Lawmakers make case against suit for unaffiliated elections board members | Eastern North Carolina Now

    Publisher's Note: This post appears here courtesy of the Carolina Journal. The author of this post is CJ Staff.

    N.C. legislative leaders have submitted their final written arguments against a lawsuit that would give unaffiliated voters a right to sit on the state elections board. Lawmakers are asking U.S. District Judge William Osteen to dismiss the case.

    Left-of-center activist group Common Cause and five unaffiliated voters are pursuing the lawsuit. They argue that the current structure of the State Board of Elections discriminates against voters who refuse to register as Democrats or Republicans. The current five-member board features three members from the governor's party and two members from the other major party.

    Legislative leaders contend that the plaintiffs lack legal standing to bring the lawsuit. "The crux of Plaintiffs' argument regarding standing is that Plaintiffs are interested in service and willing to serve. However, the desire to see themselves or other unaffiliated registered voters serve on the North Carolina Board of Elections is not a sufficiently particularized injury to convey standing," wrote attorney Martin Warf, representing legislative leaders.

    "Plaintiffs argue that they have demonstrated standing by having a willingness to serve and the qualifications to do so," Warf added. "The criteria for service on the North Carolina Board of Elections are not measured in years of dedicated service, but instead, in conditions about one's service in active elections and electioneering campaigns - with gubernatorial appointments limited to those people who affiliate with one of the two highest political parties. Millions of North Carolinians meet these criteria; therefore, qualifications for service are not as select as Plaintiffs make them out to be."

    "The core of Defendants' argument though, is that Plaintiffs cannot meet their individualized burden of showing a concrete, particularized injury beyond the assertion that a grievance is suffered by all North Carolinians who might think it best to have unaffiliated voters on boards of elections," Warf wrote.

    Lawmakers also argue that sovereign immunity blocks the lawsuit. Plus they say Common Cause and its allies mischaracterize the nature of their complaint.

    "Plaintiffs' insistence that this case is about the right to vote is erroneous," Warf wrote. "This is not a case about the right to vote; it is a case about whether Plaintiffs have a constitutional right to serve in public office. They do not."

    The Common Cause v. Moore suit filed Aug. 2 asks a federal court to declare the elections board law -N.C. Gen. Stat. § 163-19 - "unconstitutional and void." Common Cause also asks the court to block the General Assembly from enacting any new law for state elections board appointments that "discriminates against unaffiliated voters or penalizes them based on their decisions not to register as Republican[s] or Democrats."

    More than 2.57 million North Carolinians were registered as unaffiliated when Common Cause filed suit. More voters were registered as unaffiliated than as Democrats (2.49 million) or Republicans (2.21 million). Unaffiliated voters made up the largest voting group in 19 of North Carolina's 100 counties, according to the original complaint.

    "The state law barring plaintiffs and all other unaffiliated voters from serving on the State Board serves no public or valid purpose but instead is a means to entrench the Democratic and Republican political parties in power and give them exclusive control over the supervision, management, and administration of the elections system," according to Common Cause's complaint. "This law is ill-conceived because it renders ineligible a large pool of talented and able citizens from service on the State Board."

    There is no deadline for Osteen to decide whether the suit can move forward.
Go Back

Leave a Guest Comment

Your Name or Alias
Your Email Address ( your email address will not be published)
Enter Your Comment ( no code or urls allowed, text only please )

Happy 233rd Birthday Old North State! Carolina Journal, Editorials, Op-Ed & Politics Bidens serve “Friendsgiving” meal at MCAS Cherry Point


Latest Op-Ed & Politics

New business creation filings grew 40% in 2021 over 2020, for a total of 178,300 new businesses in the state.
more leftist ideological dogma from company selected by BCS superintendant
The Penn Biden Center, a Washington think tank where classified documents were found in November, hosted an event encouraging deeper U.S.-China ties.
shift of ten percentage points from traditional conservatives in Lower Austria
University of Richmond changes name of law school, family demands $51 million back
A federal agency under the Biden Administration walked back comments it made earlier in the week that it was considering a ban on gas stoves in new construction or as a replacement product, citing concerns that the appliances may cause a rise in respiratory illnesses.
On Monday, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) announced that a North Korea-associated hacking group had carried out a robbery of $100 million in cryptocurrency last year.


Theologians at the Claremont School of Theology put forward additional evidence that God has a sense of humor by pointing out that 1 out of every 20 pistachios tastes like flaming hot garbage.
Indiana taxpayers shelled out more than $100,000 to 1619 Project author Nikole Hannah-Jones for just over 24 hours of work, according to a contract obtained by The Daily Wire under public records laws.
There are several problems with ballot marking devices such as the one Buncombe County is considering.
Rep. George Santos (R-NY) is a world-class liar. He has told baldfaced lies about nearly everything — from being Jewish to (for some reason) leading the Baruch College volleyball team to wins over Harvard and Yale.
We all want what's best for our children. That's why it's important to educate them early on how to deny gender normativity and embrace dysphoria. What will people think if your child becomes a "normie?" That would be the worst!
According to a poll from late 2022, 50% of Americans trust the FBI either “hardly ever” or “some of the time.”
Former President Donald Trump defended his former vice president on Tuesday after news broke that classified documents had been found at Mike Pence’s home in Indiana.
A prosecutor in Georgia requested the findings of a special grand jury investigating whether former President Donald Trump and his allies illegally interfered in the 2020 election not be released as charges are considered.
In an incident some have labeled the Ukraine-Russia War's "Christmas Truce," Ukrainian and Russian soldiers have paused their fighting to capture a photo of their adorable matching American tanks.


Back to Top