Former Justice Bob Orr Puts His Thumb on the Scale for Congressional Democrats | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the John Locke Foundation. The author of this post is Jim Stirling.

    With election upon us, the constant stream of campaign ads that most of us cannot seem to get away from has only steadily increased. While it is easy to tune these ads out, a judicial endorsement ad from Cheri Beasley caught my attention. The former supreme court chief justice has several current and prior judges coming out to endorse her for U.S. senate. The most notable of those is former Republican turned independent judge Bob Orr. Orr recently served as one of three special masters in a recent controversial court redraw of North Carolina's Congressional maps.

    While Orr served on the North Carolina Supreme Court in years past, he is now better known for his recent activism in state politics and his moniker as the 'independent of the three special masters' who drew our current congressional map. Orr is registered as an independent, but he clearly has a party preference. He donated solely to Democrats in federal elections in 2022 and endorsed Democratic candidates Cheri Beasley & congressional district 13 candidate Wiley Nickel (D) in the two closest federal elections in North Carolina. However, his support of a candidate running in a district he helped draw is a concern.

    The façade Orr has created as being even-handed and independent falls apart with even the slightest bit of examination into his endorsement and candidate preferences. Orr has also been a financial backer of Jeff Jackson, the former U.S. Senate Candidate in the Democratic primary. Jackson coincidentally found himself in a democratic-leaning congressional district that seems almost hand-crafted for him once he dropped out of the senate race.

    Orr's endorsement of Nickel in North Carolina's most contested congressional seat and the timing of Jeff Jackson's being granted the almost ideal district calls into question if Orr put his weight on the scales for his preferred candidates or party when drawing the maps. The maps have been questionable in their design. Orr and the other special masters created seven Republican seats, six Democratic seats, and one toss-up seat. This is something that even the plaintiff's witnesses in the redistricting case Orr was involved in said was statistically unlikely, showing Republicans who likely receive nine or eight seats favoring them under politically neutral criteria. The likelihood of Republicans having an advantage in seven congressional districts or less happened only 5.3% of the time (see Figure 1).

    Figure 1: Likelihood of North Carolina congressional map outcomes by Dr. Jowei Chen. The chart is on page 33 of Chen's report.

    Orr has been heavily involved in shaping this year's congressional elections. Both as a court-appointed judge in the redrawing of congressional districts and as a public figure endorsing candidates in key elections. He all but disavowed Republicans when he left the Republican Party in 2021. His throwing endorsement and money behind candidates running in districts he drew calls into question his neutrality when designing those districts.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Red tide in New Hanover as GOP wins all 4 school board seats Statewide, John Locke Foundation Guest Editorial, Editorials, Government, Op-Ed & Politics, State and Federal What Early and Mail Voting Data Tell Us about the 2022 Election


Latest State and Federal

If an academic field gets politicized, consider looking to its professional overseers.
North Carolina’s State Auditor Beth Wood released a statement Jan. 23 apologizing for a hit-and-run accident in December that resulted in her state-owned vehicle partially sitting atop another parked car.
So-called “antiracists” typically advocate greater government intervention to combat racism
Rep. Ben Moss, R-Richmond, called for re-evaluating the “antiquated” county tier system, a system that ranks N.C.’s counties based on several economic factors, in his legislative agenda released on Tuesday.
The United States Department of Defense has begun implementing name changes for military installations across the country, including North Carolina’s Fort Bragg, which will now be known as Fort Liberty.
N.C. legislative leaders hope the state Supreme Court will hold a new hearing in the Harper v. Hall redistricting case.
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) claimed that the tax cuts passed under former President Donald Trump have been the “largest contributor” to federal budget deficits over the past few years rather than the spending agenda enacted by President Joe Biden.
The North Carolina Department of Transportation has replenished the state’s Highway Trust Fund (HTF) with $1.1 billion — two years ahead of schedule.
Career and Technical Education programs in public schools across North Carolina are getting a boost in the form of $3 million in new funding for 2022, announced Jan. 17 by Superintendent of Public Instruction Catherine Truitt.


Hundreds of people in North Carolina each day are waiting inside hospital emergency departments for behavioral health care.
A video from N.C. Attorney General Josh Stein Wednesday morning confirms his plan to run for governor in 2024.
Voting is now open in UScellular’s ninth Annual Black History Month Art Contest with Boys & Girls Clubs of the Coastal Plain Washington Unit.
A national watchdog group lists U.S. Rep. Kathy Manning of North Carolina’s 6th congressional district as one of the top ethics violators in 2022.
On April 1, 2023, approximately 55,000 children receiving NC Health Choice coverage will move to NC Medicaid and begin receiving additional physical and behavioral health services. This change will help save families money and increase access to care.
A unanimous N.C. Court of Appeals panel has ruled that University of North Carolina System students cannot sue for partial refunds of tuition and fees paid for the spring 2020 semester.
The State Board of Elections is considering adoption of a Campaign Finance Settlement Policy to resolve disputes over campaign finance civil penalties involving unlawful campaign contributions and expenditures.
Last year North Carolina Governor Roy Cooper raised a lot of eyebrows when he issued a proclamation celebrating January 23rd to 29th 2022, as School Choice Week in North Carolina.


Back to Top