Legislators urge federal judge to toss out unaffiliated voters’ election lawsuit | Eastern North Carolina Now | Top legislative leaders urge U.S. District Judge William Osteen to dismiss a lawsuit from unaffiliated voters. It challenges a state law limiting membership on the State Board of Elections to Democrats and Republicans.

Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    North Carolina's top legislative leaders believe a federal judge should dismiss a lawsuit that aims to add unaffiliated voters to the state's elections board.

    House Speaker Tim Moore, R-Cleveland, and Senate leader Phil Berger, R-Rockingham, filed a motion Friday to dismiss the case Common Cause v. Moore.

    Left-of-center activist group Common Cause and five individual unaffiliated voters are challenging a state law, N.C. Gen. Stat. § 163-19. It dictates the terms of state elections board membership. The governor appoints the five-member board, based on recommendations from the two major parties. The governor's party exercises a 3-2 majority.

    "Plaintiffs argue that by not allowing unaffiliated voters to serve on the State Board, their First Amendment and Equal Protection rights are violated. However, these Plaintiffs lack standing to bring those claims," wrote legislators' attorneys. "And Defendants, members of the legislative branch, who enact but do not enforce laws, are immune from suit for such claims in federal court."

    "Even if Plaintiffs could overcome these issues, the federal constitution does not support such associational claims, and, these claims run headlong into the North Carolina Constitution, which has been interpreted by North Carolina courts to require that the Governor be able to control the State Board of Elections," according to lawmakers' court filing.

    "Counterbalancing one major party's views and priorities on the State Board with that of the other major party's views, therefore, is a rational approach to election administration adopted by numerous other states," legislative leaders argued.

    Lawmakers remind U.S. District Judge William Osteen that the General Assembly tried to create a state elections board with an even number of Democrats and Republicans. Gov. Roy Cooper sued to block the change. Cooper won in court.

    Lawmakers then approved a nine-member elections board with four Democrats, four Republicans, and an unaffiliated ninth member.

    "The Governor then sued again, arguing that the 4-4-1 political makeup of the Board also violated the separation of powers doctrine in our state Constitution by preventing him, as chief executive, from controlling the views and priorities of the State Board," according to legislators' memorandum. "A three-judge superior court panel agreed. ... Following this decision, the General Assembly returned the administrative structure of elections, ethics, and lobbying to the 2016 structure."

    That 2016 structure includes the five-member elections board limited to the two major parties.

    The Common Cause suit filed Aug. 2 asks a federal court to declare the elections board law "unconstitutional and void." Common Cause also asks the court to block the General Assembly from enacting any new law for state elections board appointments that "discriminates against unaffiliated voters or penalizes them based on their decisions not to register as Republican[s] or Democrats."

    More than 2.57 million North Carolinians were registered as unaffiliated when Common Cause filed suit. More voters were registered as unaffiliated than as Democrats (2.49 million) or Republicans (2.21 million). Unaffiliated voters make up the largest voting group in 19 of North Carolina's 100 counties, according to the original complaint.

    "The state law barring plaintiffs and all other unaffiliated voters from serving on the State Board serves no public or valid purpose but instead is a means to entrench the Democratic and Republican political parties in power and give them exclusive control over the supervision, management, and administration of the elections system," according to Common Cause's complaint. "This law is ill-conceived because it renders ineligible a large pool of talented and able citizens from service on the State Board."

    Osteen has not said when he will address legislators' motion to dismiss the case.

poll#147
Do you consider Election Integrity an issue of some real importance, or just another conspiracy theory interfering with Democratic Socialist political hegemony?
  No, complete access to everyone voting, even in a willy nilly manner, is more important than getting it right by limiting access to those that would commit Voter Fraud.
  Yes, the most inalienable right of real citizens of this Democratic Republic is the Right to Vote, and that right shall remain sacrosanct for perpetuity.
  Again, I don't vote and I don't care.
649 total vote(s)     What's your Opinion?


poll#154
Inarguably, the policies of the Democrats in congress and Joe Biden as the Executive is plunging the United States into a recession, if we are not already there; a recession that was completely avoidable. Will abrupt changes in policies occur in time?
  Yes, the Democrats have a bold plan, yet to be revealed, to save us.
  No, there will have to be a complete undoing of the damage done by these Democrats.
  I can't do simple math, so how am I to understand the concept of basic economics.
1,181 total vote(s)     What's your Opinion?

Go Back


Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )




Locke urges U.S. Supreme Court to protect charter schools’ independence Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Republicans hope ‘red wave’ extends to school board races


HbAD0

Latest Op-Ed & Politics

We trust our readers to make their own conclusions. We'd love to hear what you think
A spokesman for Santa's Workshop today announced the organization's latest advance in their ongoing efforts to determine who's naughty and who's nice
demands federal government pays it to all, costing billions
Vice President Kamala Harris is spearheading a White House initiative to electrify the nation’s school buses, the administration announced Wednesday.
politization of leadership is biggest public concern
Twitter CEO Elon Musk said Monday that he will soon be releasing files on how the social media platform has engaged in suppressing free speech.
In the age of wokeness, ideological (re)education trumps mission-preparedness.
A new book alleges that after Ted Kennedy left his car and his passenger, Mary Jo Kopechne, in a pond off of Chappaquiddick Island, where Kopechne drowned, he returned to the party they had attended and told his close friends he wanted to say Kopechne was driving the car.
Hawaii’s largest active volcano began erupting Sunday night, with lava flow warnings issued to the surrounding area.

HbAD1

 
Back to Top