome attorneys, parties to cases, and the public back to our Court, we will also continue to use some innovations adopted due to the pandemic to the extent those innovations improve public access to the Court and improve the Court's operations."

    Starting in April 2021, the Court of Appeals heard most arguments by Webex, according to the release. The court began hearing some arguments in person in cases with parties requesting in-person arguments. Temporary safety measures in place during spring in-person hearings expired as of June 15.

    The court plans to maintain one major change adopted during the pandemic. All in-person and remote arguments moving forward will be recorded and livestreamed online, according to the news release.
Go Back


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

A city’s supposed attempt to make faces on a mural not “specifically identifiable” ended up depicting a black firefighter as white, and now she’s suing for defamation and negligence.
Many North Carolinians breathed a sigh of relief last week when the GOP-led legislature and Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper came to terms on a budget for the new biennium.
The North Carolina Court of Appeals on Monday morning issued an order temporarily suspending candidate filing for all U.S House of Representatives, N.C. Senate, and N.C. House contests.
Given the enormity of the public and private investment in US higher education, of course we should evaluate its effectiveness. But, how?
Ana Kasparian, a cohost of the popular progressive online news show “The Young Turks,” offered a strong defense of her debate with Daily Wire editor emeritus Ben Shapiro this week, calling out the Left for “platform scolding.”
Having trouble getting a hair appointment or other services? There are three bills sitting in the Senate Rules Committee that sponsors say would loosen bureaucratic red tape for some small service businesses.
New York City authorized two supervised injection sites to begin operating in Manhattan earlier this week, and on the first day, staff reversed two overdoses.


First, I want to thank Commissioner Hood Richardson for bringing Sheriff Coleman's out of control spending and abuse of the overtime budget line item to my attention.
Florida mom Quisha King received a standing ovation this week when she rebuffed the National School Boards Association (NSBA) and the Biden administration potentially cracking down on concerned individuals, including parents, who confront their local school boards.
New legislative election maps would give Republicans an advantage in the 2022 elections.
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments regarding a Mississippi abortion law that could change the abortion landscape in the United States, so naturally Democrats are out in force claiming certain Supreme Court justices are illegitimate and shouldn’t be allowed to decide the case.
I have been reading the current abortion case that has come out of the state of Mississippi and which was heard in oral argument in front of the Supreme Court on Dec. 1, 2021.
The Town of East Laurinburg’s charter hangs in the balance as the Local Government Commission recently voted unanimously to impound the town’s books and assume full control of its finances due to misappropriation of funds.
State workers in Nevada who are in enrolled in public employee healthcare plans will have to pay up to $55 more a month if they haven’t received the COVID-19 vaccine.


Back to Top