State Supreme Court will not hear Barber’s trespass appeal | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    Left-wing political activist the Rev. William Barber will not get his day at the N.C. Supreme Court. Justices at the state's highest court have turned down Barber's appeal of a 2019 conviction connected to a protest at the General Assembly.

    Lawyers for the N.C. Department of Justice had argued in February against the Supreme Court taking up Barber's appeal of a conviction for second-degree trespass. The conviction stemmed from the 2017 protest Barber led at the state Legislative Building.

    "Defendant is not raising new constitutional questions, nor is he presenting a matter significant to the jurisprudence of the State - he is reasserting the same fact-specific arguments" offered in previous court proceedings, according to a brief filed by Special Deputy Attorney General Michael Bulleri.

    Barber's 2019 conviction carried a $200 fine, court costs, 24 hours of community service, a suspended one-day prison sentence, and two months of unsupervised probation. A three-judge Appeals Court panel unanimously upheld the ruling against Barber in December 2021.

    Without a dissent from the Appeals Court, the Supreme Court faced no obligation to take Barber's case. The activist asked the high court to hear his plea under its "discretionary review."

    In May 2017 Barber "led a group of approximately 50 people in protesting at the Legislative Building in Raleigh, where they gathered, sat in the hallway outside the legislative leaders' offices and caused a disturbance by impeding access to and from offices, chanting, singing, yelling, and refusing to stop or leave after repeated warnings," according to the state's February brief.

    The group was protesting Republican legislative leaders' approach to health care policy.

    "Because Defendant [Barber] was the loudest member of the group, he was given several warnings to move, lower his voice, and stop leading the chants, otherwise he would be arrested," the brief added. "Defendant refused to move and instead, chanted louder and encouraged the crowd to continue chanting should he be arrested. Defendant refused [the] fourth and final request to leave the area and was placed under arrest."

    During his trial and in his appeals, Barber attacked the trespass charge on two fronts. First, he made procedural arguments against the way prosecutors charged him. Second, he argued that the arrest violated his First Amendment rights.

    Courts have rejected both sets of arguments. "[T]he Court of Appeals applied well-established precedent in correctly finding that this case is about Defendant's conduct - not his speech - and does not have constitutional implications," according to the state's brief.
Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




State Supreme Court agrees to take up felon voting case Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Despite the Timing, Intensive Community Policing Should Have Wide Appeal


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

It’s been well-documented that government-forced school shutdowns during the pandemic have contributed to learning loss among students.
A federal judge blocked a California law that allowed the state to punish doctors who shared alleged “misinformation” about COVID.
Good people everywhere want to see Ukraine defend itself against the brutal Russian invasion, but if the real goal of U.S. foreign policy is to oust Vladimir Putin, let’s hope the diplomats and spies have thought things through.
A national watchdog group lists U.S. Rep. Kathy Manning of North Carolina’s 6th congressional district as one of the top ethics violators in 2022.

HbAD1

Federal District Court nominee Charnelle Marie Bjelkengren appeared to struggle with the most basic of questions during her Thursday morning hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee, failing to recall the purpose of both Article V and Article II of the United States Constitution.
Scholars have uncovered new evidence showing that Pharaoh's infamous hanging of his chief baker was a result of discovering walnuts in his brownies.
Southwest Airlines reported a $220 million loss in the fourth quarter and warned investors that fallout from the company’s holiday meltdown would continue.
Two New York GOP leaders are calling for answers from the Biden administration over secretly transporting migrants across the U.S. after dozens of Columbian immigrants have moved to the upstate community of Jamestown.
The hard-Left Associated Press blared the “news” from the rooftops: “Pope says homosexuality not a crime,” screamed the headline on Wednesday.
In order to make the transition from singing to preaching more seamless, Grace Community Church has installed a trap door that the praise band will fall through as soon as they finish their worship set.
As the elitists of the World Economic Forum wrap up their 2023 meeting of the tyrannical minds, intellectual powerhouse Dennis Prager inspires wisdom over wokeness in his new DailyWire+ series “THE MASTER’S PROGRAM WITH DENNIS PRAGER.”

HbAD2

 
Back to Top