Folwell’s fight against hospitals extends to CON challenge at N.C. Supreme Court | Eastern North Carolina Now | N.C. State Treasurer Dale Folwell is urging the N.C. Supreme Court to take up a case challenging the state's certificate-of-need law.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    The latest chapter in N.C. State Treasurer Dale Folwell's feud with state hospitals involves a new friend-of-the-court brief at the state Supreme Court. Folwell supports a New Bern eye surgeon's challenge of state certificate-of-need restrictions.

    Dr. Jay Singleton is urging the state's highest court to take up his lawsuit against CON regulations. Folwell filed a brief Monday backing up Singleton's case.

    "The issue at the heart of this case - whether North Carolina's Certificate of Need law violates Article I, Sections 19, 32, and 34 of the North Carolina Constitution - is of significant public interest due to the harmful effects that illegal healthcare monopolies enabled by this law inflict on North Carolinians," wrote Benjamin Garner, Folwell's general counsel. "In theory, some argued, Certificate of Need laws would increase accessibility, quality, and affordability of healthcare services. In practice, however, Certificate of Need laws erect insurmountable regulatory barriers wielded by existing institutional healthcare entities to exclude others from entering the market."

    "Thus, Certificate of Need laws contribute to the creation of highly consolidated healthcare monopolies," Garner added. "In turn, these monopolies decrease the accessibility, quality, and affordability of healthcare while dramatically increasing their prices and excess revenues, all at the expense of North Carolinians. Determining whether the Certificate of Need law runs afoul of the North Carolina Constitution's protections against these types of harmful monopolies and special privileges is an issue of significant public interest justifying this Court's review."

    Folwell's brief explains how rising health care costs tied to CON could affect the State Health Plan, which serves 750,000 active and retired government employees. Folwell oversees the plan as state treasurer.

    "Rising healthcare costs ... pose a challenge to maintaining the solvency of the Plan and are a liability to taxpayers, who support the Plan through appropriations from the General Assembly," Garner wrote. "These appropriations grow at approximately four percent per year, but the Plan's costs continue to grow at approximately seven percent per year. Moreover, the Plan faces a $33.5 billion liability for retiree healthcare costs, with only $2.6 billion set aside from the General Assembly to cover that liability."

    "Thus, the healthcare monopolies maintained in part by the CON law are harming North Carolinians as consumers of healthcare and also as taxpayers."

    Singleton sued the state in 2020 because the CON law blocks him from performing most eye surgeries at his New Bern-based Singleton Vision Center. Singleton's patients instead must drive to CarolinaEast, a nearby hospital with the area's only state-approved CON.

    In his appeal, the doctor argues he "could provide eye surgeries at his facility for thousands of dollars less than those same procedures cost at CarolinaEast." CON restrictions stand in the way. "As a result, patients suffer while CarolinaEast profits,"

    The N.C. Court of Appeals dismissed Singleton's case on June 21. Because that decision was unanimous, the state Supreme Court faces no obligation to take the CON case.

    The John Locke Foundation, which oversees Carolina Journal, also has filed a friend-of-the-court brief supporting Singleton.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

New Bern eye surgeon urges N.C. Supreme Court to address certificate-of-need dispute Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Protest filed against Dem candidate for N.C. Senate


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

Netherlands is world's second largest exporter of food by value
A new poll shows that Republican voters put Florida Governor Ron DeSantis at the top of deep list of politicians they want to see influence the party’s direction.
Davis Patterson, a bystander during a shooting that left a dozen dead, has been arrested for misgendering the shooter, Blake Jacobson, who is non-binary.
Twitter CEO Elon Musk announced a blanket amnesty for Twitter users permanently suspended from the platform.
With rising interest rates, experts expect the U.K. to remain in a recession into 2024
CNN host Alisyn Camerota and a guest on the network struggled with the gender non-conforming identity of the Colorado “Club Q” shooting suspect.
U.S. State Department officials defended themselves Sunday after awarding Ecuador a grant of over $20,000 for a cultural center to host drag shows for LGBTQ communities in the South American country.
The N.C. Home Builders Association is sharing its concerns about a recent court ruling against an Ashe County asphalt plant.


says schools are for education, not indoctrination
Former Trump administration economic adviser Larry Kudlow blasted President Joe Biden, accusing him of lying about the state of the economy.
President Joe Biden announced his intention to push for new gun control legislation in the lame-duck session of Congress.
Wondering why people actually still vote for Democrats? Believe it or not, there are still Democrat voters out there and we've compiled their top reasons for doing so!
Two NBA players were ejected from a game over the weekend after they engaged in a fight that ended up in the stands.
When I was a tenth grade student, I had the good fortune to have an English teacher named MS. Comer.
While Arizona’s handling of the midterm election has been the focus of media outlets and pundits for some time, California still has more than 250,000 uncounted ballots across the state.
At least two counties in Arizona have confirmed that their certification of the 2022 election will be delayed as the state’s attorney general’s office wrote a letter claiming there’s evidence of “statutory violations” that occurred in Maricopa County on Election Day.


Back to Top