State Treasurer sides with the plaintiff in Certificate of Need case | Eastern North Carolina Now | CON is a racket to inflate health care costs

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)

The North State Journal is reporting:

North Carolina State Treasurer Dale Folwell has submitted an amicus curiae brief in the current lawsuit involving Certificate of Need (CON) laws in the state. 

“As ‘keeper of the public purse’ and having responsibility for 750,000 members of the State Health Plan, I felt it was my duty to become part of Dr. Singleton’s lawsuit,” Folwell said in a press release. 

 “We spend $4 billion a year of taxpayer’s money providing medical and pharmaceutical coverage for those that teach, protect and otherwise serve the people of this state,” said Folwell. “CON laws are exactly what they sound like – a CON. Every year the hospital cartel, through the North Carolina Healthcare Association, prevents any meaningful change to CON laws. Now, we must go through the courts to achieve that change.” 

Folwell’s filing, submitted on Aug. 15, asserts that the CON law violates Article I, Sections 19, 32, and 34 of the North Carolina Constitution and creates an uneven playing field that protects existing large health care providers.  

According to a press release, the lawsuit was filed Dr. Jay Singleton, a New Bern eye surgeon who challenged the state’s CON law that requires him to secure a government-issued certificate of need before he can perform most eye surgeries at his vision center. 

The CON law forces Dr. Singleton to perform most surgeries at New Bern’s Carolina East Medical Center at significantly higher costs to the patient. His lawsuit contends that the CON law violates three sections of the North Carolina Constitution, the statement says.  

Singleton’s lawsuit was dismissed in a unanimous decision by a three-judge panel of the N.C. Court of Appeals that led Singleton to unsuccessfully petition the court to rehear the case. Singleton has since filed a request with the Supreme Court of North Carolina to take up the case.  

Per N.C. Department of Health and Human Services (NCDHHS) description, North Carolina’s CON law “prohibits health care providers from acquiring, replacing, or adding to their facilities and equipment, except in specified circumstances, without the prior approval of the Department of Health and Human Services.” 

Additionally, NCDHHS says the CON law also requires “prior approval” for the “initiation of certain medical services” and CON law “restricts unnecessary increases in health care costs and limits unnecessary health services and facilities based on geographic, demographic and economic considerations.” 

According to Folwell’s statement, the supposed purpose of CON regulation is to “limit spending and cost by discouraging providers from acquiring unnecessary medical equipment. However, studies show CON laws protect incumbent providers from competition rather than protecting patients and payers from unnecessary costs.”

Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )


( August 30th, 2022 @ 8:44 pm )
When I served as a political appointee in the administration of Governor Jim Martin, I worked in the department that oversaw Certificates of Need, and CON is an appropriate abbreviation for them. The preceding Democrat Jim Hunt administration had sold CONs in return for political contributions. It was a totally corrupt system, and one that the Martin administration tried to correct by setting objective standards to receive a CON instead of a political contribution. Since Hunt came back for 8 years after Martin, I have no doubt that the system was reverted back to its old corrupt ways.

I actually got telephone calls while I was serving as the Department's General Counsel where hospital attorneys would ask where the political contributions needed to be sent to secure a CON and how much it should be. I told them that political contributions were not required or accepted and if they wanted to win the CON, they should work on sending in the best application instead.

The CON arrangement encourages corruption and has needed to be abolished for a long time. During the Martin administration, we never had any luck convincing a Democrat controlled legislature of that, however.
( August 30th, 2022 @ 12:10 pm )
This is a long overdue fight. I understand that this CON was originally set up by Rest Homes for protection against competition. The hospitals grabbed on to this good idea to protect them so they can set up monopolies in certain regions. We have that in Eastern Carolina. With competition your health care cost would go down.

Wharton study: Biden tuition debt forgiveness could hit $1 trillion Editorials, Beaufort Observer, Op-Ed & Politics Great new ad on Biden student loan boondoggle


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

"...everything that defines us is now an enemy for those who would like us to no longer have an identity and to simply be perfect consumer slaves."
During a camping retreat this week to recharge for more rioting before, during, and after the midterm elections, a group of progressives sat around a campfire and enjoyed swapping scary stories about climate change.
Mortgage rates are approaching 7% as the housing market continues to experience turmoil.
According to a Reuters report, tweets soliciting child sex abuse material have appeared alongside or on profile pages of at least 30 major advertisers’ Twitter accounts. Some of those companies are now pulling their ad services off the social media platform.


‘Gravest technological threat’ to liberty
A local couple is in shock today after a startling visit from Rightful Georgia Governor® Stacey Abrams. According to sources, the couple was listening to the heartbeat of their child on a sonogram for the very first time when Abrams burst through the wall like the Kool-Aid man
Have you ever seen former New England Patriots star Julian Edelman’s unbelievable catch as part of the team’s 25-point comeback in Super Bowl 51? It undoubtedly took “great skill” and “good luck” — thanks, in large part, to his years of practice and determination.
Earlier this year, I wrote how former congressman and Trump administration chief of staff Mark Meadows may have committed voter registration fraud in North Carolina.
“The Chosen” creator Dallas Jenkins recently spoke to The Daily Wire about the uses of social media and if he thinks Jesus would’ve used it, had it been available in first century Galilee, to spread his message.
Matt Walsh is once again stirring up controversy after he shared pictures of Nazi death camps on his Twitter account with the words "We must never let this kind of evil happen ever again."


More than 2.5 million businesses and homes in Florida were left without power in the aftermath of Hurricane Ian on Thursday morning as utility companies work to repair the state’s electrical grid.


Back to Top